what aspects in a lighter are you looking for?
i get the feeling that there will be a unanimous hoorah for the classic zippo, as it's a tried and true design, and quite a favorite amongst campers and civilized "gents" alike. i have two zippos, which I am quite happy with, although i don't like the idea of having to refill it every week or so (i don't use it often, but it likes to dry out). these aren't considered to be waterproof.
other than that, you could go for the waterproof windmill delta lighters, which go for about 45.00. 1sks.com has them.
I can't tell a difference between any of the waterproof, butane, torch lighters, honestly. but then again, i'm of the mall-ninja variety.
i also have a "fire one" butane torch that I got on sale at a local outfitters store. 20.00. it is indeed, waterproof, fairly reliable, and has treated me nice.
if you're not worried about getting wet, i'd say go for just the bic disposables. or if you're worried about getting wet, put em' in a plastic bag.
