Been Awhile! - Closet Clean Out - But cant decide which one to hold as the belt knife

[GambitJYD]

Experts and Couch analyst alike - want to to get your input/opinions

I am going though the "Closet" at the Ranch and I've decided to sell some stuff ( haven't really used them) and keep a couple - I really only need one good all around carry from the bunch - but I get analysis paralysis like most and wanted to get your opinions on what the best one to keep is.
Now a days I use a skinning knife and a ZT0909 more than anything....but want to keep a solid carry blade. Ease of field sharpening and retention being high on my list. How would you rank these?

Sage Colored Scrap Yard SOD - Moving it - Wont be battling Bears toe 2 toe anymore - They ran off!
Sage Colored Scrap Yard Keeper - For discussion
Scrapper 5 - Black on Grey Mudder Grips - For discussion
Scrapper 5 - INFI on Black Mudder Grips - For discussion
Scrapyard Mud Puppy LE - For discussion
Bark River Bravo - A2 Micarta - For discussion

 

[itsafire]

I'd stick with the Bark River because it's something different to the others.

I'd also hold on to the second knife in your list. Why you ask? Easy: It's a Keeper. (badumm, tsss).

 

[91bravo]

Personally, I’d keep the INFI scrapper. You couldn’t give me a Bark River.

 

[SharpBits]

I'd say whichever of the two Scrapper 5 knives you like best.