1. Welcome to the New & Improved BladeForums. New software info here. Please report problems in Tech Support, and read existing threads before posting! - Spark
  2. I've changed the default forum style to Flat Awesome based on feedback. Don't like it? Click here to change how the forums look Feedback on this is welcome here.

Neal Stephenson's sword-fighting game

Discussion in 'Sword Discussion' started by Hesparus, Jun 10, 2012.

  1. Hesparus

    Hesparus

    Oct 31, 2004
  2. Nate805

    Nate805 Banned

    110
    May 22, 2012
    I gotta be honest man that game looks terrible. A game that sword lovers might like though is mount and blade and the upcoming war of the roses.
     
  3. crimsonfalcon07

    crimsonfalcon07

    Dec 27, 2010
    I'm fairly interested in the game mechanics, which is really what the project is about. Eventually, we'll see something like Oblivion or whatever, but with an actual sword-fighting mechanic. I would like that a lot, although I'd really prefer to see one based around Kinect or something. Kinda like the April Fools assassins creed kinect trailer.
     
  4. Mattohn

    Mattohn

    187
    Aug 15, 2010
    Its still in being worked on, and with Valves reputation it will probably be a long time till its released.
    Seems like they are going to use the new motion control. Hopefully they dont make some GuitarHero type of sword
     
  5. Mattohn

    Mattohn

    187
    Aug 15, 2010
    double
     
  6. SeaxyBeast

    SeaxyBeast

    929
    Feb 2, 2011
    Looks like the game will suffer from the same sort of OCD detail that has made Stephenson's books less and less fun.

    I get geeking out on sim detail and I certainly get wanting something more from blade combat than the usual hold-x-for-super-powerful-swing game mechanics. It seems like what he's aiming for would be best served by a Kinect motion-capture type controller, but that seems a bit much for an arena game. The more complex the mechanics the more chance there is of fouling up the control system or making the input too complex for the AI. Think he'd be better served just aiming to change the dynamics of blade combat to focus more on distance and timing and less on button mashing. The old PS1 Bushido Blade title got the mix pretty well. Something like that for WMA would be a good starting point from which to build IMO.
     
  7. FortyTwoBlades

    FortyTwoBlades Baryonyx walkeri Dealer / Materials Provider

    Mar 8, 2008
    I think that Twilight Princess on the Wii actually did a very good job of making sword combat interesting. Simplistic enough that you didn't have to be anything even resembling a swordsman in real life to play, but got you in the same strategic "head space" during combat and gave you a good variety of techniques to employ including shield bashes.
     
  8. pullrich

    pullrich

    863
    May 4, 2010
    Ha ha, I am with you there.

    Maybe they will pull off some amazing cross-breed of Wii/Kinect mechanics so that it is more than an arm swinging game.
     
  9. gomipile

    gomipile

    Apr 17, 2010
    Well, that level of detail applied to just an arena game just might work. Also, this would be one more step towards recreating the technoporn set pieces of Snow Crash in real life. :D
     
  10. SeaxyBeast

    SeaxyBeast

    929
    Feb 2, 2011
    The arena game aspect is a useful limitation, I just wonder about how much level of detail they will try to build into the scripts and decision trees for combat.

    I once tried to write up the very first technique that every student is taught in Giron Arnis Escrima (outside block and follow-up) in as rich detail as I could taking into account body position and stance and targeting and timing for all of the elements. Just the 'defending' side description of a textbook demonstration of this very basic and simple technique ended up being about half a page and required sections of simultaneous movement for multiple body parts. As soon as I started to account for variables in attack angle and depth and 'energy' it quickly turned into a couple of pages of description with lots of connections to other possibilities. When I think about coding something like that and determining what the important factors are and where to script the available interrupts...wow. Tough calls all over.

    I think Stephenson's project sounds fascinating and that it would be a cool project to work on and a lot of fun. It also sounds like a really hard project to me because balancing realistic detail against playability and learnability and basic processing demands is going to require a lot of compromises. Is it a success if the combat ends up looking kinda like a typical LARP or is that still too much like your typical action RPG? Tough calls.

    (Also -- Note to self...must try out Twilight Princess some time)
     
  11. Street Samurai1978

    Street Samurai1978 Gold Member Gold Member

    656
    Mar 25, 2012
    I'd like to resurrect this thread and pimp the game Dishonored. It has great sword fights, wheellock pistols, and a pseudo-steampunk style world. While the creators said they drew inspiration from 16th-17th century london, I got more of a 19th century Austrian-Hungary Empire feel from it. It's certainly worth a look for fans of sword games and first person shooters.
     
  12. Nntrance

    Nntrance Banned

    157
    Aug 12, 2012
    two games sword lovers would like are both multiplayer and available on steam war of the roses and Chivalry:Medieval war fare. Honorable mention to Dark Messiah which is a single player game.
     

Share This Page