Good 2 person tent

Joined
Mar 3, 2008
Messages
1,071
I am looking for a good personal tent and I have found one by Eureka called the Tetragon 7 for about $100 at Cabelas and just want to know if you guys have any good ideas for a nice tent, I am mostly going to be car camping so I won't have to have the lightest tent around but I don't want to have the biggest and heaviest tent around. Also I want to do some backpacking at some point and so a tent suggestion for that purpose would be great. And my price would be around $100 but if you have a suggestion that you would like to throw in above that price feel free to post it.

Thank you
 
When it comes to car camping, your choice of a tent isn't too terribly critical. In a worst case scenario you can always retreat to your vehicle if your tent isn't up to dealing with the prevailing weather. But when you add in the backpacking requirement, then the game changes. It's imperative that a backpacking tent be able to handle the worst possible conditions that you could possibly face during the course of your outing. Obviously, the 'worst possible conditions' are determined by the area and the seasons in which you'll be hiking.

With that in mind, my first recommendation would be to sit down and decide if this is really going to be a tent that you'll be taking backpacking. If not, then your options open up significantly. Just about any $100 tent that's made by a reputable manufacturer (of which Eureka is certainly one) and that meets your size requirements will likely do fine. Relatively speaking, it will be both roomy and comfortable.

If it definitely is going to be a backpacking tent also, then you need to focus on designs that emphasize strength and light weight. Obviously, these are two competing priorities. As such, you have to pay a premium for the engineering and materials that make it possible to combine these two elements into one product. At this point I would be more inclined to leave the Eurekas and Keltys behind and consider moving up a notch on the quality scale to brands like Sierra Designs, Mountain Hardwear, North Face and the like. You can then determine whether you need a summer tent, or a three or four season tent, again based on the locations and time of year in which you'll be making your trips.

Unfortunately, this second course will likely require that you abandon your specified spending limit. But you can rest assured that the extra expense will be money well spent, and that the tent will last you for many years. And if money is really tight, it's worth noting that today's high quality tents are excellent items to pick up on the used market. The dollar savings over retail can be substantial, and it's fairly easy to set the tent up on arrival and quickly determine if there are any serious defects. Quite often these things sit on people's closet shelves for years and are subjected to very little wear and tear at all. But even the well used ones can still be excellent deals. In fact, my brother picked up his four season Sierra Designs tent when the local sporting goods store was selling off a bunch of their old rental equipment. Lord only knows how many camping and hiking expeditions that tent had been on before it fell into my brother's hands, but it's still going strong for him 15 years later.

If you decide to go this direction, I'd recommend a four season tent only for it's ability to better withstand extreme wind conditions. Certainly wind is a huge factor when you get caught in a winter storm at altitude. But I've also experienced some pretty nasty wind conditions in the desert when the temperature was 70+ degrees. So in that regard, I think the way they rate a tent for three or four season use can sometimes be a little misleading. Yeah, a four season will be a little more expensive and weigh a bit more than a three season tent, but I prefer to err on the side of caution - and I expect you boys see your fair share of wind in Texas. ;)
 
Last edited:
Great answer (for a guy who has the name of our state right but can't spell our fair city correctly :D)!

I just want to second the suggestion to consider spending more if you are seriously planning to backpack with the tent. I've been in severe weather in both the high country and the desert when my tent held and people with lower quality tents had them knocked down. They were not very comfy.

That said, if you can afford only a less sophisticated backpacking tent, you can stretch its capabilities with careful site selection, extra guy lines, etc.

Best of success,

DancesWithKnives
 
Yes, my spelling can be a bit hit or miss at times, particularly when it comes to this wonderfully governed (and now bankrupt) state. :)

I've been in severe weather in both the high country and the desert when my tent held and people with lower quality tents had them knocked down. They were not very comfy.

Sadly, I was forced to learn my lesson by being on the opposite end of that equation one fall night many years ago in a strip of California desert north of Ocotillo but south of Anza Borrego state park. The weather in L.A. was beautiful as we departed on a Friday night, and it remained so as we drove south to San Diego, and then east on I-8 through the high country.

The cloudless, starry night gave not even the slightest hint of our impending doom until we hit the steep grade outside of Jacumba where I-8 dives down several thousand feet to meet the desert floor below. Here our convoy began to notice a slight bit of buffeting from the wind. But even occasional gusts such as these are very typical along this stretch of road. We exited I-8 at S2 in Ocotillo and proceeded north. The skies were crystal clear in any direction you looked and the big gusts of wind seemed to have subsided. At least our vehicles weren't getting bounced around any more. The only thing the least bit out of place at this point was what appeared to be a fairly steady stream of dust illuminated by the headlights running about a foot above the surface of the road. A little strange to be sure, but not so much so that anyone even commented at the time. A couple miles up the road we unexpectedly came across one of the Border Patrol's tiny mobile highway checkpoint shacks. If you've never seen one of these, I can tell you it's a pretty pathetic sight. It's basically built on top of a small trailer, and I swear the thing isn't much bigger than a phone booth. But they can drag them around anywhere and, with a small generator, run both the portable road signs that direct you to pull over, as well as some lights and com equipment for the agent inside the box. It was only then, as we pulled up to the agent and rolled down the window, that the magnitude of our problem became apparent. Immediately gale force winds blasted into the vehicle. The roar made it difficult to communicate with the BP agent who politely inquired as to just what we could possibly be doing out here on a night like this. When we told him we were going to set up camp another couple miles up the road, it was all he could do to contain his laughter. He shook his head, wished us well, and sent us on our way.

