Benchmade Nagara Nak-Lok

Joined
Jul 27, 2005
Messages
8,169
I recently visited the Eastern Sportsmans show in harrisburg, PA. One of the many vendors there sells a wide assortment of knives ranging from so-so knock offs to Benchmade/Protech and some better. I picked up a few knives and one of those was the Benchmade Nagara Nak-Lok. I got a First Production piece #232/1000. When he first brought it out and I saw that "red box" I was a bit hesitant but new benchmade makes good stuff even in there red box models.

My first impression was WOW thats a really sweet knife. It felt slightly hefty in the hand at 3.3 oz, the Fit and Finish were a great example of a Benchmade knife....very good. The blade length is 3.25 inches an spec's out at .120 inches thick. The blade is made of Benchmades 9CR13 Stainless Steel which I have not had much experience with. The handle scales are titanium with little character just a groove for your finger and a groove at the front of the scale. Opening the knife was very smooth and clean. The knife locked firm but quiet. I have wide hands and the handle felt good and filled it nicely, not too thin but certainly not thick. The Nak-Lock is a button that pushes over a liner over the back of the blade, somewhat like a Spyderco compression lock but built in with a button. Not the same but similar. The button depressed smooth and the knife closed very easily.

One thing I noticed about the knife that I thought "wow benchmade REALLY thought about this" was how it opens. When you put your finger on the thumb stud (which is ambidextrous) and press to slide it open you notice the machined groove your thumb slides over when you open the knife. Benchmade COULD have left that area flat like the rest of the handle but put the grooves on both sides in there so your thumb could easily slide the blade into the locked position. This makes opening the knife easier imho and if left flat could have made it not as comfortable to open and close.

The blade is a drop point that has a fine tip, it came hair popping sharp out of the box. I cut some steak up with it and cardboard and is still just as sharp as when I got it. Cutting with it was comfortable and it felt good and lively in my hand. It cut through the steak and cardboard easily with no issues. The tip is fine, not too fine but this is not a pry bar by any means and I woud not use the tip for anything but general piercing. It reminds me of a gents folder for sure. The grind lines are prefect on both sides.

The clip is very basic, highly polished and can be mounted on either side, it rides reasonably in the pocket. Not really low but low enough for my tastes. Taking it in and out of the pocket is smooth due to the ti-scales.

I have not had the knife long enough to evalaute the steel but I am sure it will do fine for the general EDC tasks I need it for. As for play? There is none in any direction and the blade came dead center (a pet peeve of min). As time wears on I will see how well the lock holds and if any play develops, which based on the lock I am sure none will.

Conclusion: This knife represents a great value to me and I would think to everyone else. Titanium scales, decent steel, very good fit and finish and smooth operation. For the price (around 70 dollars) its hard to beat. Dont let the red box and made in china fool you, this could easily sell for much more and if they put S30V in it I could see going for 150. I have no pictures but am showing one from knifecenter. I HIGHLY recommend purchasing one as an edc or a gents knife.
 

Attachments

  • BM10700.jpg
    BM10700.jpg
    20.1 KB · Views: 627
Nice review. Great observations. And it is a pretty blade.

I have this alloy, 9Cr13CoMoV, in the mini-pika II and have done edge retention testing using manila rope. I found that the alloy as heat treated in the Mini-Pika II performed better than an 8Cr13MoV Byrd Flight and better than an AUS8 Ka-Bar Large Dozier. The edge retention was less than a 154CM mini-grip, N690 Monochrome or VG10 Native III.

So the steel is pretty good stuff.

Hard to beat a good design with good steel.
 
Good review Barrabas74. I have one and I think you covered the knife real well. I have a Mini Pika 2 In TI and forgot it had the same steel. The Nagara is the only new BM knife I like. The torrent looks good but I have not seen one yet. I am partial to the Axis lock but this lock is nice on the Nagara. I don't care for thick clunky knives and lately the BM are a little thick and heavy for my likes.The Nagara ia a classy slim beautiful knife and not to thick.

