Best steel for what?
I am just learning about steel. I have recently come across CPM 3V. If I can believe what I read, this stuff is just about the best steel there is...assuming it is heat treated correctly. Now I know it is hard to work with and hard to heat treat but once done, as a user, there sounds like none better.
Is this the Holy Grail of Steel? Is there none better? Does it do everything well up to an include hold of rust to some degree (not being a stainless steel technically)?
Best steel for what?
If you want to call something 'best' in its category, you need a list of criteria for this. Why is CPM-3V the best steel for you? If you want toughness, you might be spot-on.
Well that's where I am going. Folks seem to think it is best period...no criteria necessary. That is why I made this post. Maybe I am reading stuff from the chopping folks? The competion cutter types? Hard core bushcrafting?
Bushcrafting is going to be where I would come in. Koster makes one.
So let's say bushcrafting.
Ok. I appreciate the input. And I understand the skepticism with which my post was viewed. And that is where I was coming from. Surely, there is no "magic steel"...and this is not it. It does sound like a very tough customer though.
It also has wear resistance similar to D2 and a decent level of corrosion resistance.
it's a very good alloy for large blades. even small knives at 59r.r. are better than s30 according to the english catra tests. i'm not sure that some of the old carbon steels tweaked by a good custom maker might not equal it for lots less money. siegle uses 5160 in his for phenmonal results.[this is a very expensive alloy]
Small knives, you say?
* Overall Length: 7 Inches
* Blade Length: 3.250 Inches
* Blade Steel: CPM3V @ 58rc
* Blade Thickness: .150 Inch
* Weight: 3.750 Ounces
Here's an interesting side note from Mike that speaks to the difficulty in working with CPM 3V: "These knives, because of the highly abrasion resistant steel, are finished with a 320 finish rather than the standard 600 finish on the blade. You WILL notice grinding marks in the blade. We did this intentionally to keep the price of the knife at a reasonable level."
Last edited by bld522; 11-19-2010 at 09:46 AM.
I might say 3V is the best steel for a large blade or something you intend to beat the crap out of. Insane toughness, but the edge holding is relatively low. Thats not to say it can't hold an edge. It takes and holds a great edge, just not on par with some other expensive and difficult steels (think M4, 10V, S90V, 15V).
But to say its the "best" even in a particular category, no way. What defines the "best" is always going to be up for debate here.
CPM-3V: This grade provides some of the best combination of properties. It is very tough providing better toughness than all of the grades listed here with the exception of CPM® 1V®. It has very good wear resistance, about 50% better than D-2 and can be hardened to RC 56-60. It holds an edge very well, it is fairly easy to fabricate and sharpen due to it's relatively low alloy content. CPM® 3V® is not very good at corrosion resistance. The cost of CPM® 3V® is about the same as CPM® 1V® and is readily available in thin sheet stock.
IMHO, 58HRC for that knife of that size(3.5" lil' Canadian) is a lot of wasted edge holding potential. Obviously that knife is a light cutter, you won't be chopping or prying with it.
Good question. I'm not sure. Nor do I have personal experience using 3V. Everything I've read, however, seems to indicate that 3V has excellent wear resistance, especially for being such a tough alloy.
I'd say the big kids on the block right now are 3V for tool steel and CPM-154 for stainless. I don't have knives in either one at the moment. But they're both on my wish list.
Here's more info on 3V for those who may be interested:
Last edited by bld522; 11-19-2010 at 12:22 PM.
I too thought of CPM 3V as mainly big knife steel, but at some point I discussed with Phil Wilson possibility of CPM 3V at max hardness, and he made experimental CPM 3V knife for me.
Can't say it's pretty, but I have myself to blame for the design Anyway, as far as light/medium cutting goes it's a superb performer and I'd put it against D2, 154CM etc any time.
3V is awesome stuff... But it excels when you use the right geometry.
Paper thin blade with a high RC (like 60-62) in a small blade is Simply amazing...
thickness < 1/4 on a chopper with a zero convex at RC 60... light saber!!
It's great stuff but you need to find a custom maker who is wiling to work with it and has experience with HTing it...
Since I don't get much opportunity to chop things, toughness isn't what I'm looking for. CPM-3V isn't much more than a slightly harder S30V due to my uses(mostly slicing and cutting) and roughly the same level of wear resistance. I find CPM-M4 to be closer to perfection with high hardness and a good volume of small carbides.
There are currently 3 users browsing this thread. (1 members and 2 guests)