As it turned out, the reason our vehicles no longer felt like they were being buffeted by big gusts is because the sustained winds in-between the 60 mph gusts has climbed up to the 35 and 40 mph range. The GPS easily identified the precise jeep trail I had preselected for our camp sight that night and we immediately went about the business of setting up our tents. Within ten minutes my not inexpensive Eureka four-man dome tent was reduced to garbage. It had six or eight beefy aluminum poles that slid up through long sleeves sewn into the sides of the tent. These all met and were pushed into a large central hub at the top of the tent. Because of the tension that was designed into the tent to keep the fabric taut, you had to insert the poles from opposite sides. Under these conditions, even with three large men working together, it was physically impossible to get the third pole into the hub. After a couple of attempts, the force of the wind acting against the tent fabric caused the two already inserted poles to completely taco just above where my brothers were holding them in their hands. Game over.

My younger brother had just bought the previously mentioned four season Sierra Designs tent. By putting one person and a bunch of gear inside his tent to keep it from blowing away, we were rather quickly able to get the corners staked out. Erecting the rest of the tent was fairly simple after that. It made it through the rest of the night's hurricane force winds with no problems. My youngest brother had an old Coleman tent that was even less expensive than mine. His was more of a traditionally styled rectangular tent, however, and by repositioning his Jeep perpendicular to the wind we were able to tie off the upper corners of the tent to the gear rack on top of the Jeep, and the bottom corners to the rims of the wheels. Not an ideal set up by any means, but it too survived the night.

I've had a four season tent ever since. ;)
 
Last edited:
You've received good advice thus far.

I'd recommend a dome over A-frame if you expect high winds, tho I've had domes pushed down into my face as I slept.

You may also want to consider whether 2 person is enough. Personally, I like a lot of space, and normally carry a 4 person tent for 2 people. 2 ppl in a 2-person tent can get crowded if you get rained in for several hours or a day. I prefer the extra room to "spread out" inside the tent, and I am willing to carry the extra weight to pay for that privilege.

Dave
 
That's a good story and quite a coincidence because I was specifically thinking of Anza Borrego when I posted. I was once in a designated camp area with some non-4WD friends farther south in the park. A similar gale developed and flattened all of the tents in the area EXCEPT my Sierra Designs. I eventually wore that tent out. For river rafting in AK and Northern Canada, as well as 4WD camping in the Lower 48, I now use a Cabela's XPG four-season tent. Not especially light but hell for strong. Had it on a ridge in Montana last elk season in some serious wind and it did great.

Another coincidence: I was driving my '75 Bronco at the time of the Borrego windstorm!

DancesWithKnives
 
Didn't see Fubarski's post until after I finished writing mine. He makes another excellent point. For rafting/canoeing/horsepacking/4WD camping/etc. I got the FOUR-man Cabela's XPG. On my last Alaska trip (the Eek River, south of Bethel), my rafting buddy was pretty jealous of the room and comfort I had with that tent. For car camping, it was just big enough for my girlfriend and me, plus gear.

Of course, that means my XPG is useless for backpacking and I alternate between a pair of much lighter tents.

DancesWithKnives
 
Yeah I should have said something like a 3 person or 4 but after looking at Academy I found a Kelty Trail Dome for $70 clearance and a Eureka Tetragon 8 for about $80 and then a $10 rebate(yeah a rebate! don't ya just love em) but the Eureka is just a little bit bigger than the Kelty but the Kelty has the Aluminum rods and the Eureka has fiberglass rods (not sure if that makes a big or any difference) but looking online I see that the Kelty is about $150 so for $70 that is a smoking deal atleast I think so. But the backpacking tent is where I really need to think about what I want and you guys have given me a plethora (yes I know what that means El Guapo) of information on that subject. And I will look around for a nice backpacking tent and at some point I think that either the above mentioned Kelty or Eureka will be going home with me, anyone have experience with either the Tetragon's or Trail Dome's your stories are welcome.
 
Generally speaking (especially with the better manufacturers), aluminum poles are preferable to fiberglas. There are also several different grades of aluminum poles manufactured and, not surprisingly, the most sophisticated backpacking tents often feature the strongest ones. And needless to say, larger tents will often offer thicker poles.

DancesWithKnives
 
I think you've been given a lot of good advice so far. I'd check out places like REI Outlet, Sierra Trading, etc. where you can often find some very good deals.

As for the fiberglass vs. Al poles, I wouldn't buy a tent with fiberglass poles period. I have seen them break on more than one occasion in a strong wind (on other people's tents).
 
Back
Top