Bark River Knife and Tool Northstar Review

Joined
Apr 13, 2001
Messages
546
northstar.bmp

[not my knife but a good example of a Northstar with mosaic pins]

I finaly got my Northstar today. It is a black canvas Micarta with mosaic pins.
Impressions;

:D
1. This is a quality made knife.
2. Blade grinds are well executed and designed.
3. There is a noticeable lack of tool marks everywhere except near the finger groove serations and they actually help the traction in that area.
4. The mosaic pin work is exceptional. Such work in this price range is RARE today.
5. The Micarta grip is well contoured and polished.
6. Over all the design of the knife is almost ideal. The tip is both robust and very strong as well as being thin enough to be useful. The spine of the blade is thick enough to insire confidence yet the blade is ground thin enough to make it a good slicer.
7. For hunting uses I think it will be a good caping knife

:grumpy:
1. There is a good sized scuff on one grip panel that either did not receive the final polish stage or is the result of a slip of the hand.
2. The over all size of the knife is good but, for my hand, the grip is a tiny bit too small. Several knife guys that looked it over today had much larger hands than mine and flatly said the grip was too small for them. Several other guys and a number of ladies remarked it was perfect. I did notice they had smaller hands than me.
3. The utility sheath (shown above)BRK&T designed was not ready for this first porduction run. They shipped instead a simple pouch sheath and a card for a free utility sheath later.

Final impressions;
Reactions to my Northstar today ran about 100% positive on appearance and workmanship. Most folks that handled it were amazed that a knife of this quality and workmanship was purchased for just over $100.00.
Reactions to handling and feel-design ran about 70% positive and about 30% negative. Most of the complants were on grip size and lack of finger protection from the blade. I explained the concept of knives with lack of a bolster or oversize finger guards to everyone that complained but a certain number of folks thought these factors would prevent them from purchasing a Northstar. Of course none of these folks had a chance to actually use this knife for anything. All these comments were based on first impressions alone.
As for me...Even though the grip is a touch too small I think the Northstar is well on the way to becoming my favorite sheath knife for general utility duty. It is certainly not for sale and that says alot because I do not keep knives that I don't like.

:Cheers:
 
Well I just purchased one. Looking forward to comparing my impressions with yours.
 
I am holding out for the fox river. Nice to see a BRKT review. Have the mini-canadian, and it has displaced all my folders for EDC!
 
My experience with the North Star mirrors yours. It's a real quality knife. Very cleanly made, except for a couple of imperfections near the finger grove serrations. The handle is a little small, but I have avg sized hands and do not have any problems with it at all.

All in all, it's becomming one of my favorites. Just the right size. Cuts better than anything else I own, including a maker or two that is known for their knive's cutting ability. Will have to see how well the edge holds up. I'm sure it will be easy to resharpen, when the time comes.

It's a keeper. ;)
 
I like mine alot, too! Feels great in my hands, and I have a mid- to large hand (well, two of them to be exact :D ). I am making a hiking stick with mine, so far it's working out great! Has worked pretty good in the kitchen, too!

As for the sheath thing, apparantly, the sheath maker didn't quite make the sheath as it was designed, so BR had to ship the knives out with the existing sheath so as to not delay shipment. Pretty cool of them to offer the free replacement, though! :cool:
 
Hey, I'm holding out for the fox river too...I want my first BRKT purchase to be nirvana! But Mike Stewart is really very consumer-friendly....

How about comments about BRKT's edge treatment? Is it scary sharp?
 
spyken said:
Hey, I'm holding out for the fox river too...I want my first BRKT purchase to be nirvana! But Mike Stewart is really very consumer-friendly....

How about comments about BRKT's edge treatment? Is it scary sharp?

Every BR knife I have acquired came very sharp. They can push cut copy paper into < 1/8" strips, and some are .20" thick at the spine. That's pretty good cutting potential.
 
My mini-canadian came with a slight burr which was easily polished of with a strop. The edge shows the high quality of the BRKT knives. It is sharpened convex to zero edge (you don't see any edge bevel). Even thought the convex shape of the grind tends to thicken the bevel, the grind is performed so well that the angle right behind the edge can be no more that about 15 degrees per side...maybe even less. I did feel compelled to put it onto a very fine waterstone eventually, though I did know that I would ruin the convex shape of the edge (not a big fan of sandpaper). But since I sharpen free hand and didn't take away much material, this is really not an issue. Due to fact the blade is ground out so fine, sharpening is quick and pure bliss: Boy that A2 steel REALLY takes an edge!
 
Northstar came. I really like it. Much smaller overall than I had had thought. I can see why the handle would be a problem for some as my griptilian has a wider one.

I consider the few little marks on the knife as character flaws. Makes my knife different.

The knife cuts like crazy is is the best looking knife I own. Great feel and a surprisingly stought blade - I was really shocked by the spine thickness. Tough little knife!
 
The Northstar looks nice, but I still think the Gameskeeper or hidden tang forager are better designs in the same relative size/price class, especially since the latter comes with a full-size grip.
Both_Knives.jpg


The bolster keeps the index finger away from the blade better than some ricasso cuts, though I wouldn't mind sending mine back to the factory to put some on the spine over the ricasso on my knives for better thumb grip, though I haven't had any problems.

I love BRK&T. The knife on the right is olivewood burl. The one on the left is curly maple, but it is currently back at the factory because Mike Stewart saw a picture of the knife and wasn't satisfied with the appearance of the wood. He said he had some fancier scales and would be happy to retrofit the knife for free. Off went the knife.

You simply don't get that kind of service many places anymore.
 
Hey all,
Thought I may as well chime in here with my .02 worth. I find these to be very, very good cutting tools as many of you here have! The convex grind is something that I had reservations about at first, but now I have found it worthy, after using and comparing these knives to similar cutlery of the same application...

I guess, what I really find very astounding is the price $$! For a bench made knife, these buggers have got to be one of the best values going out there right now. That, I believe would explain they're rapid popularity, and hold on the current market share.

These bad boys take an edge very quickly! A couple of passes along the old moon stone and I am back in business. :) .. I have recently purchased the micro's on eBay for 35. to 40. each, and I have yet to see many better values than that in a good solid tool at such a good price in a while. I figure to keep a few extras on hand for some gift giving at Christmas time. At the current prices, it is a win~win 2 be sure. :cool:

Cheers~
 

Attachments

  • 000_0119.JPG
    000_0119.JPG
    97 KB · Views: 126
I got one. I like it. I have only owned 3 Bark River knives and all had imperfections. Nothing that would impair the utility of the knife, just mostly irregularities in the handles and bolsters. My Northstar has one scale that is ground slightly lower than the tang of the knife on one side, and a little gap between the G10 and the tang on the other side.

I can see where some people would think the handle was too small, but for me it's just right. I love the design and the thickness of the blade. Also all of the Bark Rivers I have had have had excellent blades and I am a super big fan of the convex edges they put on!
 
I got a Northstar last week. Have not done any field testing with it yet.

I also have a couple of Rogues, a Woodland, a Huntsman, 4 Mikros, and a Mini.

I made Kydex sheaths for the Mini and a Mikro, and I've got one or both hanging off my belt just about everywhere I go.

I really, really like the tapered tang and the lanyard loop on the Northstar.

JR
cigarsmoker.gif
 
Back
Top