J.S. Performance test results

Joined
Jul 27, 2003
Messages
5,667
OK, I truly don’t want to get long-winded here, but it’s important to me to explain a few things!
First, I want to thank Don Hanson for putting up with me for the last few weeks, and for the corned beef sandwich!
I’m truly honored to be first J.S. “Testee”!
Thanks, Don.
Secondly, this knife performed SO WELL, I really need to say a few words about the people who helped me put together my current heat-treating “package”.
Jerry Rados has a knife “philosophy” that was quite something for me to run into as a beginning knife maker. Talk about “over my head”! I jumped right into the deep water at the beginning, now 9 years ago.
I went to Willow Bow a few years ago and got indoctrinated by Ed Fowler and the Willow Bow Gang and I brought back forging, post-forging, and grinding techniques that I use every time I make a knife.
Having been to Ashokan twice now, and an in-frequent “bother” to Kevin Cashen, I’ve utilized his metallurgical expertise to the maximum of my understanding.
(When’s the last time you saw Ed Fowler and Kevin Cashen in the same topic??!!)
I have used Jim Siska’s take-down assembly method exclusively for the last two years at his approval.
Anyway, these guys, along with inspiration from everything Bailey Bradshaw does, has helped me get to this point.
My contact with those fine gentlemen helped me put together two knives that were darned near indestructible.
What can I say – razor-friggin’ sharp.
Cut like a champ.
Chopped like another champ with absolutely no damage, chipping, bending, and remained razor sharp.
Then, the part that I liked the most!
On my home-test-knife, I was amazed that it performed so well, but mostly, that when it came time to bend the blade, I couldn’t even insult it! I only weigh 170 pounds, but I had my legs wrapped around the work bench, and still could hardly bend the knife.
Then, I put a 3 foot cheater bar on the handle, and bent it waaaaaaaay past 90 degrees. I never heard a crack! I kept waiting for a crack! Nothing. And, it went back to under 20 degrees from straight!
I thought it was a fluke.
Then, with my official test knife at Don’s, the same thing happened! I could BARELY get the blade past, maybe 30 degrees by hand.
So, I used the cheater again.
No crack, not even at the fine cutting edge, and this one returned to exactly 20 degrees from straight.
Both knives cut - well -, stayed razor sharp through abuse, and defied destruction.
So many times I have seen test knives that had this sharp “kink” right at the vise jaws, cracked ½ way through, and then stayed acutely bent!
These bent gradually all along the entire length of the spine – without ANY cracking.
This tells me that there were NO weak links in these chains.
The blades were tough from point to butt.
As well, I wanted to show that the Take-down assembly I use was up to the task of backing up a superior blade. No failure what-so-ever.
What else could I ask for?
Thanks again to those mentioned.
KarlandDon-1.jpg


test.jpg


test1.jpg

test4.jpg


test3.jpg


test2.jpg
 
Let me be the first to congratulate you! .... Congratulations! :)
What steel did you use?
 
Congrats on a job well done Karl! They look great and it appears that they perform just as well! :thumbup: -Matt-
 
Well, what can I say. I did expect Karl to pass but there are different levels of passing, like a blade that bends 90 degs and stays bent with a cracked edge. Or one that just doesn't cut good.

Let me tell ya, Karl passed with flying colors. I was very impressed with his test blade and I now have greater respect for 5160 and the way Karl treats it.

I was also impressed with the other knives that Karl brought along, very nice work.

We Will have a new JS Smith at the Blade show next year:thumbup: Keep up the good work Karl and I also enjoyed your visit.
 
I feel pretty foolish. I forgot to mention Ray Richard!!
He talked me through some sharpening tips and techniques at Blade last year.
In a few moments, he revolutionized my cutting edge.
Thanks, Ray.
 
Karl,
Exceptional performance. Congratulations! :thumbup: I hope to meet you at Blade. Lin
 
congratulations Karl. Glad to see all your efforts pay off and just so folks can see one of your creations, lets take a look

standard.jpg


glad to have this as part of my collection
 
Thanks, Murray.
You said a couple things to me up in Michigan that have stuck with me, and I appreciate it.
And what Ray shared with me was finishing the edge with a slack and completely worn micron belt to polish the final edge and to "strop" the feather edge off.
 
Hello Karl and congratulations. Great job and I look forward to shaking the hand of a new Journeyman smith at Blade.
Again great job.

Sincerely,

Brion

Brion Tomberlin
 
Congratulations from Germany as well! Very well done, Karl! :thumbup::thumbup:


I`m proud to own 2 of your knives (the twins ;) ) and to date they served me very well! :thumbup::D
 
Congratulations Karl. It was a pleasure meeting you at the Ohio Classic Knife show. You make beautiful knives. I look forward to shaking your hand after you pass in Atlanta.


Pete Crowl
ABS Journeyman Smith
 
Awesome Job Karl. I am very proud to have been a help to you. One thing about you is you are a freakin' sponge when it comes to learning. You truly are a student of the blade.

Folks....THAT is what a test blade should look like;)
 
Back
Top