A dilemma.

Joined
Sep 28, 2005
Messages
4,527
I find myself in unfamiliar waters here, and would like some input from the fine people around here. This spring at an antique show, this little guy followed me home for $20:

784E5BDD-AE6E-441C-8CDC-49A98EBDDCEA-2925-0000030CADA0DED7.jpg


549FA396-035D-4D37-BE82-CC4CAD6A8C4C-2925-0000030CCE97938B.jpg


It's C.T. Skelton & Co Sheffield pruner, solid stag covers that still fit very well, pinched/lined/outlined bolsters, steel pommel, square and flush tang:handle (not sure if this is the proper term), firm solid opening and closing (little snap opening, not much closing but very solid feel). Swedge on pile side, swayback, pins with small circular impressions (punched?). Many things that I have not had on a slipjoint before, so I thought it would be a good candidate for my first older pruner. 7 1/4" open, 4 1/4" closed, 3" blade

My dilemma is this- Is this going to be the first slipjoint that I leave alone? I haven't sharpened it (yet), but would like to, although it has been used well in the past, I'm not sure if it is old/special enough to leave it, or sharpen it up and put it to use as it was meant to be. I've never had this series of thoughts enter my brain before, so it is foreign to me.

I may put this up in Levine's forum to find out more about its heritage (unless that information is shown to me here), but I wanted a user and collector POV, And I know I won't get the user POV there, but would here. The knife is still solid and has been a worker- guess I am looking more for arguments on why I shouldn't cut my apple tree with it. If it turns out to be rare/desirable/collectible it may sit on the desk, but I am pretty close to sharpening it, holding myself back until this discussion.

Some more pics to give a full picture:
03bc39a1.jpg

6F79FDD9-3F83-4C47-BB18-515696B9B4E5-4325-000005C799484A07.jpg

ce77e655.jpg

3b279d40.jpg


It's a slippery slope not using a knife I bought, I have to tread carefully here!!
 
That's a very cool-lookin' knife. :thumbup:

I'd be tempted (obviously :D) to put new edge on it. BUT, I think your mention of posting in Levine's forum is a very good idea. I'd wait to hear what he has to say about it, before 'altering' it, in any way.
 
I can't imagine that putting a fresh edge on that would hurt it. It is a beautiful knife. I'd sharpen it and use it...that is if I had anything to prune. I wouldn't start cutting linoleum with it mind you but if I had a couple a rowdy rose bushes I wouldn't be afraid to put 'er to use.
 
I have no info about this maker, BRL should be a good place to look for info. This is a knife and it meant to be sharp, so go ahead and sharpen it. It is a beautiful knife and great example to Sheffield golden age of knives making. Good find.
Mike
 
I very rarely buy something I won't use. I've done it. That stuff eventually goes back on the block.

Very personal issue. You'll have to look at your own compass, I'm afraid.
 
Shoot Gary or I a PM if you want this thread moved.

I think asking in the BRL forum would be wisdom.
 
Thanks Frank- I wanted this post here to get the user or not opinion, and to show it off to this crowd. I'll try to get better pics for BL's forum and post there for more history.
 
Shoot Gary or I a PM if you want this thread moved.

I think asking in the BRL forum would be wisdom.

I wholeheartedly concur.. That said, I see no reason for very carefully hand sharpening and lightly using her with care for a hand full of roses for your significant others if you choose. She is after all a fine old cutting tool for just such a chore.. Besides, from the sound of your OP, I'm convinced you'll be happier when you sharpen and use her a little.

Best,
Anthony
 
Hey guys ..lets not forget about Mick's thread( Wellington), he is an authority on English knives as well
http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/s...Made-in-Sheffield-quot-1830-1930-A-golden-age

and the thread could do with an awakening! ( not to say anything bad about Bernards thread either by the way!!)
Chris...I see it this way, once you have bought the knife and that was a good buy by the way my friend,...you HAVE the knife... doesnt matter what you do with it now...you HAVE it!...thats when I am most pleased when buying a great old knife...then I give it the Mineral oil treatment, and as Im wiping and exercising the joints etc...I am y\thinking of which direction this knife is going-edc box, or Garden box or into my safe queen storage.
 
I knew what direction I was leaning, I just did not want to do so uneducated. With BRL saying the blade is 50% and re-pinned I guess it's a good to go knife now! Interesting to me that neither knife I bought was from a recognizable company! Makes them even more mine now!
 
Guys,
I just traded this "same"knife to a dealer for a Shatt & Morgan.that I wanted.Your knife originally came in a plastic cover with a cardbard back....stating the knife was from England & touting it as "almost Handmade! I originally traded for it(yrs.ago)for EDC.Hope I helped a little.
Jim
 
Guys,
I just traded this "same"knife to a dealer for a Shatt & Morgan.that I wanted.Your knife originally came in a plastic cover with a cardbard back....stating the knife was from England & touting it as "almost Handmade! I originally traded for it(yrs.ago)for EDC.Hope I helped a little.
Jim

Say What Again??. Please explain??.
 
Sunny,
Just stating i had the same make as pictured....I acquired the knife about 2yrs ago to use as a edc.Decided to not use it for edc & use it for trade bait.I traded it last week!
Jim
 
Do you have any pics of the knife you traded? I would have thought my knife would have predated plastic shell packaging. Was yours a Skelton as well or a different maker?
 
I'd sharpen it carefully and use it. The hawkbill point is already rounded off slightly anyway.
 
Sunny,
It was the same as your picture.I saw the guy I traded it too 7 it is now his edcJim
 
Back
Top