No reason they wouldn't work, but either is going to start cutting a flat microbevel onto the convex edge. The steel has nothing to do with it, it's the type of grind. If you want to maintain the covex grind, just stick a few sheets of wet/dry paper (probably around 800 grit or so) in your pocket, and when seated use your thigh for backing. You should be pulling your edge across the paper and not pushing so cutting through and getting yourself isn't a concern. For that matter, unless it's going to be a really long journey, you're building several shelters or skinning many animals, extensive field sharpening isn't a concern anyway. If you do decide to stick in an EZ-lap or something like that and still want to maintain the grind, just try to use light pressure and keep it, like stropping with the paper, to pulling the edge across versus pushing it against. This should pull most edge imperfections back to straight and hopefully not remove as much steel.