Best Serrations

Joined
Oct 24, 2005
Messages
2,823
Thanks for the input on my previous question guys. Now I have another question to throw out there. Of the production manufacturers, who do you think makes the best serrated/partially serrated knives out there? I'm not really a big fan of serrations, but I'm coming around to them( mostly by choice:) )I mean this in terms of use and in terms of ease in sharpening. Thanks again.
 
The king of serrations on pocketknives is Spyderco. I don't know if they invented it (although I wouldn't be supprised if they had), but they certainly made it popular. And IMO, they're the best ones out there.

I just wish they were ground on the other side.
 
Buck does a pretty good job on their serrations. They are not that hard to maintain. I agree the Spyderco's are the best. They glide over the Sharpmaker.
 
Yet another vote for Spyderco. Definitely, if you want a SE, than it's a Spyderco.
 
I agree. Spyderco serrations are the best in the industry. Others seem to copy "the look" but sorely lack the cutting power when the rubber meets the road in actual use. Also, if you'll note, Spyderco serrations are different on each blade they're put on. It's like they've been custom matched to the edge type, blade length and overall grind angle of that particular blade. There's a world of difference between the serrations on a Lum Chinese folder vs the teeth on the Military. Yet both are on flat ground blades. Still and all, they each cut like lasers. The Jester has much smaller teeth (of course) but they cut just as efficently (for a knife this puny) while somehow still fitting the edges of the triangle stones for sharpening.

Over the lifespan of the serrated edge, the points wear and get more rounded. With Spyderco serrations this doesn't seem to have any adverse effect of the cutting performance. My wife has worn the tips of her K04 kitchen knife down to comical looking "bumps" but the Sharpmaker still puts a wonderful cutting edge back on it without a problem. Over time I fully expect this knife to become a plainedge as she refuses to stop using ceramic platters for cutting boards. I've also worn the tips down on my Jester which I use for every abusive cutting job I won't subject my EDC Military to. Rounded tips and all, I wouldn't want that puny little knife aimed at me. Actually, when the tips get a little rounded the knife seems to glide better and not snag as readily.

Victorinox serrations are fairly decent also, a distant second place. The teeth on my Swisstool Spirit are still going strong after over a year of rough use and they sharpen up real nice on the Sharpmaker. They cut with a different "attitude" than Spyderco teeth and don't hold their sharpness nearly as long but they perform better than other serrations in the industry.
 
I like the Benchmade Serrations. I think they are as good as any. The Griptilian 551 model has a very good combo edge.

http://www.benchmade.com/products/product_detail.aspx?model=551

The Boker Kalashnikov AK-74 knife is not a bad deal for an auto serrated knife.

http://www.fernknives.com/boker/kalashnikov/1183/index.html

My favorite is the Protech TR-3 series combo blade. It is a very good cutter.

http://www.protechknives.com/products.asp?productID=3


Let me toss this out? Has anyone ever seen a cutting contest for serrated edge folders? I think that would be a neat article in a knife magazine or an activity at a knife show. It will cut out all the "I think's"!
 
Spyderco did not invent the serrated edge, but they have done a lot of research and testing to create an efficient serration pattern. I have found that their serrations work better than anyone else's I've tried. There are plenty that do just fine, but if you want the best get a SpyderEdge.

--Bob Q
 
I guess which is best is somewhat determined on what you typically are cutting.

Spyderco knives are too aggressive and/or grabby to me. They typically need 'softened' to work on softer materials like rope and cloth and just rip and fray them rather than cut IMO. I've had the serrations from my Salt 1, and Endura both grip so well that they pull a rag I'm trying to cut down right out of my hand rather than cut it.

This trait is just on some of their knives though as they do not have the same aggressive serrations on all their knives from what I've gathered.

Cold Steel serrations are ok and cut good when new but the new ones with the needle point type teeth on them are about impossible to resharpen and the teeth break off very easily. Their older serrations were the best especially when used in conjunction with one of their Nogales clip point blades. I have never used a better serrated knife than my Cold Steel full serration Vaquero with the older style serrations they used to offer.

BenchMades serrations are great and so are Emerson knives. If I had to pick one as the best at this writing I'd go with either of these for my top pick. Its a tough call. Probably Emerson's dragon teeth work better as the serrations on my BM420 Resistor seem as aggresive as some of my Spyderco knives.

Buck makes a great serration pattern also. I really like the ones on my 882 Tarani folder over all but my Emerson knives.
 
The best: Benchmade & Spyderco.
The worst: Cold Steel...(too brittle).
 
I think Chris Reeves makes the best serrations I have EVER seen on a knife!! The next would be Spyderco, bar none!!
 
Spyderco has the best serrations; great cutters. I am suprised at the worst, Benchmade - Pika has the most anemic serrations. I had to buy a DMT tool and file on them to get some teeth.
 
To me, Spyderco makes the best serrations. This is said for the one knife where I found the serrations very agreeable. The Large and Small Manix have wavy serrations versus the more fang-like serrations Spyderco normally has. I see those as easier to sharpen, and less likely to break as I've done with past serrated knives.
 
My vote is Spyderco. But somehow that doesnt surprise me. I can say that I dont like the little bitty serrations you know the ones .
To me its important to be able to sharpen a serrated knife. Even the kitchen steak knives. When I look at a serrated knife the first question is can I sharpen it. If I cant then I dont buy./
jack
 
Back
Top