Review: Polkowski Scorpion

Joined
Nov 8, 1998
Messages
458
I recently purchased a Polkowski Scorpion which was designed by knife combatives instructor Bob Kasper. While this is my first Polkowski knife it is not my first Kasper design as I utilize a Crawford Kasper Fighting Folder as my daily carry knife. For a picture of the Scorpion and specifications please visit Bob Kasper's website. This site also contains Bob's philosophy behind the design of his knives.:

http://www.ghca.org/KFK.html#Scorpion

I really like the overall design and workmanship of the Scorpion. The Scorpion is designed as a pure fighter and excels in that area. The blade has a slight recurve for efficient slashing. The double edge makes for excellent penetration. There is a substantial dropped guard integral with the blade. The guard ensures very secure thrusting. At the top of the blade there is what appears to be a thumb ramp. According to Bob Kasper, this is actually a way to widen the blade to produce a larger wound channel. You can use this as a thumb ramp with the saber grip. At first I was concerned about the close proximity of the fully sharpened top edge to my thumb, but Bob Kasper assured me that the handle is designed to keep your hand securely in place. I practiced some snap cuts on a stack of newspapers, and my thumb stayed in place. The blade has a very attractive satin bead blast finish. The edges were not as sharp as I like, however. Some attention with a Spyderco Sharpmaker brought them to shaving sharpness.

The Scorpion is mainly intended to be used with the natural grip at close range. The slim handle makes this a very comfortable grip. The handle is noticeably thinner than the one on my KFF. This makes for a very concealable knife. The nicely finished in-the-waistband Kydex sheath keeps the handle close to the body. I normally carry the knife in the front hip position so that the knife fits into the crease formed by the thigh and lower abdomen. I cover the knife with either a fleece vest or a t-shirt. Due to the slim handle design, the knife does not print through the clothing. The knife is also very comfortable to wear for long periods.

The G-10 scales have a scallop on either side toward the end of the handle. This scallop creates a palm swell and flared pommel. I find that the handle fits my hand very nicely. The tang is tapered towards the end of the handle. Apparently this is to provide proper balance. The balance point is right around the index finger. This results in a knife which is very maneuverable. When drawing the knife from the Kydex sheath, there is enough handle to grasp with my last three fingers (middle, ring and pinky). The pinky hook and pommel flare provide a secure grip for drawing. With a tug, the knife clears the Kydex and the index finger easily finds the finger groove.

The overall finish of the knife is excellent. The edges of the steel and G-10 match up perfectly so that there are no sharp edges. The G-10's finish is rather smooth. It is no where near as rough as on my Benchmade AFCK, yet it still provides a good grip.

This knife has become my home carry knife. So if you're looking for a well-made, close range fighter that is fast in the hand and comfortable to conceal, I highly recommend the Polkowski Scorpion.

Axel




[This message has been edited by Axel Yup (edited 03-25-2000).]
 
Joined
Nov 13, 1998
Messages
153
Repeat: Excellent! Thank you, Axel!

Anybody any comparisons with similar-sized fighters/self-defense knives?

Markku
 
Joined
Feb 4, 1999
Messages
655
Thanks for the review it was great. I am looking hard at the scorpion and the pug. Now I would love to hear from a pug owner out there. I WILL be visiting the Polkowski table at teh NYC knife show.
Alex
 

MrG

Joined
Aug 11, 1999
Messages
389
I just got my Polkowski Scorpion!
biggrin.gif


And I'm in such a great mood, I thought that I'd bring up Axel's great review again, and add my two cents...

I really love this handle. I love it a LOT! This is my first Polkowski knife(the first of many
wink.gif
) and I am amazed at how secure the handle is. Slim, but not too slim, and the palm swell fills my hand nicely. And I've never seen G-10 finished like this before; it's so micarta-ish!

A lot has been said about the sharpness of Al's knives, so I was ready to cast a critical eye at both edges. I rubbed my finger along the top edge...and yes, there it was, blood! YIKES! It's sharp! Al had posted before that he would change the edge angle and work on that sharpness problem, and, judging by the wicked little cut on my finger, I guess he did. The Scorpion is as sharp as my Crawford KFF, if not a tad sharper... but not as sharp as the tongue on my pregnant wife, who tore me a new you-know-what when she found out about my new 'baby'.

On to the sheath...yes it's as thin as Axel says, and yes it's as comfortable. What isn't mentioned is how smooth the draw is. Smoother than Nicole Kidman's legs, after she shaves them.

Now, I'm sure all of you are asking, how oh how did MrG get so damn lucky and hook up with that Scorpion? Why, all I did was ask a certain Mr. Les Robertson, and, in four short months, I had a FedEx man with a package for me! YIPPEE! Thanks Les...it was a pleasure doing business with you! All I have to do now is order my Scorpion trainer from Bob Burgee at www.trainingblades.com and then I will be a complete man. HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
eek.gif


Okay, I'm gonna go cut something with my Scorpion now...

[This message has been edited by MrG (edited 03-25-2000).]
 
Joined
Oct 19, 1999
Messages
418
Axel and Mr.G,

Nice review
smile.gif
. I'm starting to get jealous, Mr.G- first Nicole, and now a Scorpion!
wink.gif
It looks like a great little hide-away fighter. I'd be very interested to hear how well it cuts a leg of lamb.

Congrats to both of you
smile.gif


Mario

------------------
Gaucho

Tuvo muy mala suerte...se callo en mi cuchillo.




[This message has been edited by Gaucho (edited 03-25-2000).]
 
Joined
Nov 8, 1998
Messages
458
MrG, Congratulations on the Scorpion. It's nice to hear that Al's knives are delivered sharper now. I'm waiting on a Gaunt in August.

The Scorpion is still my constant home carry knife. Thanks for the additions to the review. The draw from the Kydex is very smooth.

Cougar thanks for the link change. I should go ahead and change that on the review.

I have two EDGES2 trainers for my Crawford KFFs and they are very nice. However, I am having Al make trainers for my Scorpion and Gaunt complete with Kydex sheaths. Unfortunately, I have to wait until August. Hopefully, I will have a review of the Gaunt by then.

Axel
 
Top