Bark River Manitou...classic and modern

Joined
Aug 1, 2008
Messages
491
I figured since hunting is so close, this might make a little teaser for some who are in the market, especially for those who will set up camp and may need a medium duty camp knife that can double up easily as a field dresser and skinner.

Anyways, I got the Bark River Manitou in a couple days back and have been itching to put it through some work. I had very high expectations of this knife and it did not disappoint me at all.

First a size comparison to the Bravo-1, Fox River and Canadian Special...all very popular Bark River knives of which many folks are already very familiar. The Manitou is second from the top with the Scarlet and Gold Elder burl...

Manitou001.jpg


Manitou002.jpg


As you see, it is the largest of the 3 but not on weight. It is very light fast in the hand for its size, but not a lightweight. The slight palm swell fills the hand nicely and is easily one of the most comfortable knives I have held.

Carrying the knife on the belt is a pleasure for a knife this size. It rides low and out of the way and is hardly, if at all, noticeable.

Since hunting has yet to begin, I will focus on it's "camp chores" abilities. For a thinner edge it batons well.

Manitou004.jpg


Manitou007.jpg


Manitou009.jpg


Now, it is not going to take abusive punishment like other "bushcraft" specific blades but never-the-less, it handles baton work easily. The edge drives very deep, very efficiently and requires very little force to do so. If you notice, every baton picture is cross grain in a large Ash limb. I never felt uneasy if I were to make a bad hit either. The knife felt very comfortable, stable and grounded in my hand at all times and was easily controlled with each hit. The tip of the knife is thin and did not see much more than light tapping but from slightly forward of the center of the spine on back to the guard, I could deliver a substantial blow to drive the edge into the Ash limb. After putting the Manitou through it's paces, the 52-100 steel shaved hair easily. Like a typical Bark River, edge retention is simply awesome.

Precise work is also very easy with the Manitou. Fuzz sticks, notching, whittling, even for it's size, come easy and is well controlled. Overall, this is a very impressive tool and should not be overlooked. The distinctive classic look from the pommel and hidden tang, to the modern drop point blade give this knife a very classic and modern look all in one package.

I purchased my knife from Derrick and Wendy at www.knivesshipfree.com and I do want to mention that they carry this knife in 2 different style handles...the pommel style, such as the one I bought and the carver style.:thumbup::thumbup:
 
That's one fine looking knife, now I'll have to add another knife to my list after the new Bravo-II:thumbup:
 
Last edited:
Very nice looker.
Have you tried it on flesh (kitchen duty)? Looks a bit thick (.2" right?) to be a deep slicer.
 
Reminds me of my Marbles knife from the late 90's. It is one of my favorites, and that one is awful nice too.

Brian
 
Reminds of the Trailguide pattern. A nice knife, I like the more traditional look.
 
I have had nothing but bad luck with BR. I have owned three and sent two of them back. I liked the Lil Nessie but no more of them for me. The two I sent back wouldn't cut butter. However more power to those who like them.
 
Awesome looking blades. I have yet to get a Bark River, but I'm always tempted. Just haven't seen the "one" yet.

Is that an Ash Leaf Maple (Boxelder)? I hope so, because several of those leaves look a lot like poison ivy.
 
Last edited:
SWEET!
:thumbup:
Thats one of the most beautiful knives i've seen!

I don't own any Barkies, been pining for an Aurora for a while though, i'll have to add this to the list too!
:D
 
Good looking blade, a heavy duty pommel can really come in handy sometimes. With apologies for asking about a different blade, how do you like that CS? Those grooves turn me off, but then I love my kephart and wasn't 'into it' based on pics I saw.
 
Twinblade,
Thanks for doing a review so soon on this great looking knife. Bark River has another winner on their hands. I know I want one, just can't decide on a Carver or Pommel. Each looks great.
 
Just a heads up...Derrick is providing us with a BRKT Manitou for yet another passaround. :D

I'll post when I receive it and we'll get people in on it...:thumbup:
 
I have had nothing but bad luck with BR. I have owned three and sent two of them back. I liked the Lil Nessie but no more of them for me. The two I sent back wouldn't cut butter. However more power to those who like them.

Wow. Real informative. Helped a lot. Thanks. :thumbup:

:rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:
 
With apologies for asking about a different blade, how do you like that CS? Those grooves turn me off, but then I love my kephart and wasn't 'into it' based on pics I saw.

No apologies needed bro. I love the CS. I was actually so surprised in it's comfort that I now have the Canadian Special (shown) the Can. Sportsman and Sportsman II (Fillet knives) and the Can. Camp knife (think 6.5" bladed Can. Special) and all of them have the grooves. I dislike grooves as well, but these are different feeling even with a variety of grips. I have beat the hell out of that knife too...very controllable in the hand.

Very nice looker.
Have you tried it on flesh (kitchen duty)? Looks a bit thick (.2" right?) to be a deep slicer.

On the contrary, it is a remarkable slicer. It has a sizable distal taper that gets real thin at the tip...hence my comment about tapping the tip for baton work. It will not take that abuse at the front third of the blade.

Here, this may help...the knife is advertised at .200-.210" and mine is .203". HOWEVER, right in front of the choil area, the blade immediately starts at .040" under that. This is part of it's design. It is not intended to be an abusive camp knife, but I will definitely say it is a "jack of all trades"...

Manitou010.jpg


Manitou011.jpg


Manitou012.jpg


:thumbup::thumbup:
 
Awesome looking blades. I have yet to get a Bark River, but I'm always tempted. Just haven't seen the "one" yet.

Is that an Ash Leaf Maple (Boxelder)? I hope so, because several of those leaves look a lot like poison ivy.

Hey ejes,

It's Ash Leaf Maple (AKA Boxelder, AKA Manitoba Maple, AKA Acer negundo, and a whole lot of other AKA's). If you look in the third picture, you will see it's opposite leaved. Poison Ivy (Toxicodendron spp.) is alternate. You're right though, about it closely resembling Poison Ivy at times.

Doc
 
I have had nothing but bad luck with BR. I have owned three and sent two of them back. I liked the Lil Nessie but no more of them for me. The two I sent back wouldn't cut butter. However more power to those who like them.

Sorry to hear of your bad experience. I know they have sometimes sent out blades that aren't perfect (sent one back myself), but they quickly took care of the problem and sent it back like it should be.

Don't think you should stop buying the brand if you otherwise like their knives..

Sverre

PS! Nice review. Love the distal taper and bladeshape:thumbup:
 
I should have added in my last post that, although I'm a full exposed tang fanatic, that is an excellent looking knife.

Doc
 
Hey ejes,

It's Ash Leaf Maple (AKA Boxelder, AKA Manitoba Maple, AKA Acer negundo, and a whole lot of other AKA's). If you look in the third picture, you will see it's opposite leaved. Poison Ivy (Toxicodendron spp.) is alternate. You're right though, about it closely resembling Poison Ivy at times.

Doc

Thanks Doc! I thought the wood bark looked like that, but the leaf set in pic #4 had me second guessing myself. You know how it is when you've been bitten bad by something; you get gun-shy of anything that looks even remotely like it. One of the reasons I can't even stand the smell of Canadian Mist whiskey or anything that looks or smells like it (long, ugly story of a rough night in Chicago...:barf:). :D
 
BTW--the Manitou is 52-100 steel. It is tough and takes an incredible edge. I am sure you guys will love it when you do the passaround.
 
Back
Top