2004 Spirit of Steel Show - Pictorial Review

Joined
Feb 28, 2002
Messages
13,348
Overview

The 2004 Spirit of Steel Show unfolded over three days (September 18-20) at the Hilton DFW Lakes Conference Center in Grapevine, Texas. This was a terrific location for the show, with first rate accommodations at the hotel for participants and attendees. There was ample shopping to be had at the nearby Grapevine Mall, and for the hunting / fishing / camping / hiking / general outdoor set the adjacent (and massive) Bass Pro Shop was, essentially, Disneyland.

This was a special show for me because my Dad accompanied me down to Dallas. It would be his first exposure to a knife show of any kind and I hoped it would provide him with an understanding of and appreciation for my long-time interest in the subject. I was not disappointed. Dad was fairly overwhelmed by the friendliness and hospitality shown by all. We were both treated to dinner on Friday night by Chris Carlson (organizer of the Central Texas Knife Show in Austin) and his lovely wife Nichelle – steak and ribs no less – my sincere thanks to them both. On Saturday he accompanied me to the show itself and got to see the cutting competition (which will be the subject of a separate review). He had the opportunity to speak with several of the makers and view their creations. It’s fair to say that the experience was eye-opening for him and a total blast for me.

A few words about what follows. First, you will be forgiven if you think the title should read “Forged Bowies of Spirit of Steel” – I’m afraid the emphasis of the photographs reflects both my own interest and also the incredible display of big forged fixed blades - from plain working knives to ornate works of art. ABS makers were in abundance and the ABS itself was represented at (as well as co-sponsored) the show. I’ll also apologize in advance for the poor quality of many of the pictures. The only slight draw back of the otherwise spacious and comfortable ballroom which housed the show was somewhat poor lighting, which made hand-held non-flash photos subject to blurriness. If you’re hoping for Coop-like photo quality, run now while you still can.

Before I forget, I’ll say a special thanks to Bruce Voyles for putting on an excellent and thoroughly enjoyable show.

AWARD WINNERS

Best Damascus - Jim Walker
Best Hunter - Jim Walker
Best Folder - Bill Ruple
Best Combat Knife - John Martin
Best Bowie - Brett Gatlin
Clyde Fisher Award - Brett Gatlin
Best Miniature - Richard Self
Most Innovative - Ron Newton
Best of Show - Ron Newton

THE MAKERS AND THEIR KNIVES

Jerry Fisk

Shown here holding a prototype design of a “one knife does it all” type bowie:

orig.jpg


Jerry describes the bottom knife in the following photograph as “The best Southwest Bowie I have ever made.” It features a 12”-plus blade of mosaic damascus, ivory handle and elaborately engraved fittings. The stag / damascus SW bowie at the top surely cannot be far behind. I was tremendously impressed at how well-balanced and quick these massive bowies were in the hand. Nestled between them is the prototype. I cried like a baby to learn that it was not for sale:

orig.jpg



Ron Newton

orig.jpg


Ron had an assembly of his typically amazing knives. My favorite was (unsurprisingly) the big clamshell bowie he is shown holding in the photo above. The stunning guard is almost enough to make you overlook the terrific stag handle and wonderful blade profile (Newton pic):

orig.jpg


The knife that won both the “Most Innovative” and “Best of Show” awards was an exquisite “Shootin’ Newton” switch combo, which combined the elegance of an engraved and gold-inlayed gent’s latch release automatic folder, together with the punch of 17 caliber cap and ball. Outstanding!


Harvey Dean

It was a real pleasure to finally meet Harvey Dean, shown here holding a new fighter design that was easily in my top two favorite fighters of the show:

orig.jpg


This assembly alone would be worth the price of admission for the bowie fan. The botton knife is that sweet stag fighter:

orig.jpg



Mike Williams

orig.jpg


I’ve wanted to own a Williams bowie for a LONG time and have always particularly admired his river pattern damascus. The knife Mike is shown holding above (and the top knife in the photo below), with its gorgeous damascus blade, stag handle and wrought iron fittings, was a no-brainer purchase decision. I could not have hoped for a nicer knife from a nicer guy:

orig.jpg


The second knife was my other favorite fighter of the show, with a sheep horn handle and wonderful hamon that my camera, regrettably, failed to capture. It was a lighting-quick blade to be sure.


