Well, truth (or even some modicum of modesty) in advertizing is not a new thing is it? Likely as not, because this is old (relatively speaking), and US-made it is 'up to par' (or ought to be), or equal to the best of them. Now all you need to find out is who actually manufactured this, and to what specs. That will tell you more about relative quality than anything else (besides physically putting it to the test or out for strenuous work). Could be "America's Best" is merely a predecessor of emulator-niche products such as "Best Made" which is currently cashing in on a similar theme. BM doesn't manufacture anything at all and 'farms out' all the work except for the contract specs, advertising and decoration. Council Tools USA makes top of the line stuff and their name does not appear on BM products. I'd be interested to hear who was contracted to make "America's Best".