Just for clarity, this is a blade replacement after some damage to my 550HG Griptillian blade. Excellent customer service from BM.
Ok, tanto Griptillian arrived today. Initial inspection is very positive. The blade is centered, smooth, a little tight but not too bad. It can still be flipped closed and open by pulling the axis bar back. BM put the clip on the right side, which I will have to fix (lefty). Looked like they let everyone at the plant inspect it before shipping. There were fingerprints and dark smears all over the blade. Nothing a good washing didn't fix.
On to the infamous Benchmade edge. I really don't see what the problem is. The edge bevels are even, straight and come in between 16 and 18 degrees per side roughly. Thickness at the top of the bevel is nice and thin. I'll get some measurements later. The sharpness is more than acceptable. It shaves, catches hair on the back of my head, push cuts paper, and whittles beard hair. Either I'm really lucky, or Benchmade's sharpening is all over the place. The only problem I've had was the 550HG blade I got was a little too steep, 22-25 degrees per side or so. However, it was sharp and even. The red class knife I got new (Pika II) had some sharpening issues, but they are discontinued. In any case, it was just a spot about 1/8 to 1/4 inch long that was uneven and dull. EDC starts tomorrow, so we'll see how it goes. I'm hoping this thing is as easy to sharpen as it looks. What could be easier than a straight, even edge, already set for the Sharpmaker.