All-purpose bush knife: CS SRK or Recon Tanto?

Joined
Aug 6, 2002
Messages
746
I could use some advice about which of these two would be better as an all-purpose wilderness/backpacking knife.

Are there things about the design of one or the other that makes it advantageous?

Thanks,
Phil
 
I love my Recon Tanto, but I guess the SRK would be easier to use. The tanto tip was a bit odd trying to cut food...
 
While the Recon Tanto is king in the penetration department, the general usefulness of the SRK's clip-point makes it the clear winner for an all-purpose camp knife.
I'm sure others will be happy to cite examples of the 4000 situations a camper gets into where a clip point performs far better than a tanto, so I'll just wait for them to do it :)

I really dig tantos as toys and consider them excellent for combat, but there is a reason why conventional blade styles like the clip point and drop point have been around so long...
 
Originally posted by YoungCutter
I'm sure others will be happy to cite examples of the 4000 situations a camper gets into where a clip point performs far better than a tanto, so I'll just wait for them to do it :)

Didn't have to wait long, did you?
 
Clip Point has a much thinner (and thus more easily penetrating point). Also it has a belly, which is far batter for slicing purposes.
Another underlying factor that makes the SRK better is it's flat ground blade, which is a better cutter and more flexible for use than the tanto.

Things a clip point can do that a tanto can't or can't do acceptably well:
Scrape out wood or bowls or such.
Whittle
Slice
Skin

Several others I can't think of (probably because it's so late.)

Some of it is in the design, too. Understand that the Clip Point was evolved and designed for exactly the kind of applications you are considering, basic hardcore utility. The Geometric Tanto (which is what the CS Recon Tanto is, not to be confused with a true japanese tanto) was designed with one purpose paramount to all others: a VERY strong tip, at this, the Geometric Tanto excels. However the prices are many in a Gemoetric tanto, you sacrifice Belly (which is very important for slicing/skinning), you sacrifice ease of pentration for greater tip strength, you sacrifice sharpness because of almost full thick grind. The reason I say a Tanto is a good choice for combat is because I fall into the school of thought that the most effective form of combat is stab-oriented, and geometric tantos (aswell as to a certain extent, Japanese Tantos) generate unusual "boxy" wounds which do not easily close up, thus causing greater skin disruption and shock (the thing that ends fights), additionally, a Tanto is FAR less prone to breakage if it hits a bone or something, this is a tip style that has frequently been sucessfully rammed SEVERAL times into car doors (I know for a fact the Buck Strider and Cold Steel Recon Tanto have been run through this test). But for those of us who don't need to discect a Buick everyday, Tanto isn't necessarily the way to go.
 
I have a recon tanto and I admit......On my camping trip, there were times where I wished I had the SRK. It is true that the SRK is more of a general utility kind of use. Don't get me wrong tho, I love my tanto. Great for martial arts and same good steel as the SRK. Plus, it was a present from my friend, so no complains there.
 
Others have clearly stated the choice for SRK, but I'll add another reason for not choosing the recon tanto. I found that Americanized Tantos are a b**** to sharpen.... the secondary point can get fragile depending on how you sharpen it. I love my CRKT M16, but I hate sharpening it.
Personally I'll take the Becker any day. For the price that I got the SRK, I could've now get a Becker C/U 7 with a much better blade for chopping and other various tasks that someone would need in a camping or survival situation. Use the search function to look for the 7 (if you can... I know the search is picky, the C/U stand for Combat Utility)
 
I have both and never use the SRK. The Recon Tanto has more length, thus giving it a significant chopping advantage, though it still retains all of the cutting ability of the SRK. My Recon Tanto has been reprofiled somewhat to thin the edge slightly and further increase its performance. The tanto tip is more versatile than the naysayers give it credit for; it is essentially a second blade that can be sharpened differently than the primary blade. Mine is kept sharp but at a steeper angle for rough work that I don't want to sacrifice my primary edge on. Others I know keep their secondary edge very sharp in order to still have a sharp edge for fine cutting even after an extended chopping session. The transition between the edges is almost a second point, and is an excellent gouge for making all sorts of items. Point work is not a problem with the tanto tip, and I've yet to run into a job around camp where I missed having a clip point.

Unless Cold Steel has very recently started flat grinding the SRK, the grinds are functionally identical on the Recon Tanto and the SRK.
 
The SRK or the other tanto model both seem like good choice for different blade tasks but I wouldn't say SRK is what CS call rescue/survival knife. I'd deffinately want a steel butt cap on the end, something in ka bar fashion as this extra feature is a big plus in both life threatening situations. Also a negative point of SRK is Kraton handle which will wear off after extensive use and abuse. Muela uses kraton on twenty bucks knives! Overall at less than 11" it's a good blade size for tactical knife but I'd really think twice before getting one especially when there's alot of other good or better knives at related price range.
 
I agree, which is my choice for this kind of blade is a Becker Combat Utility 7, talk about a workhorse!
 
Of the two knives you mentioned, the SRK is my choice, but the BK&T's, Fallkniven A-1, and the CS Recon Scout are all much better than either of the ones you mentioned.
 
Another GOOD, inexpensive "camp/trail/bush" knife is the Buck Nighthawk. It has a pretty thick blade, but the two that I have cuts pretty well...Although I don't think it'd do very well at thin-slicing ripe tomatoes.:D.
 
Between the two, the SRK has greater utility - though I plan to thin out the edge on mine.

In this price range - the Becker CU 7" is a great carbon steel blade that I would have bought instead of the SRK had it been out.
 
Back
Top