I like both knives. Ill always take the largest knife in a fight. Ultimately, if trained, both weapon systems will be effective in a fight
I'm a retired cop that did teach firearms and defensive knife tactics. Most officers can't do a one second draw even with tons of training. An attacker can close distance very quickly with a knife. I've been in both knife and gun battle. Been s shot and stabbed. Getting stabbed is way more painful. If your in a knife fight, your going to get stabbed. Ill tale whichever weapon keeps bad guy and his potential infectious fluids further away from me. For me running wouldn't be an option. Too old and broken. My 6 year old can probably run faster. Due to my white collar job,I can't always carry a gun. I always have a knife on me.