15th hang... is it too soon to redo my early hangs?

Joined
Sep 25, 2015
Messages
193
OT: Just remembering I promised a while ago I'd post pictures & weights of what I think are legit/genuine 3#, 4# and 5# Legitimus and Plumb Victory heads I've acquired... I'll get to it and post pics in that thread... eventually.

The hangs have not all been axes --some claw & engineer's hammers, two sledges, couple spade shovels, a true-temper garden rake and then 5-6 more axes & hatchets. I feel like I'm starting to get it as its getting easier and going faster each time. Been doing some home improvement projects and using table, miter/chop and radial arm saws a bunch which has given me a much better understanding of woodworking, kerfs & notches, how much of a blank canvass a piece of wood really is, etc. More/better tools have also helped... Japanese saw rasps are awesome.

It was July 4th so I figured what better time to finally hang the 1945 Plumb U.S. Army hatchet that's been collecting dust on the bench for months... The kerf wedge went all the way down and there are no holes or gaps anywhere (top or bottom of eye). It'll soak in a bath of BLO for a week or two but I can tell its going to be really solid and a good hang (pics once its done bathing)... which made me think about my first few hangs and how little the kerf wedges went in or the holes/gaps, etc.

There is nothing wrong with my first couple of hangs. They are 100% functional and the ones I didn't screw up have been solid with heavy use so far. Should I get another 15-20 hangs under my belt before I start to rip them apart and rehang? Should I focus on using the early hang tools so if/when they fail it can be a new learning experience --or should I just shut up and not nit-pick... tools are tools; use them properly until they break, fix them and then repeat??
 
When I was new around here I remember some people mentioning they rehung some of their old stuff... Now that I'm starting to get it I realize that there must be giant voids in the kerf slots of some of my early hangs because the wedge profile was too thick --or because I didn't match the haft to the eye or/and I didn't really know what I was doing, etc. etc.

P.S. For some reason over the past few months our local HD has had some very mangled/dented 1-gal cans of BLO on the shelf. I usually spot them during the day/weekends and then go back on a random weeknight prior to close time... If you take the cans (and a happen to have a cute dog with you) and go up to the Customer Service desk, you can ask a manager/supervisor for a "scratch & dent" discount. It can be as much as 50% off... Don't forget the dog...

EDIT: Rescue & jerk factor is important. Usually when they ask "what is she" or "what kind of dog" and I reply with "she's a rescue so we don't know but the DNA tests came back with 100% spoiled jerk/brat"... that bumps up the scratch & dent discount...
 
Last edited:
If you do rehang them, take some picture so you can have an evolution of skill on your shop wall 😁
 
There are some true craftsmen and artisans that frequent this excellent site. I have been replacing handles in striking tools for 35+ years and my work rarely looks as good as some I see here. But I must confess that I have been steadily going back through some of my earlier work and cleaning up some issues. The biggest concern is that a re-handle job will fail and someone would get hurt. As long as you feel your tools are safe, then you are fine. But you may be afflicted with whatever I have caught from this webpage and want your work to look as nice as the pics that are posted on here. I am lucky in that "cull" handles are readily available around my hometown. I rarely pay over $7 for handles but they often require a little/lot of work. Good luck and keep us posted
 
I look back at some axes I rehung when I was 18 years old (darn near 1/2 century ago) and they are 'novice' hangs by current forum standards. But they're intact and have served their intended purpose all these years so I can't complain.
"If it ain't broke don't fix it".
 
If you do rehang them, take some picture so you can have an evolution of skill on your shop wall 😁

I'll take pics --and probably keep them in a bucket or coffee can because I have ranges from full axes to tiny little mini-hatchets so the hafts can always be reused. I'd put photos (or the hafts) on the wall but its currently covered with body parts from/for the dissembled car I've been ignoring for too long.

There are some true craftsmen and artisans that frequent this excellent site. I have been replacing handles in striking tools for 35+ years and my work rarely looks as good as some I see here. But I must confess that I have been steadily going back through some of my earlier work and cleaning up some issues. The biggest concern is that a re-handle job will fail and someone would get hurt. As long as you feel your tools are safe, then you are fine. But you may be afflicted with whatever I have caught from this webpage and want your work to look as nice as the pics that are posted on here. I am lucky in that "cull" handles are readily available around my hometown. I rarely pay over $7 for handles but they often require a little/lot of work. Good luck and keep us posted

I agree. This site has kicked my OCD into overdrive. Many of these metal objects with wooden handles were my dad's or her grandfather's and I'd like our kids to use them someday. Safety is #1. I'm not sure if I could live with myself if something I hung/re-hung failed and someone got hurt... Then again, considering the alternative (mass produced imported crap), pretty sure if it was meant to break it'll break --and my need/want to re-hang is simply my OCD trying to make things look as nice as some of the work posted here.

A lot of the stuff posted up on this site is beautiful and somewhere I hope I can be... someday...
 
I have hung, used, and re-hung a few of my axes simply because I wanted a different look or different handle. And I'm glad I did! Why not take something you like and make it better? Their yours, have at it!
 
All I can say is, I completely understand the desire to go back and rehang. I had rehung some multiple times before I got to 15. For me the wood is the issue. If I'm going to put a bunch of time into it, I want the right piece of wood and that's been an annoying challenge for me.
 
All I can say is, I completely understand the desire to go back and rehang. I had rehung some multiple times before I got to 15. For me the wood is the issue. If I'm going to put a bunch of time into it, I want the right piece of wood and that's been an annoying challenge for me.

You bring up an excellent point. Getting hold of a 'top drawer' store-bought handle is not an everyday event. I troll through handle bins anywhere and everywhere and over the course of 25 years have only stumbled across about a dozen top-of-the-line (end and length grain orientation-wise) pieces. It's definitely worthwhile to keep an eye out for these and immediately scoop them up otherwise the replacement handle you are hastily forced to choose on the day you need one will be a disappointment no matter how much time and effort is invested in conducting a hang.
 
Back
Top