BLADE Magazine on DVDs, and other DVD-based book.

Joined
Dec 31, 2000
Messages
17,079
The First 25 Years, Blade Magazine, 1973-1997 DVD

Y0602.jpg


The layout and organization tools are excellent, especially the Table of Contents and the Bookmarks.

Responsiveness of the file is rather slow, probably even more of an issue for lower-performance computers. This is perhaps due to the entire 25 years' worth of magazines being wrapped up into a single 1.36 GB pdf file, rather than being split up somehow. To solve this problem, copy the pdf file to hard drive.

The low satisfaction is almost entirely due to the poor resolution of the pdf files. I'm using a 24" widescreen monitor. When the pages are enlarged to 177% to fill the screen, pages become practically unreadable. Even viewing at 100% the larger print and pictures are fine, but the normal text print is difficult and uncomfortable to read.

-------------------------

Blade Magazine, 1997-2007 DVD

Z5686.jpg


This is a huge improvement over the 1973-1997 25 Years DVD. The pictures and text are sharp and readable even at 215% enlargement (full screen on my 24" wide screen monitor), and almost as good as print at 100%. Even the very small print publisher's notice (inside front cover) is easily readable.

The DVD is laid out with each magazine a separate pdf file, and the issues sorted into folders by year.

The smaller files make for a very fast response time when browsing and opening magazine issues.

Unfortunately, unlike the 25 Years collection, there is no Table of Contents, Bookmarks, or other organization tool.

---------------------------

American Premium Guide to Knives and Razors, by Jim Sargent

Z5022.jpg


First impression, the title is misleading. "American Premium Guide to Knives and Razors" gives the impression this is a broad-ranging guidebook, instead the information is almost entirely limited to Case knives.

The book is 503 pages total. The first few pages of the book are basic definitions, parts of a knife, etc. Very easy to understand and clearly labeled information. Pages 24-420 are all about Case knives. Pages 421-503 are Queen knives. And that's it. No Buck, no Schrade, no Camillus, nothing else.

My second impression is, Wow the print is incredible! The text quality is amazing at any resolution. The photos look sharp at 212% (Fit to Width), but start to pixelate well before 400%.

Disk response is very fast. Entire book is a single file of only 53 MB.

The Bookmarks toolbar seems to be closed by default, but once open allows for simple and fast navigation of book chapters.
 
I haven't even gotten around to looking at the first 25-year DVD yet.

I have looked at the second one (1997 to 2007/2008) and most of it is pretty good as far as quality is concerned.

Only some of the later years look like they were in a rush to scan some of them and have excess borders around them that aren't present in earlier issues.

They are way behind in adding newer years (2009/2010/2011) to the collection though.
 
Thanks for the reviews. I was looking at those DVD offers recently. Think I'll go with the Blade Magazine, 1997-2007 DVD.
 
I purchased these as a the two-set bundle, which was much less expensive than purchasing both separately. Plus I had a coupon.

So while the financial hit was not significant, I'm still disappointed in not being able to comfortably read all of those great old magazines.
 
Good review and pdf magazines do not need to suck. I subscribe to one survival magazine on pdf but have also received a paper version and the quality of text, photos, and even layout is exactly the same! It is all based on the company and if they really care about the quality of their product.
 
Back
Top