Reggie Barker

orig.jpg


Reggie is a fellow with two distinct personas. Knife Show Reggie is as friendly and affable as anyone else. Cutting Competition Reggie is serious and all-business (more on Reggie in the separate cutting competition review). He had a real nice selection of carbon steel fixed blades – knives which will no doubt be in further demand as the reigning World Cutting Champ continues his winning ways:

orig.jpg



Review will continue in part 2....
 
Part 2.....


Jim Walker

orig.jpg


I had a great time getting re-acquainted with Jim and his lovely wife Anne (you won’t dodge my camera next time Anne, I promise). Jim is shown above holding the knife which won the award for Best Damascus. The knife which garnered the “Best Hunter” award unfortunately dodged my camera as well. Jim had a fairly wide selection of beautiful blades, all of which sold in less time than it has taken me to type this paragraph. Here is a sampling:

orig.jpg



Brett Gatlin

Shown here holding a pair of closely-matched ironwood bowies:

orig.jpg


More than one knowledgeable maker, collector and dealer had told me that young Gatlin was a maker to watch. Knowing good advice when I hear it and having liked what I’d seen of his knives in photos, I ordered a bowie from Brett to be delivered at the show. I met up with Brett late in the day on Friday, and was presented with a knife with clean, crisp lines, comfortable handle sculpted from a single piece of gorgeous ironwood and possessed of a level of fit and finish just about unheard-of at its price point. I could not have been happier with the knife. Or so I thought. When I returned at lunch time on Saturday Brett told me, real casual-like, that the knife had won the Best Bowie award. Yowza! (Hoffman photo):

orig.jpg



Brett also collected the Clyde Fischer Award for a hunter he produced in the Fischer style and tradition.

For those of you not adverse to taking some good advice: consider one of Brett’s knives.


Andrew Jordan

Shown here holding a terrific mosaic damascus S-guard bowie:

orig.jpg


Andrew is another maker whose work I have long admired. Many of you on this side of the pond may not be familiar with this truly international bladesmith who hails from The Netherlands by way of England, having studied in Japan under a “mukasa” swordsmith and in the United States under the likes of Rob Hudson. I had no idea that Andrew would be at the show. When I was about two tables away, I glanced ahead and thought, “Wow, somebody sure has a lot of Andrew Jordan knives on display.” Which establishes at least two things: 1) Andrew’s knives have a very distinctive (and to my eye, very beautiful) style, and 2) I can be real slow on the uptake at times.

It was most enjoyable meeting Andrew and his charming wife Yvonne. Andrew’s knowledge of and passion for the art, craft and science of bladesmithing was quite evident. Here are a few examples from Andrew’s web site:

standard.jpg


standard.jpg


I picked up just a stunning little utility hunter from Andrew (yes, that’s right, me, the guy who just about never buys a little knife) and I’m looking forward to working with him on a large camp / bowie similar to the one pictured above.



If you get the feeling I could go on forever about this show, you’d be right. But acknowledging the limits of bandwidth and readers’ patience, I’ll wrap up with a few quick pics:

J.W. Randall

J.W. had easily one of the most memorable bowies of the show. This photo falls well short of capturing it’s beauty:

orig.jpg



Joe Flournoy

You can count on Joe to show up with a highly desireable assembly of bladeware, and here he did not disappoint:

orig.jpg


orig.jpg



Review will continue in part 3....
 
...Part 3.....


John Fitch

John only looks like he’s mad at me, which is a REAL good thing, considering he is holding one of his massive bowies with a razor sharp, 16” blade. (Yes it is that big, it’s just John throwing your sense of scale out of whack).

orig.jpg



Daniel Winkler

Holding a bowie with a look that is all his own:

orig.jpg



Rusty Polk

Shown holding his competition cutting knife – one of the few to put a presentation-grade blade to the test:

orig.jpg


And a selection of his bowies (the mammonth ivory on the bottom knife was stunning):

orig.jpg


Brion Tomberlin

“Too Tall” Tomberlin is turning out some very clean knives and putting them to the test in the cutting competition. I would have gladly taken home that biggun that he’s holding had I not been really quite broke at the time:

orig.jpg



Les Robertson and Bob Neal

orig.jpg


Two very knowledgeable guys that I had a lot of fun speaking with. Bob had an outstanding ironwood Dean bowie very similar to the one that won Harvey Best of Show at the 2003 SOS Show as well as a couple awesome Fisk Senderos. Les had big bad broad-bladed McIntyre bowie that was way too “me” to resist, as well as some sweet stuff from the likes of Farr, Crowell, Kilby and many others.


