An Experiment part II....Disaster

Joined
Jun 25, 2006
Messages
56
Everything about this turned out wrong. The steel, the handle, the pin...everything. I am not proud of it, but here it is. The steel came from a piece of electrical panel and it turned out to be entirely too soft. Even after heat treating it was still no good. If bent, it stays in that position. However, I figured I might as well try to finish it anyway.

The handle is from a stick I found outside. As you can see, it is full of holes and very dry. I should have known better, but I went ahead with it. Not having any kind of decent way to cut a slot in the handle, I just used what I had on hand. The hacksaw did not cut a nice straight line like I hoped it would. Although it does not show in the pics, the slot is off center a bit.

Well, as you may have guessed, I was at this point thoroughly disgusted. But, I went ahead with it anyway. After filing the blade to shape and fitting the brass pin, I drilled a hole through the handle and hammered the pin in. Of course the handle cracked.

At this point, I just decided to stop and not do anything else to it. Overall, it looks like junk. Much too big and ugly as sin.

Embarrassed by the way it turned out, I was just going to toss it. However, a little humiliation is good for the soul and now it's now posted for the world to gape/giggle/cringe at.

Did I learn anything? Absolutely. Use the right steel. Use stabilized wood. Use the right equipment. Arrogance has no place in the shop. :(

By the way, the 2 knives in the picture are a #8 Opinel & SAK Recruit.
septknife.jpg
 
LOL!:)Thanks for sharing- that was awesome!
 
All experience is valid. Thanks for sharing as well to give us other "amateurs" a push in the same direction (amateur: from the Latin "to love", hence one who does something for the love of it)
 
well, at least your account brought a smile to my face this morning!

seriously though, good job on the blade profile...
 
the failures is where true smiths learn from in all crafts they build .. i built good dozen bows before i got a real good shooter ..

now you know in a survival situation you can make a knife out of a electrical box if you had too .
i made my 1st machete out of a jeep leaf spring lol
 
You learned what not to do the next time. Good for you for trying, just don't get discouraged and quit. You will get better if you work at it.
 
LOL.:D

I would bet if you asked someone like Ohhhh Bob Dozier he might have a similar story.

The blade profile dosen't look all that bad to me.
 
Thank you all for the words of encouragement! Of course, I will never give up...working with steel of any kind is like therapy to me. Although I am new to the game, I look forward to the joy of creating...even if it turns out like the last one.
 
Back
Top