Results 1 to 15 of 15

Thread: Polishing Compound In Relation To Grit Size?

  1. Polishing Compound In Relation To Grit Size?


    ADVERTISEMENT
    If black & green polishing compound had a grit size what would it be? I've seen some videos where people sharpen their knives through a multitude of stones and then through a multitude of strops with different compounds. Now if the black compound has a "grit value" of the same as the first stone he used, wouldn't that be like starting over? So my question is, how much grits does green and black compound have? I know they are measure in microns or something but I don't understand that. Any help?

  2. #2
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Location
    Wenatchee, WA
    Posts
    1,073
    The problem with that particular question, HTM, is that it's like asking "What gas mileage does a Ford get?" Valid question, but needs a bit more information to be answerable.

    There are a LOT of compounds, and they're all different. Every maker has a different formulation, and one maker's "black" compound is going to be very different than another's.
    Last edited by Komitadjie; 05-23-2012 at 09:38 AM. Reason: Grammar FAIL.

  3. #3
    Some polishing compounds use friable abrasive. This means that as you use the abrasive, it breaks down into smaller and smaller particles. I could be wrong, but I think Flitz and/or Simichrome use friable aluminum oxide? If so, that makes it really difficult to determining the grit of the polish. Not all polishes are friable, though, so for non-friable polishes, it may be easier (although often still unclear) how to estimate a grit size.

    The whole question of what is grit size, turns out to be surprisingly complicated. First of all, any compound or abrasive has a range (histogram/distribution) of grain sizes, so a single number cannot accurately characterize it. Typically, all that is posted is the d50 number, which is the median grain size where the median is calculated with respect to the total weight (ie: half of the weight of the sample is made up of particles smaller than X, the other half of the weight of the sample is made up of particles larger than X). Next, a lot of other effects could be in play: the shape of the particles (round and smooth, or sharp and blocky), whether or not the abrasive if friable (breaks down into smaller particlse), and hardness and type of abrasive (diamond, or SiC, or aluminum oxide...).

    So far I haven't seen a complete solution to the huge variation of what a grit number "means". The best I've seen is Komitadjie's Grand Unified Grit Chart. Short of that, the other thing is experience; various people saying,"In my experience, compound A from company B seems similar to a grit number of C for company D." I wish it weren't so complicated.

    Sincerely,
    --Lagrangian

    P.S. More about the details of what grit numbers actually mean (and don't mean):
    http://www.uama.org/Abrasives101/101Standards.html
    Last edited by Lagrangian; 05-23-2012 at 10:01 AM.

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Upstate, NY
    Posts
    3,382
    Another thought to consider - the use of an abrasive on a backing with any amount of give to it will dramatically reduce the "effective" grit value. I did a few tests using the abrasive taken from a waterstone to finish the ground edge off the same stone. I applied it to some newspaper and used it as a strop - the scratch pattern was a fraction of what the same abrasive produced while embedded in a solid binder.

    I have some 600 grit silicon carbide powder that, when applied to firm leather, can improve the scratch pattern following 1200 grit sandpaper.

    There's a multitude of variables when it comes to stropping, any change to the density of the backing, how much metal swarf is mixed with the compound over time, the abrasive breaking down, small changes in pressure and angle....

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Apr 2009
    Location
    New Mexico, USA
    Posts
    7,938
    Lots of good input already, in here. ^

    As mentioned, there's a huge variety in what's known as 'black' or 'white' compounds, in particular. Very wide range of grit sizes for each, and at least with 'white' compounds, many aren't even of the same abrasive type. Many are aluminum oxide, some might even be talc (softest material on the Moh's scale). There's even a compound known as 'white diamond', which has no diamond and no aluminum oxide. It's tin oxide. Most 'green' compound is comprised of chromium oxide at pretty small grit size (at least less than 1 micron, with many averaging ~0.5 micron). Some 'green' chromium oxide compounds are mixed with other abrasives, like aluminum oxide.

    Silicon carbide (black) is friable, so it fractures into smaller, but still very sharp and aggressive particles. Some, but not all aluminum oxide is friable. Individual processes used to create the stuff will make big differences in how each behaves. I don't know whether Flitz/Simichrome uses friable AlOx, but I hope they do (at that level of polish, that just means it gets even better). The aluminum oxide used in Spyderco's ceramics is of the same fixed grit size, even across all of their ceramic 'grit' specs. Their finishing process is what makes the 'effective grit' different for each. The abrasive itself doesn't change or break down with use.

    The substrate (backing) used with the compound is a huge variable. One can take a single compound of fixed type and size, and apply it to soft, thick leather (less aggressive), firm or thin leather (more aggressive), balsa wood (even more aggressive), and then on hardwood (more, more, more so). Look at the 'black stuff' (metal) removed from the blade and left on the strop in each case, and you can easily see the difference in performance. Sort of like comparing the feeling of pebbles under your bare feet, if you walk on them on thick, deep carpet, or on bare concrete. One way is going to dig a lot deeper and hurt a lot more, depending on the 'cushion' underneath.

    Long story short, the only consistent way to know a particular compound is to try it out, and see how it performs. It does help greatly to know the exact type and size of the abrasive starting out, but many manufacturers don't specify such details. And many dealers/vendors may not even know.

  6. Thanks for the major headache guys. Lol

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Apr 2009
    Location
    New Mexico, USA
    Posts
    7,938
    Quote Originally Posted by HeavyTakeMusic View Post
    Thanks for the major headache guys. Lol
    Clear as mud, right?

