Anybody have a Suburban?

Joined
Dec 17, 2005
Messages
7,809
Wife and I are looking into getting a Chevy Suburban/ GMC Yokon XL.

Anyone have one and not like it? Anything to look for problem wise?

I know I'm going to hate the gas milage but we need the space.

Thanks for any input.
 
yes. my wife has a 2001 model

they are the ultimate people mover short of a passenger van AND they have lots of cargo space in the back. they drive well considering their size and a very comfortable drive for long trips. they are great towers, although we do not use ours for that.

they are tougher to park though..especially backing out. they handle like an aircraft carrier in such cases. be prepared for the potential for some parking lot fender benders. :(

gas mileage is poor compared to mini vans and car based suvs. however true 8 passenger seating is great if you get the 2/3 rows as benches. the 3rd row is tolerable for adults only for short trips. kids love it though

reliability has been fair

ours had a bad pcv valve at 7k miles that i discovered by the low oil light coming on. it took 3 or 4 trips to the dealer to fix it and only after a fellow md told me what was wrong. it caused a buch of engine gunk buildup that can still be a minor issue even 120k later. i have to put a bottle of techron through every once in a while.

it also had a bad battery, a bad turn light and one bad rear brake under warrany.

it was a special order vehicle that had the rear lift gate instead of the barn doors in the back. it came from a mexican plant and that seemed to be a major problem site. many of our friends have Us made ones and they have been fine

other issues include a bad water pump and fuel pump. they had issues with the wiring harness to the fuel pump...but they swear that was not the problem with mine.

the emmision control light came on once but they could not find the cause


so will i get another one? probably not although the new model is really nice and reliability is better. there is little difference between the gmc and the chevy other than "extra sound insulation" and some chrome doo-dads. if they gave lexus like service i would go that route, around here they dont so no way would i spend anything extra for a gmc.

i run vehicles until the wheels fall off and expect i will probably get 7-8 years and 150k or so out of the one i have so thats not bad

i would buy used though , there are screaming good deals on them
 
We have had two. One went about 210K the other about 120K before things started to go to south fast.

The first one was a 1997, which was flawless, the only repairs IIRC, were an alternator, water pump, starter, and a radiator that took a projectile, ( a bolt from something punched a hole in it. The Leather seats were starting to go at 180K but for a work vehicle I just bought a pair of slip covers from cabelas and they were fine. The radio/CD player switched to being an FM only at about the same time, I just lived with it. I think I was on my third set of Michelins and maybe the second set of rotors and five set of pads. There may have been some other things, but nothing major. I retired it and sold it to a friend who needed a truck at his cabin for hauling junk etc. for a bout $500, it was on the last legs of the motor and I think he put a new one in it. but all up expenses for 210K that I owned it were probably in the 2K to 2500 range. excluding gas oil and tires.

The last one we had was nearly 100% trouble free for 110K it was a 2001, On belt, a set of brakes, a set of tires, and a seal on the front diff cover. otherwise nothing, then in the last ten K miles, it suffered several failures, the front Posi diff gave up the ghost. They said we were driving it on 4 wheel too much, and I had not had it on 4WD for a long time, just the occaissional punch in and out when starting off in snow or on a boat ramp, but it went, 1500 bucks or so for that, Then the transfer case started to act up, found out it was cycling in and out of 4 wheel on its own, (at this time my daughter was the primary driver.) that was what burned up the front diff and the transfer case, we found a used T case and that was a grand to put in. Then odd stuff started happening, Door locks going on and off, the passenger rear window up and down by itself, all this was traced to a bad default ground that was causing the other stuff. that was discovered by a kid who was a friend of Daughters and was in tech school for GM, None of the local dealers had found it. Finally at 120 K the tranny started acting up, shifting oddly etc, That was traced to a damaged control module, most likely from when the ground was bad. at that point I had lost confidence in it as a safe vehicle for my daughter and traded it off for a VW toureg diesel, which we sold back to the dealer in 18 months.

I bought a used MB m350 and love it, So far its doing great, only oil changes and a set of brakes, ( the originals had run 65K so it was due) With the kids now 18, 19, My needs for a monster has shrunk. IF someone would make a good minivan in AWD that had the guts to pull a 2500 boat, I would buy that instead. I had a couple of Aerostars in AWD and really liked them, we had one Astro Van in AWD but that vehicle sucked, you sit at an angle to the wheel, because the motor dog house intrudes too much, the WB is so short it always seems to waggle on the highway esp in the wind, and where I was working, the wind always was blowing. Mileage sucked, and it could not carry as much as Aerostar.

MY personal wish would be for someone to make a HP common rail diesel in a mid size SUV or AWD minivan that could get the 30 MPH or so and have the guts to pull a small to mid size boat. A 200 HP/350 FtPd motor would be cheap economical and have plenty of guts.


The VW we had was a great motor, but the interior made you sick. There was some smell/oil/material/fabric that would make you car sick. Now i have driven a couple of million miles for work, and I have never ever gotten car sick except in that stupid VW. And it was not just me, a buddy and I took it to Iowa pheasant hunting and he booted from the smell, at first it smells like new car smell, then it gets you ill. another couple of people who road in it got close to booting too. And it was not just my car, when i went back to the dealers the first time, they said they had a soap, it worked for a bit, then they tried some steam cleaner, then they bought it back from me.
 
Sorry for the sidebar, but I found this:

Eventually VW confessed that the crayola smell was from the asphaltic sound deadening material that they sprayed on the floor. It did not cure properly and smelled during hot weather. They bought the car back from me but they will not tell me the test results as to whether it was hazardous or not. Does anyone know? Has anyone tested it? Does anyone still have one that we can test?
 
