A Bag Of Scrap

Jack Black

Seize the Lambsfoot! Seize the Day!
Platinum Member
Joined
Dec 2, 2005
Messages
71,228
Up until a year or so ago, I don’t think I had ever seen a pocket-knife being sold in my local market. These past few weeks, due to various seasonal factors, it’s been much that way again, but on the whole the situation has changed dramatically, and over the past six months I’ve had some reasonable finds there. What seems to have made a difference is that the traders have realised that there’s a market for old slipjoints, namely ME, who they’ve taken to calling ‘The Penknife Man’! :D Even stall-holders I’ve never spoken to before have approached me, and asked if I am he! So, hopefully, when they’re scouring the car-boot sales and junk shops, and doing ‘house clearances’ when someone dies, or when they’re offered a few old pocket-knives by a seller, rather than passing them up, they’ll realise they can make a quick profit selling them to Yours Truly.

Unfortunately, the car-boot sales are almost all closed for the winter, as are many of the antique fairs and jumble sales. There are less people shopping in the markets, less people bringing goods to sell, and a number of the traders I regularly buy from have shut up shop for the whole of January. It’s been a rather dismal month, but then I expected that. I keep looking anyway, in my local market, and further afield, looking forward to sunnier days and better rewards.

Yesterday, I was doing the rounds of the market, and I didn’t see anything at all worth buying. There’s a nice chap I’ve bought one or two things off, who specialises in old coins and pocket-watches, but who often tells me he has a whole box of knives somewhere at home. I look forward to the day he finds them, if it ever comes, yesterday certainly wasn’t it. He recognised me as I passed his stall though, and told me that someone had left a bag of knives for me, for which the bloke wanted a fiver (£5). Usually these job-lots are a mixed bag, but you might find one or two decent knives in with the rest. So, I paid him and took them home.



There were 10 knives in the bag, so it’s hard to believe they wouldn’t be worth £5, but what a dreadful pile of rubbish it contained. I’m sure the market-trader sold them on to me in good faith, perhaps he was even sold them in good faith, but the original owner of what is left of these knives wants horse-whipping in my opinion. What kind of moron treats his tools like this? It’s bad enough that someone would break one knife blade using it as a pry-bar, but to work your way through a whole pile of them, snapping blade after blade, that’s a special kind of stupid. As you can see from the photos, the state of the knives was disgraceful, and most of them have blades snapped off. They were scarcely worth the cost and effort involved in cleaning them.

I separated them into two piles, the first might be worth a little effort, the second not really worth any.





In the latter pile were two Chinese-made SAK-copies, the sort that get sold here for as little as the equivalent of $1. Both had one of their covers missing, and were otherwise in a filthy and decrepid state. The German Scout knife might have been a little more interesting if it had not had a blade completely snapped off, and the tip snapped off another. Like the Richards 4-blade Scout knife it also has terrible blade-play, undoubtedly from prying. The fourth knife may well be the cheapest-looking knife I have ever come across, in the American sense of the word (in Britain, the word ‘cheap’ simply means inexpensive), it’s like someone has stuck an old knife blade between two pieces from an aluminium-foil takeaway container, from which they’ve also fashioned an awl. I’m almost tempted to clean this one up!





That’s the worst of the rubbish out of the way, now for the rest of it.









The ruler-knife was in an absolutely filthy state, as you can see, and if it was not a Chesterman’s ruler, I might not have bothered with it. Chesterman’s (later Rabone & Chesterman) had a large Sheffield factory on Pomona Street, backing onto the River Porter, one of Sheffield’s small, but important rivers. My grandmother was born on Pomona Street, and she worked at Chesterman’s as a young girl, as did her mother, and much later my brother’s godfather. The rulers in which the company specialised were made from long strips of steel of various widths, and many Sheffield workmen had off-cut rulers in their tool-boxes, made from the strip-ends. Chesterman’s produced rulers for other companies to advertise their names, and this penknife carries the name of a company in Darlington. I imagine it was intended to be given to the company’s clients. I had not expected to find the name of another manufacturer on the blade tangs, and there is none. It may have been manufactured by any number of Sheffield cutlery companies, or possibly it may even have been put together in-house. Unfortunately, it’s not much of a knife now, but I’ll keep that one, the smell reminds me of walking past the rear of the factory many times as a young child, and the knife makes me think of my Gran.





The Crossland Brothers pen-knife has not only lost a blade, but the tip of the remaining blade is damaged. It’s interesting that in terms of the tang-stamp, prominence is given to ‘England’ rather than to ‘Sheffield’.







I forget the name of this pattern with the Wharncliffe blade, but I think it would have been quite a nice knife once. The remaining blade still has plenty of snap in it, but I’m unable to make out the maker. The bone covers have a lovely grain to them, but I’m unsure exactly what they’re made of.









