Advice....

Dysentery Bob

BOUNCED EMAIL: I need to update my email address in my profile!
Joined
Jan 29, 2004
Messages
166
Howdy, knife nut that has started looking at getting a khukuri. I plan to put this in my patrol bag and use if the need arises while on duty. Now I have been to both sites; Himalayan Imports and Khukuri House.

Of the two, I have found 2 khukuri that I kind of like,

http://www.gurkhas-kukris.com/catalog/product.php?id=3839fa874
http://www.gurkhas-kukris.com/catalog/product.php?id=3638fc98

Now I notice that the prices of these blades are less than those of H.I, does that mean they are cheaply made and inferior to H.I?

Any advice is helpful and thanks.
 
Welcome Bob.
I'm biased- I believe HI is the number one Khukuri to have, the go to model to beat. I believe also you can get a decent product from other suppliers. Have you been to HI's web page and their shopping site? Lots of informative stuff to read on the web page particularly.

munk
 
If this is the same Dysentery Bob I used to do Laz runs with, good to see you again. If not, welcome anyway : )

By and large, HI seems to take a bit better care making their blades. I shopped carefully for my first khukuri and ended up getting all of them from Himalayan Imports. There's a superb guarantee too. It goes both ways. The smiths ( Kamis) get a good deal and medical etc. So smiles all 'round.

I just finished coming back from a camping trip where I used a baby khukuri (Bilton) to do all sorts of hard work. Never had a moment of doubt the knife could handle it. Still looks great too. Not bad for a 'beater' knife!
 
Morgane said:
If this is the same Dysentery Bob I used to do Laz runs with, good to see you again. If not, welcome anyway : )

By and large, HI seems to take a bit better care making their blades. I shopped carefully for my first khukuri and ended up getting all of them from Himalayan Imports. There's a superb guarantee too. It goes both ways. The smiths ( Kamis) get a good deal and medical etc. So smiles all 'round.

I just finished coming back from a camping trip where I used a baby khukuri (Bilton) to do all sorts of hard work. Never had a moment of doubt the knife could handle it. Still looks great too. Not bad for a 'beater' knife!

Yes it is....been a while. I am now with Cobb County Police in the North Atlanta Metro area. Left Savannah about 2 years ago.

I do have to appoligize...cant remember your character name? Old age you see and all the old duels that I participated in....or not doing what the wife ordered.
 
I've been buying khukuris for eight years now. When I first started, Himalayan Imports had already been in business for eleven years, but was experiencing some competition from the now defunct Gurkha House (the source of GH's khukuris was Khukuri House). GH and HI were both head and shoulders better than my first two khukuri shaped objects. HI's knives had better fit and finish, but GH's products were cheaper so I bought knives from both companies.

Over time though I picked up more and more knives from HI and stopped buying them KH products. The main reason was convenience. I can buy a knife from Yangdu and have it at my door within a few days. I haven't bought a knife directly from KH, but I'm pretty sure that it'll be a longer wait since their knives are coming from Nepal. Furthermore shipping from HI is free if you live in the US. KH's shipping fees are therefore quite high in comparison. And if you add the cost of shipping to the cost of the knives themselves then you quickly realize that KH isn't quite the bargain you thought it was.

Another reason that I like doing business with Himalayan Imports is its ironclad warranty. If your knife is faulty, they'll take care of it. I never thought that I would ever need to use the warranty on a khukuri, but an experience I had a couple of days reminded me that you just never know. We moved this weekend and needed to break down some old broken down furniture. For this task I chose my HI BGRS and my GH WWII. Both knives are 16.5", but the HI is a heavier and stouter knife. I didn't think it would be an issue however because the GH was plenty stout and it sported a thicker, more traditional convex edge than the one the BGRS had.

My brother took the WWII and I took the BGRS. We then split up the work and I took aim at an old desk while he proceeded to destroy some shelves. I was surprised to find that the desk was actually made of real wood. It took a while, but I managed to reduce it to kindling. Afterwards I examined both knives. The BGRS suffered no damage. I wish I could say the same about the Khukuri House blade. Despite the convex edge there were three large chips in the blade. The handle also cracked and the bolster was destroyed, having come apart at the weld. I think my brother hit some screws accidentally, but I'm still upset because I don't feel that this knife should have suffered such gross damage. I was watching him the whole time and he was only taking half-power swings from a very awkward position. Keep in mind that my brother is an accountant, not some lumberjack. If the KH knife had been constructed properly it should have suffered only minor damage. This wouldn't bother me if this was an HI because I know Yangdu would make it right. As it is I am now the owner of a worthless khukuri shaped object with no recourse. I'll chalk this one up to inexperience and part of the cost a person has to pay when learning about knives.
 
