Best tactical folder under 4" (spring assisted?)

Joined
Jan 19, 2012
Messages
16
I am new to this form and just have a few knives, a Benchmade, a few Kershaws and CRKT's. I have been looking into something in a tactical knife; 3.60" to 4" in length. I do a fair amount of hiking and looking for a folder that i could carry. I was thinking SOG Trident w/ tanto edge? I would perfer an assisted opener but i am not 100% locked on that. Also I live in CT and i am locked to a 3.99" carry limit. I have a $150 or so budget to work with.

thanks guys for the input
Andrew
 
I would recommend a Spyderco Para 2. A great knife, and carries very easily. For assisted openning, the Benchmade Torrent is very nice, although neither are Tanto points.
 
Azad, I've owned I think 5 SOG knives, still have 3, and the folders I currently have are the Pentagon and the X-ray Vision Mini. These folders use an outstanding locking system called the SOG Arc lock, and I would HIGHLY recommend that if you get a SOG knife, make sure you get one that uses this lock system. It is their best IMHO, and one of the best locking systems available, roughly equivalent with the Benchmade Axis lock in strength.

Personally, I'd probably steer clear of SOG if this is to be your ONE go-to knife, and if you want high reliability. I like the design of my SOGS, but they have had maintenance issues of and of the 4 SOG folders I've owned, 3 of them have had to go back for tuning/maintenance within the first 6 months of owning them. They have had some QC issues, at least in my experience and I'm not the only one who has observed this.

Another note, is that I'd suggest avoiding assisted openers. The better locking systems today, like the Benchmade Axis lock and several of Spyderco's best locking systems, allow you to open a knife quickly and one-handed, and there's simply no reason to add the extra mechanical complexity of an assisted opener. The assisted opener just means more springs, more parts, more stuff that wears out and breaks down. I'd avoid assisted openers altogether, and stick with a quality knife that can be opened with one hand.

With that said, here are a few suggestions in your price range:
Spyderco options:
* Para Military 2. This is the shortest one of the bunch at about 3.5" blade, but still a great knife.
* Military
* Police
* Endura. ***This is probably the 'value' option: gets you a quality blade near 4", a strong lock, good steel, and a reasonable price. You can even get a special Endura wave edition that has the Emerson "wave" opening feature, where there's a hook in the blade that will catch on your pocket and open the blade instantly as you draw it. Very slick, very effective. Might want to look at this.
* New Manix 2 XL edition. ***This new XL edition of the Manix has a nearly 4" blade, as opposed to the earlier ones that had a shorter blade.

Benchmade options
* Mchenry Williams in M390. Awesome 4" blade, a classic!
* Benchmade Adamas. A new hard-use folder in D2 steel, made for mil/leo users. Great-looking blade, but VERY heavy for daily carry, it's nearly 8 oz which is about twice what a typical folder is!

Zero Tolerance options
* ZT 200. A big, beefy blade in 154cm. Outstanding, but like the Adamas, REALLY heavy at 8 oz.
* The forthcoming ZT 561. These are the Rick Hinderer collaboration knives. Powerful framelock design, Elmax super-steel. Outstanding choice, but these are outside your budget, they'll run $200 to $250 plus you can't get them yet.

Hogue options
* The new Hogue EX-01 folder. You can get them in 3.5" or 4" designs, and tanto or drop point blades. Running around $200.



Depending on your price range, if it were me, I'd probably get the Endura (if I were wanting to spend less money but still get a solid knife), or if you've got more to work with, I'd get either the Mchenry Williams or the Hogue.
 
i own the sog trident with tango edge. i bought it way back when i 1st really started carrying knives. it is a decent knife. i used mine so much the tango edge is rounded off.(can't see in this picture) i would not recommend it to anyone looking for a working knife. the paracord cutter/seat beat cutter doesn't work even with a sharp blade. blade steel tends to roll a lot, and the assisted opening is decent but it makes one handed closing a challenge to not slip and cut yourself. mine has developed blade play after honestly mild use over the few months i carried it.

thats just my opinion though the houge ex-01 is amazing though, i bought on a month ago and has been awarded the RFP as a home. blade design is great even tho I'm not the largest tango fanboy. i couldn't say no to the edges and angles grinded on the ex-01. and its a very large knife which i prefer.


2011-12-20011747.jpg

2012-01-15194435.jpg

2012-01-15193951.jpg

2012-01-15194045.jpg

2012-01-15194025.jpg




*save up a few more weeks, and buy a houge :)
 
Honestly, the Kershaw Blur in 154cm or s30v will fit your criteria. It's about a 3.6" blade in a stout 1/8" stock with strong aluminum handle. You get Kershaw's top notch warranty as well. You can always remove the torsion bar if you decide to and get a manual knife. I have one, it's my favorite EDC bar none.
 
The paramilitary 2 is a great folding knife. But its not assited I know gerber has some great assited folding knifes
 
Thanks everyone for the input, Ill have to do some more homework it seems now. After reading a few more reviews on the SOG Trident i think im going to put that one at the bottom of the pack at this time. I have used a Spyderco but have i personally have a hard time opening them with the thumb hole. At a quick glance the Hogue EX 01 seems like a well made knife. I have personally never heard that Hogue made knives, but i have shot a few hand guys with their grips and i was very pleased. Would this be more bang for the buck then any benchmade knife in comparsion?

thanks again everyone, sure am learning alot
Andrew
 
Azad, I don't think you'll go wrong with either the Hogue or Benchmade McHenry Williams knife. Benchmade knife has some real positives: it's a classic (it's been out for years and is widely admired, owned, and proven as a great knife), it has awesome steel (M390--which is better than the Hogue steel), and of course Benchmade is famous for good quality and great service. If you ever have an issue, they'll take care of you. On the other hand, the Hogue is a new up-and-comer, and Elishewitz (who did the design) is an awesome designer with a strong track record. The Hogue is definitely a bit more "beefy" than the Benchmade: it weighs more, and some would say it has a stronger locking mechanism. I agree that it weighs more, I don't know about the locking thing. Benchmade Axis locks are incredibly strong; you just don't hear about them failing.

Of these two knives, if it were me, I'd go for the Benchmade because primarily the things I mentioned: a more proven design, a top-notch blade steel, and Benchmade's excellent service.
 
Back
Top