There is no such thing as a dumb question, especially here....!!!
I am sure many here are like you and have the very same questions. They might not now but did so in the beginning. I know I was like this. I had only spent more than $30 bucks on a knife once and that was the famed Buck 110. I then went up to $60 and bought a Kershaw 1050 which I feel is like a Buck 110 on steroids. Then I went WAY overboard and bought the Buckmaster for $200. I thought that was outrageous, but it was discontinued, so paid it.
Fast forward several years and I was very eager to try more Hollow Handle survival knives. I started looking for something even better than the Buckmaster. I then stumbled upon the company of Chris Reeve Knives. I looked and saw the prices ( this was when the One Piece Knives were still being made ) and was like WOW.....$300+ for some of them. I liked the spearpoint models and thought I would try one of them. I settled on the small Shadow III. I figured it was the cheapest at $175 and if I did not like it, I could resell it.......Well, I did not only LIKE it, I LOVED it and within a few days ordered the Tanto I for $350. I remember not even making it home when I got the Tanto I and pulled off the side of the road to open it. You might say after that my friend, I was hooked....lol.
Well, after acquiring several of the OPK, I thought, heck, if the OPK are this nice, I wonder how the folders are. So, around Christmas, I stumbled upon a Large Regular Sebenza for $280. Little did I know at the time, it had the famed BG-42 blade steel....Well then, I was hooked on the sebenza.
Fast Fast Forward several years and I have owned 101 Chris Reeve Knives. And NO, I do not currently have 101, I have owned that many over the years. Some were sold and traded for others, some were just sold. I still have a nice few though.
So since your mainly questioning the Sebenza and its toughness, I will stick with that.
Are they worth it.....YES. I have tried pretty much every comparable brand out there and I have ALWAYS come back to CRK. I like them, they are simple...!!! Quality is unmatched. Customer Service is unmatched. The Fan Base is unmatched.
I have carried sebenzas for years now and I have never even come close to wearing one out. and I KNOW I could go a lifetime and never do so under normal use, even some extreme use. I use them for what they were designed for....That is To CUT. They are not pry bars, axes, etc. I have cut the backs of shingles with them, I have cut tar paper, I have whittled, food prep, cut loads of cardboard and they have always come through with flying colors. There are blade steels that I like over others, styles I like over others, but all in all, its still a sebenza. The framelock will not wear out under normal use and the above I have stated.
As for the Spa, I think many people buy a used one and want it minty perfect, so they send it in. There is a difference with having a lock issue and the spa. In my experience, most lock issues are because a previous owner though they were "Chris Reeve" and tried to fix it, when they could not, they sold it off to someone else. I have had that happen to me with me being the "someone else". If you plan to use it though, really no need for the spa. Used to cost $35 for a full spa, which included reblasting scales and the works. Not sure now as it may have went up a few bucks. I did send One in once and the service is top notch, looked like new when it came back.
Chris does offer blade replacement, but at the cost of a new blade. They used to cost $120, but I don't know what its up to now as I have never needed one.
As for a replacement blade, I cant ever see this being needed under normal use and if you know how to sharpen a knife. Honestly, I dont even know if I have sharpened my sebenza 25 this year yet and I use it all the time. I ONLY use the Spyderco Sharpmaker. I also carry a CGG Classic and just broke down to sharpening it which I have not in months as well and after about a dozen passes on the sharpmaker, it was hair shaving sharp again. What I am trying to get at is you dont need to sit here with the sharpmaker for hours trying to sharpen something that is already sharp.
What do I get out of a CRK.....??? The joy of owning one is easily the first thing. Its like the Rolls Royce of the knife industry. Yes there are other makers out there that are even more $$$, but none of them and I repeat NONE of them come close to CRK in quality, reliability, performance, and just the damn joy of ownership. The ONLY company that I would put WITH CRK would be Hinderer. Rick & Rob are great guys to deal with as well. Strider.....I am just not going there.
Does anyone use their sebenzas....??? I sure do. I even started the famed thread " What did you use your sebenza for today "....??? I have some that I have never carried, I have some that I have carried and used ALOT. I have even LOST a sebenza. I have run the gammot of CRK use.
And YES, I love "snail trails" on my sebenza. Every scratch and scuff on my sebenza is an adventure I was on with my sebenza.....!!!
I hope I answered your questions. If I missed something, ask away. There are TONS of other friendly CRK fans here on this page that can attest to what I have stated above.
Enjoy...!!!