Norton Waterstones

Joined
Jul 21, 2007
Messages
23
For those with experience with these, what is your opinion of them? I'm considering getting a 4k/8k stone.

How is the life on these?

Can I expect my great grandchildren to be using this someday, or will it be a 1/8th inch shim in five years?

Any known problems with them?

Thanks!
 
I've used Norton stones for quite a while now and love them. They are easy to use and very easy to sharpen a knife. the only trick with them is to keep the surface moist (use a spray mister). I haven't had any problems with them and haven't heard of anyone else having issues with them either.

Hopefully. you're not planning on using this as a primary sharpening stone because it's principally used for final finishing and polishing of an already sharp edge. In addition, I wouldn't get that combo, unless it's a matter of economy, because the 4k is quite soft and will wear faster than the 8K. Buy the individual stones in these grits. You'll be much happier with them.

You'll also need a coarse or XC diamond stone to periodically flatten these stones because they will cup or dish with use and the stones need to be reasonably flat to sharpen well.

Most waterstones will wear considerable faster than the average Arkansas or Silicon Carbide stone. They are produced with a friable cutting surface that, as it wears, breaks away and reveals new sharp cutting edges. You'll probably get several years out of them with reasonable use but I wouldn't expect them to last long enough to pass on to your "kin".

Good luck.

NJ
 
If you're only using the combi stone for personal use it will probably last a lifetime. Be sure to soak for a minimum of 10 minutes before use and keep wet. Also, it probably won't be flat out of the box. I use a DMT DiaSharp XXC for initial flattening and Norton flattening stone before each use.
 
They're a bit fine for general purpose sharpening as others have said. I have reprofiled a small camillus electricians knife with one before(edit: It was a king brand 4000 or 6000 grit stone), it took about 3 hours, on a 1000 grit waterstone it would have been about 5 minutes. The shapton 1000 is my favorite for general sharpening, it cuts fast and leaves a hair popping edge with some bite to it. I would imagine the norton would leave a similar edge, though the shapton has a rep for being very long lived. Mine has only a minimal amount of dishing since I bought it a couple years ago, you wouldn't even notice by looking at it. I've heard good things about the bester ceramic waterstones and I'll be getting one of their 500 grit stones later this year to try out.
 
They start at 220, which I wouldn't say is too fine for working up an edge. Norton sells a flattening stone for these ($30 or so).
 
Back
Top