I had a imposter Spyderco Delica for less than one day before it broke!

kgriggs8

BANNED
Joined
Jan 28, 2002
Messages
1,634
I got one of those "same as Spyderco" type knives that look like a FRN Delica. The one I had was CE. It actually looked pretty good and in the morning before work, I thought to myself that it could pretty much do the same thing as a CE Delica. A Delica is not a brute of a blade so I fooled myself into think that it was less knife than it really is.

Here is what happened. I used the El Cheapo Delica look-a-like on a few items at work like cable ties and opening boxes. It wasn't as sharp as a real Delica but for $2.00 I was kind of happy. I thought, if I lose it it is no big deal and at least I am not paying $40 for it. Well, I needee to cut a hole in a piece drywall. I knew it was not a Sebenza so I decided to take it easy. I started just scoring the drywall to cut through the paper and then I was going to cut through the main part of the drywall once I was through the paper covering. It didn't make it that far. The blade actually snapped compleatly off the handle and the lock and other parts just crumbled into my hand.

I had to laugh. I have many Spydercos and Benchmades and some custom knives to choose from but for work I used to use cheap knives. I have started using my good knives for work because that is where I use my knives the most and that is where I can really tell which knives are best.

The point of the story is, even though a Delica looks like a cheap knife, it is actually very well made. The cheap knives would cost you more than a Delica if you had to replace them every time they broke. At $2.00 each, and only lasting about half a day, you would be spending the same as if you bought a new Delica every month!

People alway talk about how such and such a knife is not worth the money because there is another knife that is almost as good for half the price. I normally agree with them. It depends on what we are talking about though. I think a Sebenza is not worth the money because a Manix or a Para will do just about every as well or better than a Sebenza at about 1/3 the cost. The Delica cost 20 times as much as the cheap knock off but the funny thing is, it is actually worth it. The Delica is at least 20 times more knife than those made in China knock offs and it is actually a good deal.

I have no particular love of the Delica, I like my Calypso Jr. better than the Delica but most Spydercos even the ones that look cheap like the FRN handle models are actually good bargins. Spyderco is one of those companies that make good knives at good prices from their low range up to their high range. Most makers have a dead zone where either the quality goes down or the price goes up to the point where you should avoid certain knives but Spyderco delivers good quality at good prices across the board.

Very few of Spyderco knives are the best out there. They are mostly priced to give you the best knife for the dollar but that is the great thing about Spyderco. You never really go wrong with a Spyderco because you tend to get great steal and a great design along with a good grind and blade geometry. Most Spydercos will cut just as well as the most expensive knives in the class but you don't get all the other features. You got to give something up to make a product that retail so little. Most Spydercos are $50-$100 and at that price they deliver on cutting ability.
 
Good story, illustrates why one should pay a little extra for a quality tool.

However, I worked for years in settings where I cut a lot of sheetrock, stripped cables, etc. (some construction, some computer network installation, etc.), and I can say that even more important is using the right tool for the job. A pocket knife is not the right tool for cutting sheetrock. It just flat-out doesn't work well. Try using a nice, new, sharp blade in a Stanley-type utility razor, and you'll see it works much better. The blade on a pocket folder is way to thick to efficiently cut that type of material.

Glad you weren't hurt by the failure of your folder...

Peace.
 
puukkoman said:
Good story, illustrates why one should pay a little extra for a quality tool.

However, I worked for years in settings where I cut a lot of sheetrock, stripped cables, etc. (some construction, some computer network installation, etc.), and I can say that even more important is using the right tool for the job. A pocket knife is not the right tool for cutting sheetrock. It just flat-out doesn't work well. Try using a nice, new, sharp blade in a Stanley-type utility razor, and you'll see it works much better. The blade on a pocket folder is way to thick to efficiently cut that type of material.

Glad you weren't hurt by the failure of your folder...

Peace.

*cough*victorinox*cough*

I did use an endura to cut all of the carpet out of my house, and it worked rather well.
 
kgriggs8: I think this post should be made a sticky or be moved to the FAQ section! :thumbup:
 
i had a similar experience. i got the knife form a gun show it had some eagle on the handle. i was opening one of those plastic cd cases years ago. the lock broke and the blade came forward. luckily it did not hit my hand. so form that point on i will only use a good knife, mainly my delica or native.


james
 
"However, I worked for years in settings where I cut a lot of sheetrock, stripped cables, etc. (some construction, some computer network installation, etc.), and I can say that even more important is using the right tool for the job. A pocket knife is not the right tool for cutting sheetrock. It just flat-out doesn't work well. Try using a nice, new, sharp blade in a Stanley-type utility razor, and you'll see it works much better. The blade on a pocket folder is way to thick to efficiently cut that type of material."

I know, I know. I probably would have used the right tool if I had the right tool. I only needed to cut a small hole and I that is all I had on me at the time. A Delica would have been able to do it no problem.

The funny thing is, I really wasn't even using all the much force. I wasn't using as much as you would think it would take to cut drywall because I knew the knife was cheap and I was not trying to break it. It just broke and fell into parts. I could see the lock, the pins and everything.

The main thing is, Spyderco uses FRN and the cheap knives just use some sort of weak plastic handle. They look the same but they ain't the same! Not all plastics are created equal.
 
Back
Top