Great looking rotation IMO. I like that AG especially since I am a nut for stag. The Case that Keith gifted you is an all around great EDC IMO. The Case, to me, is the kind of knife that can go anywhere. It has a classy look with the black handles, the serpintene frame that I consider an absolute hall of fame classic, and a small and large blade. I would be proud to EDC both of those, but I can really understand your appreciation of the gift from Keith. Somewhat of a sentimental, it happens for a reason guy, I would feel similar
As for myself, and for conversations sake, I stick to one at a time. I feel like I can focus on keeping up one knife better then a small rotation. So I keep all my knives, even my users, clean and protected in storage. I keep one as my current EDC that I focus my attention on. I could spend time working little kinks out, sharpening until the blades are just how I like them and so on.
Right now my current is a 57 clip point stag whittler. Im adjusting to a smaller blade then my 85 single blade spear easy open, but its nice to make a change.