Axe Decision

Joined
Mar 5, 2015
Messages
12
I have been considering the purchase of one of the council tool axes to see how they perform compared to other axes. I have determined three possible choices.
35JC36S.gif

The Classic Jersey Axe.
35DR36S.gif

A 4 pound Dayton pattern.
JP40DV36C.png

Also I've been looking at the Velvicut felling axe. Is it worth the money?
-Thanks
 
I dont know if its Worth it or not but the last one is my favorite one, but thats not saying much.
go with your need and budget!
 
In order to best advise, we should know how you will use it, what are your intended use scenarios?
 
For an everyday felling axe used to cut large diameter timber literally everyday I'd choose the Velvicut.
Better steel will mean less downtime due to fewer sharpenings.
 
I like a double bit or the jersey pattern with a ~34" straight handle for felling, but I've never felled anything over 24" or so diameter with just axe, so I don't know about large diameter timber.
 
I will be using it as a felling axe for cutting large diameter timber almost everyday.

Is there a reason you don't want to use a double bit? In the US, after the double bit was invented it pretty much dominated single bits in commercial logging axes. My favorite felling axe is a 4.5 lb Jersey, but I don't cut large diameter timber almost every day.

I enjoy felling with an axe, but if I had to cut trees every day like you are saying, it seems hard to justify not using a chainsaw. There are lots of situations in felling in which a chainsaw is a safer tool than a felling axe, there are so many more felling techniques possible with a chainsaw than an axe.
 
You waste quite a bit of wood when you use an axe to fell and chop trees into lengths. I know it's wonderfully good exercise and does not invoke engine noise, machine maintenance and fossil fuel odours but it is also very (very) slow going.
Manual bucking and felling saws make clean cuts, are fast, efficient, waste very little wood and have been around for 120+ years! As a consequence axes have been relegated to limbing and splitting already a long time ago.
I was lucky (?) 45 years ago to have experienced the very tail end of an era where gov't workers were required to use axes to chop down entire forests. This was entirely for the purpose of land clearing so waste was not a concern and older chainsaws of the time with direct drive (no clutch), no safety features and no vibration damping, were still common and very dangerous to use.
Borrow a few different types and weights of axes and give them a real good workout before committing to buy!
Looking at the pictures you provide, myself would be a sucker for getting the Jersey only because of the generous wood contact in the eye and the no frills haft. But then again that's just me!
 
If for some reason you aren't using a chainsaw for this work then you should at least have a crosscut saw.
 
I did a splitting contest. Velvicut vs Kelly Perfect. It was a tie. But I do like the CT.

[URL=http://s810.photobucket.com/user/doubleott/media/Kelly%20Perfect%20vs%20Council%20Velvicut/KellyPerfectvsCouncilVelicut003.jpg.html][/URL]

"Also I've been looking at the Velvicut felling axe. Is it worth the money?
-Thanks"


It is a very nice axe. Your the only one who can determine if it is worth the money. What are you willing to pay for an axe?

[URL=http://s810.photobucket.com/user/doubleott/media/Kelly%20Perfect%20vs%20Council%20Velvicut/KellyPerfectvsCouncilVelicut004.jpg.html][/URL]

[URL=http://s810.photobucket.com/user/doubleott/media/Kelly%20Perfect%20vs%20Council%20Velvicut/KellyPerfectvsCouncilVelicut010.jpg.html][/URL]

Tom
 
I did a splitting contest. Velvicut vs Kelly Perfect. It was a tie. But I do like the CT.
Tom
Looking at both your 'ladies' first one I'd go with is the 'previously enjoyed' one on the left. Not because one is any better than the other (and to be honest rounded polls are not my 'bag' either) but for the whole nostalgia trip. Thank you for knocking a few heads.
I sit in the autumn woods every year with a live 96 Springfield cavalry carbine for that same reason. It actually talks to me! The latest short mag fashionable CNC-made and synthetic gear doesn't and never will.
 
Just finished a Keen Kutter with a 36" Fawn's Foot handle. Very similar to your Classic Jersey.
 
Looking at both your 'ladies' first one I'd go with is the 'previously enjoyed' one on the left. Not because one is any better than the other (and to be honest rounded polls are not my 'bag' either) but for the whole nostalgia trip. Thank you for knocking a few heads.
I sit in the autumn woods every year with a live 96 Springfield cavalry carbine for that same reason. It actually talks to me! The latest short mag fashionable CNC-made and synthetic gear doesn't and never will.

I understand perfectly what you are saying.
 
Back
Top