WELCOME DB!!!!!!!!!! I work in Marietta right near Dobbins on Delk.

I own both, started with KH, once I got my first HI I never have been tempted by KH again. The KH knives were not bad, but they aren't HI.

Watch this place for the DOTD's (Deal of the Day's) and get one cheap. You get what you pay for. Stick with HI.

My KH knife is in pieces in my shop, I gave the other one away. I try new modding techniques on it first. I call it Frankenkhuk.
 
>Yes it is....been a while. I am now with Cobb County Police >in the North Atlanta Metro area. Left Savannah about 2 years >ago.

It's an honor to meet you again.

>I do have to appoligize...cant remember your character >name?

The character names don't really matter that much. I do recall being bedridden and delerious with agony most of the time back then. You were always a joy to play with and write to. Later you started becoming a police officer. Not surprising since you were always strong and protective. That's the charcter I remember.

> Old age you see and all the old duels that I participated >in....or not doing what the wife ordered.

Get ready. Wives and Khukuris don't seem to enjoy sharing the same financial pool. Ask Steve Ferguson about Ram's draw if it gets really bad.
 
Welcome Dysentery Bob! Good luck with your search for a great Khukuri. It sure can be fun. I like the "American Eagle" Khukuri you linked to. I only have HI blades and love them. I say, get what grabs your attention, then if you can try a nice HI even if thats not your fancy at first. Will be worth it, and you can never have to many options. ;)

Welcome and please stick around for the fun!

Heber
 
jmpstock said:
On the web pae for the first knife
http://www.gurkhas-kukris.com/catalog/product.php?id=3839fa874

Did anyone other than myself find the following hilarious?

"...An over ambitious, overrated name 'American Eagle'
is given to denote the speciality of the knife..."

:confused:

John

Sigh, ......I asked them to run ALL the ad copy past me before publishing, but does anyone listen to me? No.

Another marketing page lost in translation.:D
 
tedwca said:
Sigh, ......I asked them to run ALL the ad copy past me before publishing, but does anyone listen to me? No.

Another marketing page lost in translation.:D

I know how you feel, I did technical support of sales & marketing for
over 20 yrs. It's simply amazing what sale & marketing folks think
is a good idea sometimes, even without the vagaries of translation.

John

----------------

"With this new digital technology, the suckiness comes through
with great clarity." Mike MST3k
 
Bob, if you're determined to give KH a try, then buy direct from their ebay site. They have some but not all of their models there, otherwise you will pay way more for KH than you will for HI, which in addition to having a lifetime "no B.S." warranty to the original purchaser, which no other mfr. has, also includes free shipping into the cost of their knives.

Believe it or not, the only rubber (kraton) handled knife I would buy would be Cold Steel. They at least have that down, and you could always reprofile their beveled sticky edges to convex. Also, check the stats, that rubber handled job is only about 13" OAL. Pretty small if you want a chopper. I would rather spend about $75 and get a beautiful little HI katunje "Yangdu special knife" if I wanted that length.

The other one is nice looking though. The only KH knife I have been flat out knocked on my butt impressed with was the Khasi Mari, which is basically a 20" Samsher with 3-pinned panawal handle. It is a great deal for the price, (from the ebay store only; I would not have bought it if it had to be shipped from Nepal.) As my HI purchases outnumber all other manufacturers about 30:1, I don't feel too bad acknowledging that sometimes the competition gets it right! :D

Norm
 
I haven't seen any KH fan forums (not that they couldn't exist, but I DID look when I was new to the scene). The thing that sold me on HI was this forum, actually. The HI forum is amazing to me- I mean, that all these characters could come together with dissimilar backgrounds and tastes, in support of a common appreciation of a overseas custom manufacturer with a (relatively) small output...it's the whole reason I'm here- I mean, these guys have converted me wholeheartedly- never seen that, never felt like that about a brand before.

Plus I have a couple KHs, a 16" Panawal AK and a 15" BAS (back when I was more concerned about saving a measely few dollars). HI's superior quality is quickly apparent in a side-by-side comparison and demonstration. I just ended up buying the HI version of each knife.

Be picky about snagging a good DOTD item, and you'll find that HI khuks can actually be had cheaper than KH!
 
What soupah said. The only khukuris I have are HI. I have not felt the need to look anywhere else.

Eric
 
I don't feel guilty! I just feel poor! I got both of my KH for $5 each and 5 biltongs for another $20.

So far I have beat the crap out of my Panawal 16", I have yet to really test the Service One, I have blued them both and made new kydex tactical sheaths in desert tan and black. I would love to have a nice HI some day, but I can't afford it now.
 
Back
Top