Are all these knives necessary?

UffDa

Gold Member
Joined
Sep 11, 1999
Messages
42,596
Please excuse me if I ramble a bit.

There is a local radio food and wine program that I listen to sometimes. Today they had a representative from Wusthof on talking about their new line of chef's knives. He mentioned a 25 piece set of these knive that sell for well over $1000. He commented that they would not even attempt to market anything like this in Europe. They would be laughed at. It seems that only Americans (and maybe Canadians) are the only ones who would be interested in having more then a few knives.

This started me thinking. (A dangerous thing)
I remember reading about people who live by their knife and how they get along just fine without INFI, Talonite, ATS34, etc. I remember Ken Warner writing about the African staff on safari who used knives that we would turn our noses up at with great skill and who did not feel at all disadvantaged. In fact, when Warner offered them the use of his new-fangled custum made knives he found that they didn't care much for them. For one thing, when they got dull, they couldn't readily sharpen them.

The Lapps also live with their knives. I remember an interview with a Finnish bladesmith who felt that the ideal blade would just cut into a soft iron nail. Anything harder was not practical for daily use.

I love the new steels as much as anyone and wouldn't want to give them up, but sometimes I think we put to much value in "hi-tech".

------------------
Do not lead me for I will not follow.
Do not follow me for I will not lead.
Do not walk by my side either.
Just leave me the hell alone.
 
Man sailed the Seven Seas using hemp, canvas and carbon steel well enough to circumnavigate the globe. Does that mean we should abandon powered steel-hulled sea-craft?

I left “necessary” behind some time ago as far as my knife purchases are concerned.

Heretic
wink.gif


------------------
James Segura
San Francisco, CA
 
Also, it's fun to think about "what if". Such as, "What if I get stuck in the woods with only a knife? I want the best" Right?
Why else would we take a $350 knife and do our best to destroy it. Crazy Americans!

I didn't mention the comments made about Americans and their guns. Why do Americans need more then one S&W or Colt? Yeah, why do I have 7 of the things in my safe?

When Beretta first started importing the 92 into the US they only sent one magazine with each pistol. Of course, American wanted more magazines. The Italians asked "Why? What are you doing with these things?". Crazy Americans!

------------------
Do not lead me for I will not follow.
Do not follow me for I will not lead.
Do not walk by my side either.
Just leave me the hell alone.
 
Originally posted by UffDa:
Why... would we take a $350 knife and do our best to destroy it. Crazy Americans!

Blasphemer
tongue.gif



------------------
James Segura
San Francisco, CA
 
They are absolutely right.

I don't NEED More than one knife
I don't NEED a gun
I don't NEED a free press
I don't NEED food (bread & water with an
ocassional fruit will do)
I don't NEED Money
I don't NEED to Work
I don't NEED much of anything

Virtually any deprevation can be justified with the word NEED. Have you noticed how rarely you actually use that word. I usually discredit anyone who argues from the basis of need. A world based on NEED would be a very boring place.

We have a variety of knives becuase we recognize and appreciate the individual. Everyone has their own preferances/style and we provide the tools to allow each to maximize their potential.

 
Hey UffDa,

You can send any knives you don't need my way
smile.gif


Glen

--------------------
"All I need to survive is my Sebenza." -- Thoreau, in _Walden_
 
I need my knives, I NEEEEED them all.... and your's too, so hand 'em over.............. must have, cannot live, cannot live without..........

------------------
EdRozen-On the cutting edge of finding out what the cutting edge is....
 
Originally posted by storyville:
Hey UffDa,

You can send any knives you don't need my way
smile.gif


Glen


Hey Glen:

If I got rid of all my stuff I don't NEED,
I would just have more room to put the new
stuff that I don't NEED. It's cheaper to keep the old stuff.

Dennis

 
Humans are by nature, explorers. Often what drives the acquisition of new things is that not only do we want, but we also want to know.



------------------
Hoodoo

The low, hoarse purr of the whirling stone—the light-press’d blade,
Diffusing, dropping, sideways-darting, in tiny showers of gold,
Sparkles from the wheel.

Walt Whitman
 
Back
Top