Benchmade question?

Joined
Dec 22, 2004
Messages
29
I am seriously thinking about getting a Benchmade and I have a few ?'s first. There are 2 that I am interested in: The Skirmish and the Resistor. I know that G10 and S30V are two top qualities looked for in a knife, but the Resistor has 154CM and the handle is part anodized aluminum. How corrosion resistant and durable is aluminum and how does 154CM stack up to S30V? Does anyone own one of these knives or heard anything about them? How is the monolock system on the Skirmish? I assume the AXIS is the best? Is the titanium handle on the Skirmish good compared to G10?

Thanks Jim
 
Aluminum is almost as corrosion resistant as titanium. Some people don't like metal handles, though, especially in winter :) or if the knife is going to be used for cutting up animals or food, which might make those handles too slippery. I generally prefer metal.

G-10 may be the best of the plastic-like materials. It was originally developed for circuit boards and is highly resistant to corrosion, acids, electricity, blood, sweat, and tears. But Micarta is also good, and Zytel or F(iberglas) R(einforced) N(ylon) is quite serviceable, too, although some consider it cheap. Stabilized woods, impregnated with preservatives, are practically as durable as these artificial materials.

154-CM is a recent "super steel" and the American twin to the highly regarded Japanese ATS-34. Its properties are now well known and its heat treatment is pretty well assured. Yes, S30V is the "latest and greatest" but that doesn't invalidate the quality of earlier excellent choices.

How a company heat treats its blades, what the thickness and sharpening angle is, and how the edge is shaped are all at least as important as the actual steel used. In fact, a good, cheap, old fashioned high carbon steel will intrinsically outperform all but the very most expensive of the new stainless steels. It just rusts more easily, which reasonable maintainance can avoid.

Ranking locks is an unnecessary enterprise. Many are more than good enough, holding up against more force than the human hand is ever likely to apply. The frame lock (monolock) is extremely reliable. So is the axis lock. The axis lock is more fun to play with. Lockbacks are almost foolproof. Slipjoints themselves are perfectly safe if the user only remembers to cut with the edge and not with the back.

The frame lock is a development of the liner lock, which when properly constructed is also reliable. The SOG arc lock, Cold Steel ultra lock, and Spyderco ball lock are all variants of the axis lock principle, which itself is similar to the old Gerber bolt action lock. But no folder lock is inherently as strong as a well made fixed blade.
 
"G-10 may be the best of the plastic-like materials. It was originally developed for circuit boards and is highly resistant to corrosion, acids, electricity, blood, sweat, and tears. But Micarta is also good, and Zytel or F(iberglas) R(einforced) N(ylon) is quite serviceable, too, although some consider it cheap. Stabilized woods, impregnated with preservatives, are practically as durable as these artificial materials."

Well, I guess that's a lesson. Don't cry over you knives. ;)

People also like G-10 because of the way it is usually finished that provides lots of protection. It also does not get "pocket rash" or get worn from EDCing it.



"154-CM is a recent "super steel" and the American twin to the highly regarded Japanese ATS-34. Its properties are now well known and its heat treatment is pretty well assured. Yes, S30V is the "latest and greatest" but that doesn't invalidate the quality of earlier excellent choices."

Both are good.



"How a company heat treats its blades, what the thickness and sharpening angle is, and how the edge is shaped are all at least as important as the actual steel used. In fact, a good, cheap, old fashioned high carbon steel will intrinsically outperform all but the very most expensive of the new stainless steels. It just rusts more easily, which reasonable maintainance can avoid."



"The axis lock is more fun to play with"

Ah, yes! :) fun fun!
 
Berettas,

These are both large knives but big in different ways. I have the Skirmish and the fixed blade resistor. The folding resistor has a longer blade than the fixed.

The Resistor has a shorter blade than the Skirmish but a thick handle with the aluminum and the G10 overlay.

The Skirmish has a larger blade at 4.4" but is very flat with the titanium handles. The knife is long and the blade is quite broad but it is thin in the pocket.

Two very different knives, both large but in very different ways. The fixed and folding resistors are very different as well with the fixed being a very slim package,I only with it had the same blade length of the folder.
 
Back
Top