Best steel for throwers?

[black mariah]

After a bit of practice on wood and experimentation finding the right shape, I've decided to go ahead and grind out a few throwers. These are going to be about 13" long when I'm done. What would be a good choice of steel to use? I'm thinking 5160, but I'd like some more input.

 

[Bobwhite]

Not an expert by any means but from what I do know that is a sound choice if you don't harden it too much. You want it on the soft side so it won't crack or chip.

 

[Bobby Branton]

5160 will do a fine job. The best that I've found and used for many many years is 1050 hardened at RC44-46. If you have any doubts, check this link out http://www.brantonknives.com/serv02.htm


Bobby

 

[black mariah]

I've seen that page a few times before. My crappy little Screaming Arrows bend like that on one miss. I'll get both 5160 and 1050 and see how it works out. Thanks a lot.

 

[Bobby Branton]

The difference is that mine will spring back to shape. Mine is bent with a 20 ton press, not by throwing.

Bobby

 

[black mariah]

Yeah, I know. These Screaming Arrows are total crap. After every session I have to straighten the things out. It's kind of fun pretending to be Superman, bending them back into shape by hand.

 

[toolmaker]

ive always been partial to L6. nearly indestructable steel. keeps an edge, you can chop wood with it, throw it, immerse in salt water, dig a hole, whatever. takes a licking and keeps on ticking.