440V, good in a utiltiy folder?

K

Kevin Deaton

Joined
May 7, 2000
Messages
121
I am strongly considering a Carson M16 in 440v, but I have a some concerns about durability. I have read that this steel is somewhat brittle and will chip easily. Is this true? I plan to carry the knife daily and use for a wide range of utility tasks. Would I be better spending the extra money and going for the stellite blade, or get a Ralph Apogee in 420v?

Thanks,
Kevin
 
I have had good luck with 440V and would recommend it for use. The only time a 440V blade chipped when I used it was when I hit a rock while trimming weeds. When it comes to blade chipping, I think the grind of the blade is at least as important as the steel. For example, Sebenzas, which are BG-42, are known to chip easily because they have very thin grinds. That same characteristic makes them great cutters and slicers. Think about what you wnat to use your knife for and look at the grind, if the name design is appropriate for your task, 440V should be fine.
 
I think a Carson in 440V would be a great purchase. It is an excellent steel grade when heat treated correctly (like all steels) and you have Kit's guarantee. Is is a win-win situation for you. I think you would be very happy with the piece.

------------------
~Greg Mete~
Kodiak Alaska
JKM-Chai
 
I haven't had any chipping problems with 440V. I guess it would depend on what you plan to cut. The edge holding makes it worthwhile to me.

Paul
 
The complaints of 440V's brittleness, IIRC, have been with its use in production folders (e.g., Spyderco and Kershaw Onions). In custom/handmade knives with small blades (4" or under), 440V with quality heat treat really excels; I'm familiar with Tom Mayo's and Steve Mullin's work (both with Paul Bos heat treat). Kit Carson is certainly at the top of the class.

Glen
 
Well, I went with the M16 in 440V. It should be here in the next couple of days. Thanks to all that responded.

Kevin
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top