Appreciation for the character of a flawed traditional

Joined
Jun 22, 2008
Messages
1,898
I figure this is the only place that would tolerate me gushing over this worn old tool I carry in my pocket.

I purchased my first traditional more than 20 years ago. I bought a box of used knives for a good price. In the box there was one knife if I was after.... and this old traditional was definitely not it. I promptly stuck the traditional and the others in a drawer and never looked at them again...until about 1.5 years ago.

I got interested in traditional's and I remembered that I had an old stag covered traditional somewhere. I pulled this knife out and opened the main blade for probably the first time, and was it sharp !! I was amazed. I had no prior experience with carbon steel blades. I'll just say that I haven't bought any fancy modern stainless since.

This knife is really worn. It is a 2 blade congress pen. It served somebody well in hard work probably before I was born. The main sheep's foot blade was rounded at the tip and looked like it had been sharpened on a boulder. The secondary pen was impossible to open. I posted here and got some good advice on the pen. I left the pen partially open for a month and I lubricated the heck out of it. The spring relaxed a little bit in the lubrication made it much easier to open. Plus, my thumbnail probably got stronger.

I have been carrying this knife most days for quite some time. It has a rounded tip on the sheep's foot and bad gaps in the back spring, but I absolutely love it. The thin blades take an amazing razor edge. I love the walk and talk. Seriously snappy. The uneven stag covers feel great in the hand. The significant gaps around the back spring would prevent anybody from ever wanting to buy it, but all these flaws make it more precious to me. I don't think I use it as hard as the original owner but it sure gets a workout. It's become a trusted companion.

Not too long ago I lost it while fishing around a very remote lake. I had set it down while tying a lure and walked away. The next day my friends agreed to help me walk around the entire lake to look for it. They certainly didn't understand what the big deal was but were gracious enough to help me. I figured there was less than a 10% chance we would find it but I had to give it a try. Unbelievably, in the tall grass I came upon it. The glint off the nickel silver bolsters caught my eye.

I'm sure some of you have some flawed traditionals that you can't help but enjoy. Please share them here. Cheers.







 
Last edited:
Nice story. Thanks for sharing. I am so glad you found it! I've often lost things while fishing, and I know how relieved you must have been to find your knife.
 
So, where is the worn out one? The one you show has plenty of life left in it. I'm glad you were able to find it. I've used a metal detector searching for dropped knives myself.
 
^ i would have had to hike 36 hours to fetch a metal detector.

Worn yes. worn out?...nope!
 
DSC_0496_zpsh8lhokwn.jpg
[/URL][/IMG]

I thought I was the only one. I've posted pics of this ol boy many times here. I found it with the tip broke off and after a little grind, voila a "modified wharncliffe". It's one of my favorites. This is an old pic I had with my great granddaddys 38. Neither are worth much money but they mean alot to me.
 
some of the functions on this sabre USA are a bit stiff, but other than that I love it regardless.
this imperial Barlow isn't really defective, just not as finely built as a case, and the clip doesn't open perfectly flush. Other than that I love it cause it's lightweight, the steel is great, so is the walk and talk, and it's a gift from a forum member and really got me into carrying slipjoints.
this black beauty is certainly still a great knife but the blade should be about 1/8th " wider ( it's original owner definitely got their money's worth ) and I had to straighten the blade as it was bent.

I love all of these knives and I use them regularly, I'm wish the black beauty wasn't over-sharpened but there's nothing I can do and it still works great.
 
I don't have pictures just now but I certainly think the way you do. I appreciate great fit and finish but equally a flawed and well used traditional knife as well. I love the ugly duckling type of knife. It may not be purdy to others but I ABSOLUTELY love the flaws that makes it unique. Knowing it's up for the unglamorous cutting chore always appeals to me.
 
Nice story, and it sounds like you have some good friends :) :thumbup:

I have lots of worn old knives that I enjoy carrying and using. Seeing a knife that's been abused upsets me, but honest wear simply adds to its character I think.
 
Lots of life left in that knife!! One of the things I like best about traditional knives is that they often have lots of history and character:thumbup:
 
I don't usually enjoy the flaws, although I do appreciate a knife with it's own character. However, I enjoy taking a flawed knife and fixing it up to my liking. Even something simple as sharpening a dull blade can make the knife feel like something special to me.
 
I don't usually enjoy the flaws, although I do appreciate a knife with it's own character. However, I enjoy taking a flawed knife and fixing it up to my liking. Even something simple as sharpening a dull blade can make the knife feel like something special to me.

I too am gratified by fixing things and I do admire the F&F of a finely crafted folder. In the case of this particular knife I am not inclined to do anything more. It is perfectly usable.

Hickory n steel- thanks for sharing those. Good looking tools.
 
I too am gratified by fixing things and I do admire the F&F of a finely crafted folder. In the case of this particular knife I am not inclined to do anything more. It is perfectly usable.

Hickory n steel- thanks for sharing those. Good looking tools.

It's a good looking knife, cool pattern. I think the thing I connected to most in your story was putting it away and then remembering it almost "anew" later on. That can do it for me even more than fixing something up or than it's perceived "perfection." When all that time has passed, it's almost like I gave myself a gift when I find it again, rather than I bought it.
 
As I'm sure you can tell by now, on the porch we don't call 'em flaws, we call it character. :) Here's a few with character.

Graeff&Schmidt Jack Knife, chipped, cracked bone covers with worn blades and a little wobble on the main blade.

HCrzQGU.jpg


Josef Sziraki pearl Sleeveboard Lobster cracked/chipped pearl.

4KPsh1X.jpg


LF&C Petal Lobster cracked.

7PpM03g.jpg


Restored broken pearl with Ivory from piano keys, Schrade Walden.

kIfo8hv.jpg


It's all personality not a flaw in the bunch, I hope when I'm over a 100 a little broken bone, some worn out joints and a chip in the pearly whites is all I have to complain about. ;)
 
As I'm sure you can tell by now, on the porch we don't call 'em flaws, we call it character. :) Here's a few with character.

Graeff&Schmidt Jack Knife, chipped, cracked bone covers with worn blades and a little wobble on the main blade.

HCrzQGU.jpg


Josef Sziraki pearl Sleeveboard Lobster cracked/chipped pearl.

4KPsh1X.jpg


LF&C Petal Lobster cracked.

7PpM03g.jpg


Restored broken pearl with Ivory from piano keys, Schrade Walden.

kIfo8hv.jpg


It's all personality not a flaw in the bunch, I hope when I'm over a 100 a little broken bone, some worn out joints and a chip in the pearly whites is all I have to complain about. ;)

Ivory from piano keys? Talk about a cool backstory!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
You're not the only one who appreciates character. :D





My favorite 'ugly duckling' find was this old Case Congress. The blades are so worn that the owner had to file down the kicks to keep the tips of the blades in the well. Eventually he had to grind out nail reliefs in the handle to access the blades. I suppose if you bought a knife during the Great Depression, you didn't just throw it out when it gets a little worn. :D I still use it sometimes instead of an X-acto for light craft projects.

 
Back
Top