RKH
 
I just thought I'd chime in here about the factory edges on BM knives. I bought a Pika II and it came shaving sharp, though the angles were uneven and it took a while to resharpen after dulling. Some sections of the blade would actually shave above the skin. I also sent off my 805 TSEK for a new blade. I had worn the old one down until the point was almost sticking out of the handle. They only had partially serrated ones left, but I like BM's serrations better than others, so its not a huge loss. I just started carrying it yesterday, and noticed the plain edge portion will also shave above the skin, and some sections will whittle hair.
 
Thanx for the review,i am still lost @ the lock,:thumbup: when the knife is open do you push the button in to release the blade..........
 
Here is a picture of the lock, I dont have a good camera with a decent macro on me but here are some pics. Its next to a benchmade Kulgera for size comparison.

you do press the button to depress the liner and close the knife.
IMG_0153.jpg


Not as good a pic
IMG_0148.jpg


Sorry bout the finger prints
IMG_0151.jpg


IMG_0152.jpg


Here it is in hand
IMG_0149.jpg


Here is a pic where the thumb slides across the groove to open it showing how well thought that groove is
IMG_0150.jpg
 
Thanks for the nice review.

I am still waiting for mine to arrive from knifecenter as well. Looking forward to trying out the nak-lock (seems kinda like a button push liner). Also, I noticed you have a Kulgera, I have the exact same knife and love it.

Regards,

Shea
 
nice looking knife, and thx for the review.

the button appears to protrude from the scale relatively significantly. have you noticed any indication that different grips may disengage the lock?
 
I played with one of these in person recently and had a good time with. Not my thing, but felt and looked very high quality. My girlfriend loved it.
 
nice looking knife, and thx for the review.

the button appears to protrude from the scale relatively significantly. have you noticed any indication that different grips may disengage the lock?

If you pinch your thumbs on the side of the scales it didnt disengage, as long as I dont put direct pressure on the lock pin IE: intentionally doing so I havent had a problem. This was a concern to me in the beginning as well, but having used and owned many William Henrys that employ a button lock I am used to working "around it" so to speak.

In an ice pick grip my pinky feels the button but even with hard pressure on the pinky there isnt enough direct pressure to really push the button. Using it like a filet knife and putting your thumb on the side of the knife I can feel the button but even while pressing hard I didnt have it disengage. Your right it does protrude a bit but so far so good.

I am edc'n this guy for a bit so if I come accross anything I can let you all know.
 
Thanks for the great review! That lock looks like Warren Osbourne's "strap-lock" with a push button added. Does the liner wedge between the blade-tang and the pin just rear of the stop-pin?

Regards,
3G
 
It makes it so much easier to get a feel for the knife when it's reviewed that like. In the hand, next to knives we may know. Puts a face oce on the Specs. Thanks & Good Job.

I have this alloy, 9Cr13CoMoV, in the mini-pika II and have done edge retention testing using manila rope. I found that the alloy as heat treated in the Mini-Pika II performed better than an 8Cr13MoV Byrd Flight and better than an AUS8 Ka-Bar Large Dozier. The edge retention was less than a 154CM mini-grip, N690 Monochrome or VG10 Native III.
.
This info was plesant suprise. :thumbup:
 
Yeah I know what you mean, I should have put it next to a small sebbie or griptilian for a better view but those were the two I had on me.

I just did some cutting of cat-5 cable with it the last few days and it did ok. It resharpened real easily and is back to hair poppin sharp, this steel takes a real nice edge.
 
Thanks for the review.

I picked one up yesterday, and agree that the fit and finish are really great, except in my case, the thread on one of the clip screws became stripped when I tried to re-tighten it. I did not severely overtorque it, in my opinion.

I will take it back to the B&M I bought it from today.

The other thing about this knife (I still like it, OTHER then this issue), is that deploying it with the thumb stud is much more difficult then it should be. I am comparing this to deployment of Axis knives, liners, and Spyderco lock backs.

Once you get past the resistance of the detent, it opens up smooth, but just doing the initial opening is killing my thumb.

I'm curious if this is the same experience others have with this knife, or if easier openings are more the norm?
 
I've played with a few and they opened glassy-smooth for me.
 
Back
Top