advice needed (big blade vs. axe)

Originally posted by Crayola
Don't forget the "I enjoy it" factor too. If you are a bowie kind of guy, get a large bowie. It may not chop as well as other tools, but it definitely will do the deed and you'll enjoy carrying it and using it.

Heh, that's what it's all about, eh? When asked, I typically advocate a minimal amount of well-chosen gear. In reality, when I hit the woods, my motivation is often that I camp so I can enjoy my tools, rather than bringing my tools so I can enjoy my camping. I usually bring way more knives than I need to :) What gets used most is the high-performance fixed-blade (TTKK, AGR Deerhunter), with the big chopper and the folder being used much more rarely.

neetone is obviously more purpose-driven though. Based on what he wrote, I might be thinking hatchet or even axe.

Joe
 
For hiking or backpacking I would go with a big knife and a light weight folding saw. If you are just going out to gather and chop firewood, sure - bring an axe with a full length handle. When carrying a backpack though, the main factor is weight (try to keep to the bare essentials).

When I'm camping I bring a camp axe to chop wood. When I'm hiking, I take the basic 9, a folder, and a ceramic rod to restore a good field edge. But, by all means - carry what makes you HAPPY! :) I agree with Crayola there. If you carry what you like, you will like what you carry. 'nuff said.
 
Neetones - I assume your forays into the "wilds" are on foot and not horseback, ATV, canoe, boat, snowmachine, etc. What you should carry depends greatly on where you will be carrying it. Look at the history of indigenous peoples and you'll see a variety of methods for dealing with excursions into the wilds. In South America, give a Yanomano indian an 18" machete and he'll do just fine. He can use the machete to fashion tools and clothing from the biological materials at hand. In temperate and sub artic climates where the need for fire may extend beyond cooking, an 18" machete will still work okay, but not as well as a saw or camp axe mated with a small fixed blade knife. Northern indians tended to carry a flint knife and a flint hand axe, but only if steel versions were not available. Having to use your cutting tools as weapons should not be overlooked. Saws, like the folding Swede saw, are great until the blade breaks or they need sharpening. They don't make for good weapons. A camp axe is fairly easy to sharpen with a flat rock, can be used as a splitting wedge, a hammer for breaking up rocks or ice (chopping a hole in a frozen lake for water is much easier with an axe than a large fixed blade), for chopping wood and breastbones, and they make pretty good weapons. The small fixed blade can be used for all other cutting chores. Even so, if I had only one cutting instrument to carry anywhere, it would be a 7 to 9 inch fixed blade knife made of a tough steel, like INFI or Carbon 5. My survival kit, which is designed for carry around my waist, contains a handpowered chain saw, a SAK, and a small fixed blade. The remaining space is devoted to fire starters, wire and cord.
 
Has anyone read Gary Paulsen's "Hatchet" series? This kid gets a hatchet when he goes to visit his dad in Canada. The bush plane goes down and the pilot dies, so the kid has to survive using only the hatchet. He does pretty well, too. The first book is "Hatchet", the second I think is "Brian's Winter", then "The River" and a new one that I can't remember.

Asha'man
 
The best portable chopper I've found for easy carry is the Ax International Pac-Ax.

632719.jpg


It folds down into an amazingly small package and comes with a nice belt pouch. Unfolding takes only a second but it chops like a real handaxe.

I got mine from REI.

--Bob Q
 
Back
Top