I don't believe there can be a "consensus" per se. The edge retention you experience will largely be dictated by what/how you cut, how you sharpen, and what sharpness you require. That said, there is nothing wrong with steel that is causing less than expected performance, which seems to be more what you're asking. The steel will do what it is supposed to do, as Jim said, and I think the LWT (and Native) are a great platform for it.