    For just starting out, you might try just some Simichrome or Flitz, or the reputable diamond compounds (DMT, Hand American) are much more consistent and predictable, too. I like Simichrome, and often use it on one of my strops. I don't doubt Flitz is also good; many here seem to like it also. So many of the generic bar/stick compounds are just too unpredictable, until you've actually used them for a while, and can figure out where they 'fit' in a stropping/polishing sequence.

    Good luck.

  8. #8
    I use some Lee Valley green Honing Compound. It's a mixture of chromium-oxide and aluminum-oxide that is designed to have a scratch size of about 0.5 mircons. I found this to be okay, but for getting a polish, I tend to like 0.5 micron diamond paste, which seemed to me to work faster and give a more mirror-like polish. The diamond paste is rated at 0.5 microns, and I bought it at McMaster.com.
    http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/pag...84&cat=1,43072
    http://www.mcmaster.com/#polishing-compounds/=hnt9fa

    If you want stropping compounds of a known size, you might also check out some of these at chefknivestogo.com that have micron ratings. These probably also polish given how fine they are, but I haven't had a lot of experience with them. I own some of Ken Schwartz's CBN, but have not yet had a chance to really test it (Ken's stuff is strongly recommended in knifeforums.com). A lot of people here really like Hand American's green chromium oxide semi-paste, and also the boron carbide semi-paste.
    http://www.chefknivestogo.com/handamerican.html
    http://www.chefknivestogo.com/kenscorner.html

    Flitz and Simichrome are also popular polishes.

    Sincerely,
    --Lagrangian

    P.S. For reference: Visible light has a wavelength of 0.4 to 0.7 microns. So if your scratches start getting smaller than about 0.2 microns, you are into the optically smooth realm. Probably a an abrasive particle will make a scratch much smaller than it's diameter, especially if it is on a soft surface like strop. Prof. Verhoeven looked at modern razor blades, and found that they are sharp to about 0.4 microns as well. This may give you some guidance on grits for polishing. For coarser grits, you might check out Komitadjie's Grand Unified Grit Chart which is a sticky in this forum.
    Last edited by Lagrangian; 05-23-2012 at 07:23 PM. Reason: Clarified some points in the P.S.

  9. can someone direct me to some diamond paste. i can seem to find it online. does it look like a polishing bar or does this come in a tube or can?

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Apr 2009
    Location
    New Mexico, USA
    Posts
    7,938
    Quote Originally Posted by HeavyTakeMusic View Post
    can someone direct me to some diamond paste. i can seem to find it online. does it look like a polishing bar or does this come in a tube or can?
    I use DMT Dia-Paste. It comes in small tubes (syringes, actually; very convenient applicator). Looks like a very small quantity, but a tiny dab of this stuff will last a very long time, on a strop. Comes in 6/3/1 micron sizes. Each can be purchased individually, but here's an 'all-in-one' assortment from knifecenter (BF member dealer):

    http://www2.knifecenter.com/item/DMT...3-and-6-Micron

  11. #11
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    Washington
    Posts
    12,034
    I wish I knew what size my "Green" compound is. I strop with Harbor Freight "green" (#6) metal polish. Gives an edge sharp enough to whittle hair.

    I bet the stuff from Lee Valley would be finer, and better. But I just have not been able to use up all the cheap stuff I have.

    Seriously, 6 + years, and I am not even 1/2 through the 3 dollar stick I have.

    I also bought two other levels, but don't use them anymore. I just go from sandpaper to strop.

  12. so is diamond paste recommended for strop to use on convex edges? ill be mostly sharpening convex knives. thats a great deal. do these last a long time? and do i have to apply a bunch like you do with polishing compounds bars?

  13. #13
    Join Date
    Apr 2009
    Location
    New Mexico, USA
    Posts
    7,938
    Quote Originally Posted by HeavyTakeMusic View Post
    so is diamond paste recommended for strop to use on convex edges? ill be mostly sharpening convex knives. thats a great deal. do these last a long time? and do i have to apply a bunch like you do with polishing compounds bars?
    It'll be fine for convex (or any other edge type). It does last a very long time. I usually apply it in small 'dots' (~1/8" or so); maybe 3 or 4 dots on the smallish strop blocks I use (< 6" length). A flexible plastic ruler is very handy as a spreader, and will help even out the application. If put on too heavy, the surface of the strop will be very sticky/pasty after the compound dries, and any excess compound will simply be scraped off, onto your blade. This is why it's important to apply it very, very sparingly. Don't want to waste any of it. If the application turns out to be a little too light, just add a very tiny bit at a time (maybe one 'dot'), and try it again.

  14. #14
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Location
    Wenatchee, WA
    Posts
    1,073
    The diamond paste, and Ken Schwartz' CBN / Diamond sprays are both exceptionally good for hand strops on all kinds of edges and metals.

    For powered strops, Ken offers a paste version, and Hand American offers a Boron Carbide 1u paste, and a .5u CrO paste that are both excellent. The Hand American stuff works just as well on hand strops as powered, as well.

  15. #15
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    SE Michigan
    Posts
    8,833
    In my use of diamond compounds handamerican 1 micron was the best.
    The first sharpening
    The Burr
    How to make a strop


    For sharpening inquiries email me at: traditionalsharpening@gmail.com
    Free return shipping on orders over $50

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •