Advice sought on buying Dremel

Joined
Apr 3, 2002
Messages
253
Any Dremel experts out there?
I'm about to buy a Dremel (or similar tool, I only know of the Dremel) and wondered if any users could throw in their opinions.
As well as a bit of polishing and light grinding on blades, it'll be used for just about everything so I want to get one that I won't think about changing after a year.
I'll always be working near an outlet so is the cordless neccessary?
I would choose between the cordless 7800, or the mains 395 or 3981.
Any advice would be appreciated.
Cheers

apolpgies for cross post in bladesmith forum
 
I owned and used a Dremel 5000-30000rmp model for several years until I dropped it and it broke. As a replacement I bought a Black and Decker RTX because of a few reasons...

1. I liked the form factor better for the B and D. Looks and feels better IMHO.

2. The B & D has more power as far as amps and torque.

3. The B & D will stay on a set RPM unlike my Dremel which with the sliding lever, would increase speed on its own with the vibration of the unit.

4. The B & D can be turned off and back on while keeping the dial at the preset RPM whereas the Dremel had to use the speed adjuster to dial it down to 0 RPM to cut off. This feature is helpful when you are working on something that requires a constant speed to keep results even. You can turn it off and not worry about getting the speed right when you cut it back on.

5. The B&D has a keyless chuck that is just like that on a drill, whereas the Dremel has a keyless chuck that uses one of two size collets that need to be interchanged depending on the size bit you use. This can be quite an annoyance. The B&D will automatically adjust to fit any bit. Keep in mind that any bit made by Dremel will work in the B&D and vise versa, so don't let the abundance of Dremel-made bits as opposed to the lack of B&D-made bits affect your decision. I'm still using all the bits that I had with my old Dremel.

You do need to realize that I'm comparing the model I had to the B&D, not all models. The one I had is still made and sold, but they do make one with a digital adjustment where you push a button to adjust speed, but this is probably too stepped in increments from 1-10 whereas the wheel on the B&D is true variable. You can leave the speed just above or below a specific setting if you want. I believe the digital model divides the speed from 5000 to 30000 in 10 increments which is a change of at least 2500rmp per setting. Also, the Dremel has been around for a lot longer than the B&D model, so I cannot say how long the B&D will hold up. My Dremel lasted several years before I got clumsy. Also, the bushings on the Dremel are easily changed and readily available where Dremels are sold. Also, the Dremel has more attachments available, which will surely change as the B&D becomes more popular.

Either way, you are sure to get a good tool. It will be basically personal preference. The looks and feel of the B&D is what ultimately made me get it instead of another Dremel. Just be sure to get one that is truly variable in speed with a top speed of at least 30,000 rpm. As far as the cordless, stay away from it. It is a lot slower, and only useful if you aren't working around an outlet, which you said you would be. Go to Lowes or Wal-Mart and get a feel for each model before you decide. Also, keep the receipt, as you can always change your mind and exchange it if done in a reasonable amount of time.

Mike
 
I have an old one and a newer one. The new one goes to 35,000rpm where the old one only went to 30,000rpm. AS far as B&D goes, their tool don't seem as well made as tehy once were to me. The Dremel has a keyless chuck as well, but I prefer the collets as they seem to hold the cuting tool tighter to me. The ability to start and stop the tool without changing speed holds little interest to me as I'm usually turning the tool off to change bits, which will be used at a different speed anyway.

My advice is to get a 395 kit that includes the flexi-shaft attachment. I find the flexi-shaft allows me a lot more flexibility rather than trying to guide the tool and fight the gyroscopic action that the fast spinning stator in the motor causes. With the flex-shaft, you can use the cutting head like a pencil and not have to fight to get the cutter to go where you want. I just hang the motor from an L bracket near my vise and go to town.

I find the Dremel off discs to be one of the greatest tools ever invented.


jmx
 
Originally posted by jmxcpter
My advice is to get a 395 kit that includes the flexi-shaft attachment. jmx

Great advice here! You might also consider the drill press, I use mine alot. I also use the cutting discs but we use the sanding drums a bunch.
Stay Safe,
Clyde
 
Thanks for the advice guys, I've been hunting around on the net and although I've found ones from B&D, Rotozip, Minicraft and Bosch, I think I'll probably go for the 3981 kit.
The Dremel seems to have been around a long time, and spares and repairs look easier. Their site even has an owner's club and forum!
 
Here's one of my Dremel projects. Took an $8 livestock cane from the local seed & feed and turned it into a fine tactical whacker.
Stay Safe,
Clyde
 

Attachments

  • tactical whacker.jpg
    tactical whacker.jpg
    61.3 KB · Views: 129
I would go with the Dremel just for all the accessories. I own a 395 type5 - 5,000 to 30'000 rpm (it was top dog when I bought it, about 6 years ago)
I just used it to put a finger groove on my BM 814 pocket clip, once you have one it will become a favorite tool.
 
Back
Top