I had a similar experience. Shout out to Amber with their CS team - needed a screw for my Grip, called BM and Amber had a set mailed out to me.
Unfortunately, when I got the package, it did not include the screw I needed. Another quick call to BM (spoke to Amber again) and she mailed out another set.
Showed up 3 days later with the correct screws and my Grip is back to normal.
I am super pleased with Benchmade's CS Team and warranty service.