A good trade got a whole lot better (quite unexpectedly)

Joined
Jan 9, 2012
Messages
3,331
When I was just getting back into enjoying traditional slip joint knives a couple months ago I bought a Northfield 73 Scout because I was intrigued by the primitive bone. It proved to be too thick to pocket carry, and almost impossible to open. The gentleman who sold it to me graciously took it back in exchange for an ebony Tidioute 68 White Owl (and kindly refunded me the difference in cost).

I am still attracted to the primitive bone, so when I saw the Northfield 65 Ben Hogan that B Hess had listed for sale, I became instantly interested. He kindly answered all my questions, even entertained my trade offer. Probably against better judgment (because I tend to prefer smaller knives), I jumped, and we agreed to terms. The 65 arrived yesterday, and I really like the look of the bone on this one.

But here is the kicker. When I pulled out the Certificate of Authenticity I see that this knife was manufactured on February 4, 2011. That would have been my grandfather's 99th birthday -- the man responsible for my love of pocket knives.

I have posted before about the Schrade Walden 708Y I gave him on what turned out to be his last Christmas with us, and my grandmother gave back to me the following Christmas. Here it is. That Schrade is the knife in my avatar.

Now I have two knives that are fitting tributes to a man loved by everyone who knew him, the man for whom I named my son.

If ever there was a man the complete opposite of Ben Hogan, for whom this knife is named, it was my grandfather. He was never one to assert himself or push his opinions on anyone, but everyone respected his wisdom. He would never own such a large, and what he would consider ostentatious knife, but I still think it fitting. His love for others and wise counsel often proved to bear larger than expected fruit in the lives of those he touched, so I don't mind one bit having a somewhat larger than expected knife by which to remember and honor him.

BenHogan1.jpg


BenHogan2.jpg
 
Very nice Doug!! Good looking PB and I like the long pull on the thin clip. My only #65 is the same way but in red wine bone.
 
That's a great looking knife, Doug! I'm sure everyone's taste is a little different, but to my eye that's about the prettiest Primitive Bone I've ever seen from GEC. Congratulations, and thanks for the nice story to go along with the pics. I was eyeballing that one myself shortly after it was listed in the "For Sale" section - loved the Primitive Bone but wasn't sure about ole' Ben (the pattern). ;) I'm glad you got it, and it sounds like a fitting tribute to your grandfather. :thumbup:
 
An awesome story, and a great looking knife too!

I'll have to investigate a Primitive Bone GEC one of these days...
 
Great story, most excellent knife, and you have also found a great fellow to work with on collecting fine traditional pocket knives!

Thanks for the pictures!

best

mqqn
 
That's a great looking knife, Doug! I'm sure everyone's taste is a little different, but to my eye that's about the prettiest Primitive Bone I've ever seen from GEC.
Thanks Keith. I am pleased with it too.

As you can see the sunlight is different in the two pictures, much warmer in the second, which in my opinion shows the bone in its truer appearance. The reason for that is I set the knife on top of the blue bird house and took several pictures from which to choose the best. Only when I had reviewed them and chosen one (the first picture posted) did I realize that I only took shots of the mark side. So, back out into the yard I went for shots of the other side. Once I realized the difference I should have taken better shots of the mark side, but by that time the sun had changed again, so I decided to go with what I had.

Thanks to all for the nice comments. I wish you could have known my dad's dad. He was a kind and gentle man, but with a keen sense of humor, and a love of pranks. I still can't believe all I gleaned from him that shapes who I am today, in just 10 years we had together.
 
The reason for that is I set the knife on top of the blue bird house and took several pictures from which to choose the best.

I know that different monitors often calibrate colors differently, but I'm fairly certain that birdhouse isn't blue. ;)

Great pictures, Doug, and better story.

~ P.
 
A very apt comment on a thread about my grandfather. If he had not beat you to it, he would have laughed as soon as he heard it!

bluebird house

Better?
 
A very apt comment on a thread about my grandfather. If he had not beat you to it, he would have laughed as soon as he heard it!

bluebird house

Better?

Yup!

I once read a thread about a man commissioning a guitar in black walnut. I told a long story about "red wine glasses" (and my step-grandmother's procurement of the same-- *red* wine glasses) before pointing out, "Son, that guitar ain't black."

Whooosh. In response, I received a very patient post explaining that "black walnut" was a type of tree/wood.

I'm glad you saw what I did there (albeit with a winky thing, as a Clue just in case), and didn't respond by explaining bluebirds and their houses to me real-ly slow-ly.

Cheers. :)

~ P.
 
Seriously, that is just the kind of comment he would make. My dad and I, and my son have all inherited the trait (and from what I have been told, my grandfather got it honestly from his dad). Drives the women in our family crazy! Here's another odd connection between us. For five generations in our family the oldest son was born in a year ending in 2. My great-grandfather was born in 1892, my grandfather in 1912, my dad in 1942, me in 1962, and my son in 1992. He completed the century cycle, being born 100 years after my great-grandfather.

So there is you useless information, completely unrelated to the thread, data for the evening.
 
Great looking primitive bone on that. Also a spectacular pattern. It is definitely on my short list of must haves!
 
Seriously, that is just the kind of comment he would make. My dad and I, and my son have all inherited the trait (and from what I have been told, my grandfather got it honestly from his dad). Drives the women in our family crazy! Here's another odd connection between us. For five generations in our family the oldest son was born in a year ending in 2. My great-grandfather was born in 1892, my grandfather in 1912, my dad in 1942, me in 1962, and my son in 1992. He completed the century cycle, being born 100 years after my great-grandfather.

So there is you useless information, completely unrelated to the thread, data for the evening.
Three people in my family so far have died on January 23. It seems like there is a pattern to some things.
 
Hi Doug!

I really like that pattern and the Primitive Bone. Thank you for the story.

For pocket carry it seems really to be a little big. But I think it seems to be really good for any backpocket carrying.

Kind regards
Andi
 
Very nice knife Doug. And some great memories to go with it. It could not have found a better home.
 
Thanks for the kind words everyone. I posted the following in the daily carry thread, I guess it belongs better here.

Here's an update on the Hogan. I had decided to use it primarily for food prep slicing tasks, since it is too large to comfortably pocket carry. After yard work this afternoon I relaxed on the screened porch, and used it to slice an apple for a refreshing treat. Later I used it in dinner preparation: primarily slicing onions and checking the boiling potatoes for done. It is starting to develop a nice, natural patina.

BenHoganApr7a.jpg


BenHoganApr7b.jpg
 
Beautiful knife, great patina and the added soul to the knife is awesome.
I really enjoy these pics, great way of showing off the Primitive Bone Doug. :thumbup:

I love my Hogan, it's a beast of a knife, I just never carry it enough. I think it would really succeed as a great food prep knife.
 
Great looking.

I must have bigger pockets. I carry a grandad barlow (even a two bladed version) in my front pockets all the time.
 
I must have bigger pockets. I carry a grandad barlow (even a two bladed version) in my front pockets all the time.
I think it's just a matter of what you are comfortable with. I don't even like to carry pocket change.

My slim Wadsworth sleeveboard, Camillus pony jack, or my Case peanut or mini copperhead are about as big as I like to carry, unless I have jeans on. Then I can go with something slightly larger like the Northfield White Owl, or even the Böker Tree Brand Stockman.
 
Back
Top