1st Impressions of MadPoet

Joined
Feb 4, 1999
Messages
5,786
As some of you know I have a couple kit blades due from MadPoet, which I will discuss when I get them, but yesterday I received one of his finished knives on trade for some things I had. Here is a brief 1st impression:
The knife is one of his drop point hunters. On his webpage, there is a pic of four of these knives together, and mine is the top one. D-2 tool steel, probably a 4.5" blade and 5" handle or so. Steel is hardened to Rc 60-61. Handles are made of granadillo wood with brass pins.
I haven't really gotten to use the knife yet, but my first impression was that it is quite rustic looking (in a good way). Mel left a bit of the rough finish from the heat treating on the blade flats, but flat gorund the rest to a nice satin finish that still shows the original grind lines. His mark is fileworked into the spine, and is pretty cool-looking, too. The scales are nicely contoured, but absoultely functional with not a trace of fanciness included. This knife is truly made to be worked, and hard at that!
Despite the decidedly non-ornamental look of the handle, it is SUPER comfortable. The slabs are quite thick with a slight palm swell, and they just melt into your hand. You could use this knife all day without it wrecking your hands. The wood is nice looking, too.
I would say the blade is probably 3/16" thick at the spine, although that is an eyeball measurement. It has amazing heft to it, and you really know you have a tool in your hand when you hold it. I love the weight of this thing, and it has good balance, too. It is flat ground, and sharp as all get out! Point is pretty scary, too.
Another nice feature is the handmade leather sheath. Mine is a little loose, but Mel says it should tighten up as it dries out. It is built to last and is a nice change from the Kydex stuff I make for most of my knives.
All in all, this knife is really cool. Everything about it screams "Beat me! I can take it! Come on, Girlie-Man!" and the knife is obviously going to withstand a lot of abuse. I like the obvious freehand handmade look it has, and it is a really nice change from most of the knives I see today that are overfinished. I would not hesitate to take this knife into the woods and beat it to hell, because I know it would take more than I can dish out. Despite being a "hunter", technically (I don't hunt), this knife will serve well as a camp knife. I showed it to a friend who is a martial artist, and he loved it, then my fiancee even kind of dug it, too. That says volumes!
If you are considering a MadPoet knife, I would check out his website (I won't give it since I don't want to be accused of being a walking advertisement), which, if you can't find, just email me. He also has been really cool about making two custom knife kits for me which, if you knew the price, would make your jaw hit the ground (in a good way!).
 
I would second what Chiro said. My daily utility knife is a D2 fixed blade by Madpoet (3/32" thick and like a razor). I am considering getting him to do me a larger one hopefully in say CPM-3V in a few months after some of the blades I have on order arrive and I update my wish list after I evaluate them.

-Cliff
 
Chiro75,
Don't think of posting a web link as bad advertising, think of it as a convenience to your fellow forumites, who would otherwise have to waste valuable mouse clicks to find the site!
Please reconsider.
 
Hi:

Mel is a super nice guy.

You can find his web site at:

http://www.angelfire.com/mn/madpoet/

 
I concur, Mel's really nice. He'll go out of his way to make you what you want. I don't know if it's still up, but there used to be (and maybe still is) a wharnecliffe blade, skeletal handle knife in one of the pic's. It's with another knife and label "customers special order" (or something like that) Don't forget Mel's a custom maker he can modify anything to your wants and likes. His sheaths are a step above too!

------------------
JerryO
 
Mel's work is great. I have the Buckeye Burl clip point skinner on the web site. This knife is a 5/32" razor. Aprox. 4 1/2" blade with plenty of belly. The wood is beautiful but not highly finished. As Mel told me: " It's nothing fancy but it cuts like the dickens." The swinger sheath is very comfortable and nice quality leather work. Not good for concealment of course.

Mel agreed to make me a 6" drop point hunter out of 3/16" D2 with cocobolo grips and a high rise leather belt sheath. Can't wait to see how it turns out.

Waldo
 
Chiro,
Does that mean I should have charged you more for the blades? ;-) Actually, I think that one had goncoles alves for a handle, but who am I to quibble with a customer ;-)

madpoet

------------------
 
Hi Y'all,
I have two MadPoets and as some of you know, Mel is working on another small boning/caping knife to partner with my 4.5" skinner in a combo sheath. They will soon debut as the "MadPoet Camp Set"!
I've been trying to dull mine around the house. The balance and handle ergonomics are great, they cut like crazy, and in my opinion, that little shadow of heat corbonizing along the spine gives it character. I wouldn't want mine mirror polished. With the D2 and Mel's edge, these babies are like Meat-Seaking Missiles!
Mel's a great guy to do business with.
I highly recommend him and his knives.
If anybody wants to see my 4.5 skinner with ironwood, I think it's near the bottom of page 2 on his web photo gallery.
 
Mel is making a drop point hunter for me with some flourishes that I requested, including setting a piece of turquoise I provided in the butt. The project has resulted in an e-mail correspondence that has been more than interesting. Mel is an amazing guy to work with on a design project. You owe it to yourself to check out the "madpoet experience." Cat has soul.

Best,
the pup
 
I've been using my MadPoets around the kitchen, but yesterday, started carrying the 4" semi-drop point/utility with cocobolo in a "swinger" sheath while out in the woods hunting mushrooms. I had forgotten how much I used to enjoy carrying a good sheath knife.
My 2 knife MadPoet Camp Set will be completed soon, but it is intended for use in hunt camp, not so much for carry. This 4" knife is just right for carry, and I'm going to get back to carrying a fixed blade on my walks.
I am fortunate to live in the middle of an interesting woodland prairie area with good arrowhead/artifact hunting.(the oldest knife in MY collection is about 5000 years old!- picked it up in my hayfield.)
The MadPoet with the swinger sheath feels just right on my hip, and now that I've "broken the ice" and started carrying it, I think it will be covering alot of territory.
It's a beautiful day here in west central Illinois- I'm going mushroom hunting with my dog and my MadPoet. Bye
 
Back
Top