There’s not much left of the Wigfall. A shame as I don’t have anything else from this old Sheffield firm.

Though it has been neglected, the Richards Pen (the fourth knife in the group pic above) seems to have got away with its blades intact, and indeed they’re still sharp, so perhaps this one came from a different lot, or perhaps it was lucky, and the original owner ran out of paint-cans to open, or went to meet his maker (or a big pitchfork) before he got round to snapping the blades of another knife.

Jack
 
I really enjoy finding old slip joints my self I usually won't spend more than give bucks unless if I really like it I got a 70's case penut and a old kabar Barlow this way
 
For $8.20 USD, roughly the equivalent of 5 pounds, I agree, it was a marginal value. It seems it was fun "unveiling" the tang stamps, and also getting a connection to Gran though. To me it would have been worth the money.
Thanks for letting me meander along!!
I have long given up trying to find anything interesting anywhere near me at Flea Markets etc. But I have had some good luck when I visit American cities.
 
Nice haul :thumbup: The scales on that 2 blade Wharnie whittler are definitely not bone but ivory :eek: I would have paid a tenner for that one alone , I like stripping the old ones down removing broken blades or grinding new ones to suit ,then putting them back to work ! Keep rescuing and Ihope the weathers better oop North than here down South :D
 
On the knife with the obscured tang marking, the pattern itself was historicly called "Wharncliffe".

A cut from the 1930 Simmons Hardware jobber catalog pattern guide:
29koqhg.png


The same catalog had a blade identification guide and the blade was also referred to as a "Wharncliffe" pattern blade.

il92it.png
 
On the knife with the obscured tang marking, the pattern itself was historicly called "Wharncliffe".

A cut from the 1930 Simmons Hardware jobber catalog pattern guide:
29koqhg.png


The same catalog had a blade identification guide and the blade was also referred to as a "Wharncliffe" pattern blade.

il92it.png

I much prefer single blade slip joints, but that pattern you posted is one of my favorites. I love the curves of the frame, which contrasts very nicely with the straight edge of the wharncliffe main.

- Christian
 
Thanks for the tale Jack. I love that little wharncliffe. Sure looks like ivory from the pic. That's my kind of wreck.

Best regards

Robin
 
Many thanks gents for all the comments and helpful info gents, very much appreciated. I've got a head full of WD40! :D

I hope the weathers better oop North than here down South :D

It's been wet, but we've not suffered in the same way, hope you're not among those worst affected. Thanks to you and Codger for kicking my brain into gear :thumbup:

Sure looks like ivory from the pic.

Didn't you say that last time?! :D Yeah, I reckon so, a shame it's been so badly abused (probably by a recent owner I reckon too) :(
 
I am seeing as much variety in the history written on those knives as the ages and patterns of the knives themselves. Each one has it's own story to tell. Some are interesting, some are sad. I see neglect on some, hard use on others, abuse on some. I see many hands on a few of them, original owner who appreciated a nice knife and was willing to pay the vig to own it. A subsequent owner who acquired it on the cheap and put it to work, often on harder tasks that those for which it was intended. Some were disrespected and ridden hard like a rented mule until they were left gasping in a drawer or old toolbox somewhere while the owner found another cheap replacement. In fact several of those may have had the same owner who tossed each in the pile as it broke rather than in the rubbish bin, the fate of many knives over the years. More than one might have been the first knife of a youngster, all bright and shiney and sharp on Christmas day or a birthday. And his learning took a toll on the knife until it too was tossed in a drawer or perhaps a cigar box with a forgotten top or yoyo. Several of them, after some attention, still have some useful knife life left in them and would delight some lad who has never owned a knife of any description. And of course some are clunkers like a wrecked, worn out car that might be useful for a few parts some years down the road, waiting in the weeds for someone to come along needing a shield, a spring or a blade. I like grab bags of old knives. I like reading old knives. Thanks for sharing. :thumbup:
 
Good post Codger, and thanks again for your help :thumbup:

I do believe that all of the knives may have had the same owner, (I'll clarify when I next gead to the market), but like you, I think that many of them would have had prior owners, who perhaps treated them with more care, something that makes the snapping of their blades all the sadder. I often buy a few knives that have come from the same source, and they are frequently worn with character, perhaps worked a bit too hard in some cases, but are often still sharp. The Richards penknife is a pattern I find regularly, and it's quite sharp, but it's the exception. Perhaps that got slipped in the bag at the last minute, or maybe the guy who broke or bent the other blades just hadn't got round to that one yet. Hard to understand why he didn't buy himself a pry-bar or an old screwdriver.
 
Good points but... what man of means to just go out and buy a new knife would go to the trouble to gather and bag, then try to peddle essentially scrap knives? The man was doubtful the owner of the ivory handled knife when it was new. No, I'd guess that the gatherer/bagger/seller was a picker... getting them cheap or free from wherver he came across them. Possibly a collector getting rid of the dross of previous group buys where he kept the better ones and bagged these. But then very little of this can be known as fact. Still a cool hodgepodge of knives and relics of knives.
 