Chris Carlson

orig.jpg


Shown above in the company of Big John, Chris had one of the nicest folders I have ever held by Bailey Bradshaw – six different kinds of sweet (pic from Chris’ site):

standard.jpg


At long last… the end.


I’d really like to say a special thanks to all of the exhibitors who made this show an enjoyable and memorable experience for me and so many others.

Cheers,

Roger Pinnock

PS - One more - I was able to get from Ron a photo of his award-winning Shootin' Newton that is actually worthy of the knife itself (Hoffman Photo):

orig.jpg
 
great Pictures what a show!
i too have one on order from Andrew..love his style.
 
Roger,

I think we are going to have to pass the hat, in order to send you all the big shows. First rate photos and commentary! Many Thanks!!!! :cool:
 
Thank you for your hard work. This little Fisk bowie is gorgeous.
 
That was one of the best reviews of a show that I have seen. Excellent photos of both the makers and of their great knives.

Thanks a lot Roger. I have enjoyed my visit to this thread immensely.
 
Great review and pics Roger! Very educational for those of us not as well versed in the way of the bowie :)

I especially like that Harvey Dean with the pins in the handle...do you have any pics of the Shootin Newton??

Thanks,
RL
 
Roger, thanks for taking and posting those great pics. You nabbed a couple sweet pieces, that's for sure.

Matt
 
OK, even my 20mos old son pulling at my arm couldn't pull me away. This was compelling!

Roger, the only thing I admire more than the photos you showed us is your writing and commentary. The movie was great but the storyline was incredible! ;) Yours is a gift.

And speaking of gifts, the makers you showed us all have a gift of eye and hand. It shows. I'm 2000 miles away and enjoyed much of the show. Cool.

[grumble]ONE stinkin' folding knife, and it was lifted from a website. Harrrrummph. :grumpy: [/grumble] ;)

Thanks.

Coop
 
Thanks for the review Roger. I can see now your reason for going to SOS instead of Chicago - I think you must have gone for the bowies :D
Great photos and commentary.


Don Hanson lll
 
That small Fisk bowie WAS awesome, no pictures could do it justice...I came to the show mostly for supplies, but MAN I wanted to buy that knife. Unfortunately, I was broke.



Jared
 
Roger - Thanks for a superb thread - I had been looking forward to this since you mentioned you would do it - not dissappointed .... just one thing though ..... wheres the McIntyre Bowie you nabbed? ;)

Stephen
 
Thanks very much guys - I do appreciate the comments.

RL - I have added the Shootin' Newton pic to the end of the review.

Coop - I knew I'd catch it a little bit for the lack of folders. I actually did take a few, but they just didn't turn out. Here is some blurry evidence of that - beautiful knives by Mark Sentz that I only wish you could see better:

orig.jpg


Keith - Andrew Jordan's knives really are exceptional. make sure you have a look at the link on his site to the video documentary which featured his work, entitled "Messen" - you'll see some jaw-dropping examples of his work and also see a mosaic damascus bowie being made. Andrew was kind enough to provide me with a CD Rom of the documentary at the show. It's a great way to show people what forged blades are all about.

Stephen - I'll be posting up additional pics of all my show knives after I get them. The McIntyre is a real nice carbon steel / madrone burl broad-bladed beast.

Cheers,

Roger
 
Again, Thank you Roger. Excellent posts and some beautiful knives. And thank you for the kind words. Seeing all of the great pieces only makes me want work harder to move to a higher standard in my knives. I am looking forward to seeing you again sometime.
Best regards
Brion "Too Tall" Tomberlin
Anvil Top Custom Knives
 
Thanks, Roger. What an outstanding collection of knives under one roof. Unbelievable.

Your pictures are tremendous with a lot of pics of gorgeous knives. Very well done. One of The best show reviews I have seen, like Keith said.
 
Back
Top