JK, I got mine a few months ago, the original in green camouflage in what they call Neo-traditional style, which wraps around and snaps shut (rather than the Standand style, which has a zip closure fly). Wearing it, I've raised a few eyebrows as can be expected, and it sure is a discussion starter. It's up to individual preference what to wear underneath it. At the minimum one wears just one's pride, as they say, but as winter has come on, long underwear wouldn't be amiss. As an option, the manufacturer offers "modesty snaps" so you can button up between your legs, and that might work if you bike. The kilt itself is very well made, the pockets are useful, and, as a whole, if the thought of snapping one around your waist doesn't bring a smile to your face, well, then I'd steer clear, for it isn't a cheap, as in inexpensive, thrill. Mine was the least pricey at around $100. Well, despite my username, I say bring on the haggis 'cause I sharpened up me dirk
(BTW, bfm, the thread you may be thinking of was back I think in August, and titled "Check out these britches")