Anybody have trouble sharpening your traditionals that have bellied blades?

Joined
Mar 27, 2012
Messages
554
For some reason, I have a heck of a time sharpening the curved blades that I own. My sheepsfoot blades are all razor sharp from kick to tip, but most of my others (the pen blade on my barlow is what is giving me trouble at the moment) start to get less than sharp when the curve starts. Do you guys have any tips for this? The last 1/4 in of my clip blade won't even catch my thumbnail!

Thanks guys (and gals).
 
The curved portion of the blade is always hardest. Slow down, take your time. Once you feel you have the angle right slow down as you sweep through the curve of the blade an watch to ensure you are keeping that angle. You can also mark the blade on each side with a permenant marker. This will show you where you are hitting the blade and where is being missed.

Above all else remember to sharpen the entire blade evenly. Same strokes on each side and although you can focus on the curve of the blade try to balance the sharpening across the blade. Maybe experiment on a cheapie....

Sam
 
Strangely, the belly in my blades tends to get sharper faster than the straight part of the edge. I think I exert a tad more pressure when lifting the blade. Also, if I am not careful, the edge angle in the belly can get lower than the straight part. Even when I dont see it happening, I will often go five strokes just on the straight edge to catch up.
 
You have no problem sharpening from the shoulder to the start of the curve. That's great and will help you with the belly.

Now, as you sharpen, imagine a plane that exists relative to the blade, between the very edge to the spine portion of the blade. Let's say it exists at 20 degrees relative to the hone. In your mind, now extend this plane backwards from the spine for a couple of inches. This plane is what you swing the handle through as you sharpen the belly. It looks like you're raising the handle of the knife, but really what you're doing is keeping the very edge of the blade aligned with that plane. The knife must be aligned so that where the blade touches maintains that same 20 angle.

Now, a different thing that helps me. Forget the above and concentrate just on the very edge. Wherever it touches the stone, it must be going directly (90 degrees) into the stone. So as you push the blade forward against the stone, you move the knife handle so that point of the edge scrapes right into the stone. Now to add from the above paragraph, as you do this, the handle comes up in order to keep the necessary 20 degree angle of the edge into the stone.

For me as a right hander, as I sharpen the belly, the knife rotates counterclockwise, but the handle also swings through that 20 degree plane to keep the very edge at a consistent angle, from shoulder to tip.

Once you get the hang of this, you can improvise other techniques to suit your needs. But the above will get you sharp.
 
Strangely, the belly in my blades tends to get sharper faster than the straight part of the edge. I think I exert a tad more pressure when lifting the blade. Also, if I am not careful, the edge angle in the belly can get lower than the straight part. Even when I dont see it happening, I will often go five strokes just on the straight edge to catch up.

I guess I've been lucky as well. The belly portion of all my blades is always the part to bite me first, when testing the edge with my fingertips. It's also the portion that seems to slice most easily, in testing with paper & such while sharpening up and stropping.

It makes sense, in that the curved edge of the belly puts a smaller portion of the edge in contact with the hone, and that has the effect of focusing pressure along that portion of the edge. It should sharpen up quicker, so long as the angle is sufficient to keep the apex in contact. That means lifting the heel of the blade slightly during the stroke, to follow the curvature of the edge into and through the belly, to the tip.


David
 
Is that a GEC Barlow? I find the pen blade on my whittler to be one of the easiest blades to sharpen. I can't remember what my technique was but I know I used my translucent arkansas. I also don't use the old "imagine you're cutting a thin layer off the top of the stone".
 
Back
Top