757 Vicar - Initial Impressions

Joined
Feb 25, 2014
Messages
71
I posted this on the Benchmade Community Forums -

I have worked hard trading, selling and saving in order to buy one the 2015 new releases, and was torn between the 757 and the 484-1. A call from the nearby Army-Navy (whose knife and gun department manager knows I am a new Benchmade addict) telling me that he had a new shipment of 761s and 757s made the decision for me...a 757 it would be.

I arrived at the store to find several Vicars and I quickly picked one out and brought it home. Opening the beautiful blue box, the first thing that struck me was the weight. This is NOT a "disappear in the pocket" piece of cutlery! The blade was centered perfectly (and I do mean perfectly, as my caliper attested) and the G-10 scales were impressively "grippy." I noticed NO hot spots when grasping the knife forehand or even backhand. The edges have been smoothed and chamfered for comfort and the jimping ridges on the back - spacer were not uncomfortable. The jimping on the back of the blade matched perfectly with the jimping on the fore-end of the back of the handle. [By now I hope I am spelling "jimping" correctly.] It was obvious to me that they BM folks had paid true attention to detail with this big handful of a knife, and a handful it is, even for my extra-large mitts.

I flicked the blade open and it was flawlessly smooth. As a matter of fact, it was so smooth it sent me scurrying to the catalog to find out if this knife had the familiar bronze/phosphor washers or a ball-bearing system. The liner lock-up was early and came with a satisfying "click" (Yes I enjoy satisfying clicks except when the clicking sound is coming from my joints). This knife would be fun to open, close, open, close....

There was no, nada, zip, zero (not even a smidgen of) play in the blade up, down left or right. This is a good thing, because the scales cover the pivot screw - something I don't understand.

The grind on the blade was completely even from stem to stern. The blade itself reminds me of a kind of Bowie knife blade without the pronounced Clip point, and it is THICK and meaty. Love the balance and love the fit and finish. I hope that some day there will be another model done with the AXIS lock, though this lock-up is solid.

I would love to see a comparison video of hard-use testing against something like a ZT 301 or something similar. I love this knife. Well done Benchmade.

Jay
 
I have a first production run and it has mad up and down play. Kinda bugs me. Great knife otherwise.
 
The Vicar ranks up there as one of my favorites of the 2015 line up. No question it's an exceptional knife. The one I received was also a first production and about as good as it gets f&f wise for a production knife. No issues with mine. What I like so much about the Vicar is it's a solid robust knife but not over done. One of the standouts for sure.

Congrat's on your new knife!
 
Last edited:
I've handled one..really liked the feel of it overall, especially the handle. Not a fan of clipped blades though.

I DO however love my 761.
 
I have a Vicar on the way from none other than 1SKS. I'm very much looking forward to it.

The Good Shepherd, I moved your post from Community, as it did not meet the criteria for that section according to the rules.
 
Last edited:
I have a Vicar on the way from none other than 1SKS. I'm very much looking forward to it.

The Good Shepherd, I moved your post from Community, as it did not meet the criteria for that section according to the rules.

It's possible that I've fondled your Vicar.

Ahem. Not sure how many he has in stock but.. I couldn't resist.
 
I will thoroughly soak it in gasoline over night. Thanks for the heads up. ;) LOL!
Kevin seems to have a pretty healthy stock of that model, they are all present and available on the website. Hope it gets here soon.
 
The new gold class Vicar is my favorite out of all the gold class knives I have handled.

img-0260.jpg
 
Bahaha gasoline or not it's a fun knife.

Have you seen the new limited run gold class Vicar?

I did indeed. I think it looks crazy gangsta, like a cartel boss would own it. The only thing. I like about it are the scales and the blade shape and steel. I had not purchased anything from 1SKS in a long time, so I figured I would give this knife a try since it was on my list. I like larger folders and this fit the criteria perfectly.
 
The gold class Vicar really pops with the Damascus and the gold accents. Good score pbcg! Do you have comparison pics with the regular Vicar?
 
The gold class Vicar really pops with the Damascus and the gold accents. Good score pbcg! Do you have comparison pics with the regular Vicar?

Thanks!

Unfortunately not at the moment. My daughter has commandeered my camera for school but when I get it back I'll see what I can do.
 
The gold class Vicar really pops with the Damascus and the gold accents. Good score pbcg! Do you have comparison pics with the regular Vicar?

Here you go. Was able to take these real quick this morning. Wish the lighting was a bit better but you can definitely see the differences, and the similarities.
nF9SnHN.jpg

npXfOdf.jpg

xZxJDYF.jpg

2UvDqdq.jpg

iOVb8in.jpg
 
Thanks for the side by side shots! The Gold class grinds look similar but better than the prototype Vicar. I didn't realize the Gold class blade is also wider. Nice!
 
I got my Vicar, such a well balanced knife. I love me a large folder. Smooth action, sharper than any other BM I've had in the last couple years, and the centering is dead on. I'm very pleased with it. One thing, the liners...my God, the liners. I wish Benchmade made more knives like this. They really excel with liner/framelocks.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top