Close... I have a 2002 Avalance. No problems thus far, with the exception of one of the DRL's burnt out... I see that alot on the 'burbans and avalanches. I love it, wish it got better gas milage.
 
I've owned two Suburbans. One a 1989 old boxy one that was like a cavern on wheels. I loved that thing. Truly I cried when my wife and I sold it. Has to be one of the best vehicles I have ever had the pleasure of owning.

Later I got a newer model, liked it fine also but never quite took to it like the first one. It wouldn't hold as much, maybe that was why. Still, because it was newer it was nice in many ways. Quiet by comparison but then time came to get another and I had a Yukon all picked out. The wife had other plans though and before I knew it I was driving a Lincoln Navigator. I was always a GM fan so this was a big step for me. Can't say after 150,000 miles that I regret it because the Lincoln has proven to be flawless perfection over time and I rank it right up there with the finest most reliable best built of any I've owned even above the Land Cruiser and Mercedes I had once. I would say it is a safe bet to go with the Suburban though. I can tell you I'll own another one, because I'm sure not spending more than I paid for my home to get into another Lincoln Nav. :D

STR
 
Posted by bandaidman-they are tougher to park though..especially backing out. they handle like an aircraft carrier in such cases. be prepared for the potential for some parking lot fender benders.

Says you. I took my initial driver's test in a 1975 Suburban :cool:
 
SG11... To get back on topic, Approx what year suburban are you looking at? 1/2 ton 3/4 ton? 2wd 4wd? Big block, small block.

There were issues with certain variations, but all in all they are awesome. I've had 4 in various years/setups.

*one particular note* The late 90's 4X4 models had not so good brakes.
 
Says you. I took my initial driver's test in a 1975 Suburban :cool:

you are probably a better suburban driver than my wife or her circle of friends.

i can think of at least 15 little fender benders among that group :eek: :eek: :eek:
 
Thanks for all the input guys.

I jumped the gun and got an 04' Burban about an hour after my first post.

It was just an inkling in my head when I posted and when I went to look at the one I saw that got the wheels turning, I drove away with it.

It's an 04', 5.4 liter I think, 1500, built in the goodol' U.S.A.. It's a super dark blue, I'd prefer black, but it'll do.

Every option under the sun, heated leather, DVD player, onboard computer.
It's very nice, nicest vehicle I've ever owned or thought I would own.
 
I jumped the gun and got an 04' Burban about an hour after my first post.

Well . . . it's water over the dam now but I'll throw in my 2 cents. I've had two 'burbs: 1995 and 1998. I got the '95 used and the '98 new. Both were 4x4, and in BOTH vehicles I had problems with the 4x4. I had a heck of a time getting the 4x4 to engage in the '95. I chalked it up to being a used vehicle, and figured the previous owner had done something stupid with it.

When I got the '98 brand new, I expected it to run like a champ. It did in every regard except 4x4. This time it wasn't necessarily hard to engage, it just made a horrific 'thump' when it engaged/disengaged. Now I've driven my share of 4x4's over the years and expect a certain amount of noise when engaging and disengaging the 4x4. However, the noise that came from my new burb just about made me sick. Oh well, I got rid of it about 11 months later.

Ignoring the 4x4 issues, the trucks were awesome. Tons of room, and they handled great for being such big vehicles.

I'm sure you will enjoy your burb.

Andy
 
Another late :02, but what the heck - nothing like having your purchase justified instead of feeling buyer's remorse! ;)

Had a Suburban and two Yukons (including my current one). LOVE 'em! (Also had a Range Rover HSE 4.6 that I loved, but that's not a fair example because I had the ONE unit shipped to North America that year that had no mechanical or electrical problems. ;) )

A friend of mine was a very senior exec with GM and when I got the Suburban the first thing he had me to do was have the factory shocks replaced with something decent. Made a HUGE difference in ride and handling.
 
A friend of mine was a very senior exec with GM and when I got the Suburban the first thing he had me to do was have the factory shocks replaced with something decent. Made a HUGE difference in ride and handling.

What year was that truck?

Mine seems to ride and handle fairly well but if you think it could make it better.....
 
I have had 3 Suburbans and 2 Yukon XL's. Fantastic vehicles, the ultimate for highway cruising comfort. Tough as all get out, great for pulling heavy loads, and great for taking kids off to college. Gas mileage admittedly is not as good a mini van, but who wants to drive a mini van when you can drive a suburban!

The only problems I ever had with the vehicles was from my own rough housing.

-Mark
 
My mom runs a home daycare and drives a Yukon XL (2000) as her brat bus. My only complaint is that the interior starts to feel really cheap and breakable (and starts to look bad with peeling paint on buttons and the dashboard), but that's par for the course on most newer American cars. It has a big smooth engine, hasn't had any major problems, and if you can get past the fact that the doors start to creak and the windows start to lag and make noises when they travel, you'll probably love it.

It has good steering, acceleration, and very good braking for its size (especially if you use good pads, we have ceramics in it right now). If you plan on getting a 4x4, get used to the occasional malfunction (the 4wd will stick, not go on, get error messages etc.). GM has been very good about recalls and service on O2 sensors and other tedious repairs that have needed to be done.

I don't know what new problems have arisen in these seven years and what ones have been fixed, but I think it's a nice truck with good creature comforts. Go for it! :) Edit: Oh, you already did. Congrats :D
 
Back
Top