Bag of small tools vs. multi-tool?

Joined
Jun 13, 2007
Messages
4
Today I bought a Victorinox Trekker and Leatherman Juice S2.

Before I go further I ought to say that I've never ever owned or used any sort of SAK or multi-tool in my life. I did not expect that the biggest problem I would have with both of these tools is the basic open and close operation of the various blades. It's a PITA to dig out the blades. I'm sure with practice I can become super fast at it. But I'm thinking it'd be simpler, more efficient and more ergonomically kind to my fingers to carry a fanny pack or some kind of belt bag that contained smaller stand-alone versions of all the tools I need: small bit driver + bits, small knife, small scissors, small tweezers, small pliers, etc. That way I could just unzip and pull out exactly what I needed and start using it instead of messing around and even quicker toss it back into the bag when done.

btw I got the idea from this terrific thread

What do you carry with your multi?

http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=463073&highlight=bits

I originally thought the multi-tool was going to work for me but I think the man-purse is the way to go for my way of doing things. This method allows me to carry around exactly what I need and leave out what I don't need and I'd not have to fuss with folding and unfolding sharp metal blades. Of course I have never EDC a fanny pack or belt man-bag in my life either so this idea may not turn out to be any better, especially if it feels like I'm lugging around a toolbox all day. It'll depend on the design of the bag, where/how I hang the bag on my body, and most importantly the size/weight/shape of the tools I'll put inside it. Or maybe I need complicated pants with 100 pockets.
 
Sounds clunky IMHO. Unless you are using the tools on a regular basis throughout the day I don't see a reason to burden yourself with an entire bagful. For example, I do find myself cutting multiple things in a day and also needing a screw driver fairly often (excluding at my job) as well as a caplifter. To solve this, I have my Native in my left pocket and a SAK Rouge in my right on my keychain. Also, I have a nifty little husky screwdriver tool which is a flat piece of metal with variously shaped and sized points and flats to accomodate multiple sizes of flat and phillips heads. Actually its a really knife tool and I will be quite sad if I ever lost it, thats how nice it is (despite being something from a 99 cent bin!).

That said, if you are something along the lines of a apartment handyman or similar and are using your tools constantly throughout the day, perhaps a tool bag is in order. I know at work (cycle shop) I typically have a 3-way hex wrench or a couple hex keys as well as a full sized phillips driver in my pockets through the day.
 
If you know exactly what you are going to need and have room to carry the proper tools then a multi-tool / SAK combo might not be as good as a real set of tools, small or large. My take on multi-tools in general is that they are to help you out of a pinch when you don't have the proper tool(s) on hand. Once you get used to carrying either or both a SAK and/or a multi-tool, you'll be hard pressed to walk out the door without them in your pocket or on your belt. They are handy to have and allow for more functions than just a bladed pocketknife.
 
Hi There,

I've carried a huntsman since I was 14 or so. On my third now as I'll be 64 in a month. They work just swell for my needs. Give it a try.

Best - Joe
 
1950, not meaning to be critical here, but I suspect you "overbought" when you chose what you did, especially considering your lack of experience with things of this sort. A fat SAK won't turn you into a McGyver. You must have been a tool using person for a long time first. Maybe you would be better off to backtrack some now, and buy yourself a simple Victorinox Soldier model. It has all the tools you'll ever need, and probably some you won't even know how to use until you learn more about them ... and it only has four blades, too. Remember the KISS Principle. You do know what that is, don't you? :D
 
Back
Top