Benchmade River/Rescue...any opinions?

Joined
Jun 26, 2001
Messages
72
I'm toying with the idea of picking up a Benchmade River/Rescue (plain edge) for use as a general purpose backpacking knife.

Anybody here own one or have any opinions on this design?
 
I like the design of the RRK but before you buy it check out Swamp Rat Knife Works. They are a devision of Busse Knives and they make a medium size knife called the Camp Tramp for $130. The best part is they still offer an all inclusive warrenty, it even covers all out abuse! :D
 
Originally posted by will22
I like the design of the RRK but before you buy it check out Swamp Rat Knife Works. They are a devision of Busse Knives and they make a medium size knife called the Camp Tramp for $130. The best part is they still offer an all inclusive warrenty, it even covers all out abuse!

Gee will22, did you know that the Benchmade R&R is an uncoated stainless (GIN-1) sheepsfoot knife with about a 4 inch blade, removeable G-10 scales and a kydex sheath? I doubt it. Why bother posting an opinion about a knife you have likely never handled and certainly never used and then suggesting another far more expensive knife that you have never handled and never used? Get real.:barf:

Back to topic:

Six String - the R&R is a very nice knife for the price. I used a BM Nimravus (from which the R&R was derived) and it is a very good backpacking knife. The GIN-1 steel is quite adequate and has good stain resistance. I think though, that you will find that the very specialized sheath supplied with the R&R may not be your first choice for a backpacking knife. Unfortunately, getting an aftermarket sheath will cost you another $35 or so, which brings the price up to $80-$100 depending on where you purchase the R&R.

So I would advise you to handle the knife with the sheath first. If you find the sheath is acceptable, then I suggest it is a good value. However, if you find it clumsy (I did)you may want to look at other knives such as:

Spyderco Moran Drop Point (great kydex sheath)

Grohmann Model #1 with Micarta Handle (special order)decent leather pouch sheath (or Marshman Brothers stocks aftermarket kydex)

Others swear by Fallkniven such as the F1 which comes with multiple sheath options.

None of these follows the sheepsfoot pattern, but they are all great cutters and very versatile. Each has a good sheath option as part of the basic purchase. The Spyderco and Fallkniven use VG-10 steel, the Grohmann uses an unidentified "German Stainless Steel" which is rumored to be 440A. I have recently gotten a Grohmann Survivial knife, but haven't cut a thing with it yet.
 
. . . in fact that's what brought me here. You can find all my questions and the members' answers by searching my user name. After a lot of reading I narrowed it down to an M2 Nimravus or a Gerber Yari. As much as I like what I have read about Benchmade's M2, I went with the Yari based on Hoodoo's recommendation and the $65 price at Wholesale Hunter ($76 delivered). The flat grind Grohman's look real nice, too. I think Marshman Bros. also sells some carbon steel models for those who prefer it.
 
Originally posted by Six String Samurai
I'm toying with the idea of picking up a Benchmade River/Rescue (plain edge) for use as a general purpose backpacking knife.

Anybody here own one or have any opinions on this design?

I think I'd have to throw in with will22 on this. As far as size is concerned, anyway. The blade on the River/Rescue is slightly over 3", and backpack implies hiking in the woods. If you have to make yourself a crutch, splint, or just a walking stick while you're out there, I think you'll get tired of the short blade pretty quick. My stockman pocketknife has a 3" blade, after all.

If you have to cut through any underbrush you'll probably appreciate the longer blade, also.

I don't know that I'd pick the Camp Tramp, but I'd pick something similar.

Maybe I don't understand what you mean by backpack knife. Maybe you guys take six or eight different size knives with you when you go out, but I'd pick something bigger. :)
 
Until I discovered these forums and caught the disease I only carried an SAK Huntsman or Outrider. I've been hiking and camping in the Cascades since the '70s and haven't regretted it yet . . .
 
Back
Top