I am not one to give advice as I am but an advanced newbie, but this topic is dear to my heart. I made my first knife from 1095, and then several more. I had to replace them because they were soft. Once I got a hardness tester, and proper quench oil, it came to time. Here is what works for me:
1475 degrees
Soak for 5-10 minutes (time at temperature). Don't overdo it.
Quench in Parks #50 first choice, McMaster-Carr 11 second for my 2nd choice (both work)
2- 2 hour tempers @400 degrees
Usually end up at 57-59 RC.
My hunting knife (my 100th) is made from 1095, and it cuts!
Milt
Read the stickies for lots of info. You may got lots of different opinions, but my advice is to just keep trying to find the magic formula that works for you. Or, use 1080 or 1084! They are much more forgiving.