I know the weather is a sensitive subject in England and I do so love a bad pun- but the flood of memories from the smell and feel of an old ruler penknife?That is beyond any currency.For 5squid I reckon you got a bargain.:thumbup: with the hidden bonus of this thread and we get to postulate the lives of these blades -even the poor ones!-and by association the kind of people that owned them .It s fantastic.
Your passion for history and specifically the history of Sheffield knives is cooler than the last beer in Fonzies fishbox at a hot rod swap meet.
Cheers.
 
If you got an afternoon's entertainment out of looking through that bag o' scrap, then it's a better bargain than most movie tickets. :)
Plus, I think you could make that Wharncliffe usable. Maybe even drill out the pin at the broken blade and put in a bail?
 
Oh, my internet connection is SO bad tonight! Grrr! :(

Good points but... what man of means to just go out and buy a new knife would go to the trouble to gather and bag, then try to peddle essentially scrap knives? The man was doubtful the owner of the ivory handled knife when it was new. No, I'd guess that the gatherer/bagger/seller was a picker... getting them cheap or free from wherver he came across them. Possibly a collector getting rid of the dross of previous group buys where he kept the better ones and bagged these. But then very little of this can be known as fact. Still a cool hodgepodge of knives and relics of knives.

I slightly know the guy (Dave) who left the knives for me, he's a business partner of the other chap. Both are clueless about knives. I shall investigate further when I next visit the market! :thumbup:

I know the weather is a sensitive subject in England and I do so love a bad pun- but the flood of memories from the smell and feel of an old ruler penknife?That is beyond any currency.For 5squid I reckon you got a bargain.:thumbup: with the hidden bonus of this thread and we get to postulate the lives of these blades -even the poor ones!-and by association the kind of people that owned them .It s fantastic.
Your passion for history and specifically the history of Sheffield knives is cooler than the last beer in Fonzies fishbox at a hot rod swap meet.
Cheers.

Thanks for the kind words my friend :)

If you got an afternoon's entertainment out of looking through that bag o' scrap, then it's a better bargain than most movie tickets. :)

True! :D
 
I think you did well, between the ruler knife and the wharncliffe. And vendors are bringing knives to you now- that can't be bad.
 
A few more ruminations:

The Chesterman knife has a snapped blade and the tip and the edge near the tip of the other blade is turned over slightly. The Wigfall has a snapped blade, but no apparent damage to the other, which is arguably not very suitable for prying, being too pointed. The Whittler has a snapped blade, and the same could be said of the Wharncliffe blade as per the Wigfall Pen. The Crossland has a snapped blade and the tip of the other blade is broken slightly. Both blades of the Richards Pen are undamaged, and they would certainly have broken or bent if subjected to the sort of side pressure required to snap the other blades. Both the Richards Scout and the cheapie with the pressed metal covers have slightly bent blades, and the blade on the Richards has considerable side-to-side play. The Solingen SAK copy has had both knife blades snapped. The knife blades on both of the Chinese SAK copies have considerable side to side play and the blades do not sit straight, but they may have been like that when they left the factory, which could also be said of the Richards knife and the cheapie.

It would appear to me that certainly the knives with the snapped blades (and possibly most of the others) have all at some point been either owned by the same person, who abused them each in much the same way, or they were all together in the same PLACE, a workshop or garage for example, where they were used and abused by several people in much the same manner. These knives could have come together in any number of ways, being found in vehicles that passed through a garage or scrapyard, brought into work by different people over many years, inherited all together, bought in a job lot in a junk shop, cleared out of a derelict house after someone had died, confiscated by a teacher or at the entrance to a nightclub. I doubt that one person, who clearly cared nothing about knives, kept on going out and buying them individually, however inexpensive they were, as he progressively snapped their blades. I think it more likely that these knives were just on hand, and when they could no longer be used as pry-bars, they were just thrown back in a tool-box or thrown in the corner of a workshop.

So then perhaps the person who latterly owned these knives, the abuser, died, or went into an old people’s home or prison, or got evicted, or just decided to clear out his garage. Alternatively, perhaps a workshop or garage was torn down. They then ended up, together with a load of other junk being sold for a pittance at auction or removed as part of a house clearance. Most of the stuff on the flea-markets comes this way.

Of course, there are many alternatives, one of which is that they were part of much bigger collection accumulated over several years, perhaps by a junk dealer, and that the feller who brought them down to the market simply picked out all the rubbish! :D
 
I think you did well, between the ruler knife and the wharncliffe. And vendors are bringing knives to you now- that can't be bad.

Aye, I've done pretty well out of these job lots in the past, though I usually pay a bit more and examine them first :)
 
Back
Top