BM Park AVenue, Opinions?

Architect

Gold Member
Joined
May 31, 2001
Messages
2,213
If you have one of these knives, do you care to take a crack a sharing your opinions?

I bought a Spyderco Calypso and Calypso Jr. with the thought of making one of these my EDC. As much as I like these knives, I will always pick up a liner or frame lock design over a lockback for EDC minor office use. I recently got the BM 940 KOTM, which is very nice, but I am intrigued by the idea of the "pocket chain" carry versus clip carry. Is there anything that you don't like about the Park Avenue? I would much appreciate your time.
 
It is small. I did not like the ergonomics. It has an anodized aluminum handle that will in time show scuffs with pocked carry. I guess I don't like metal handles.
 
I handled one in a store. It's small and thin, a gentlemans knife not for hard use. Unlike Roger, I love metal handled knives, a good hard anodized coat can take much abuse.

I have actually used a green 3M scrub pad to remove metal left on various BM and CRKT anodized handles by coins and keys.

However, the pocket chain left me cold, it just didn't seem easy to use. I also am not a fan of coated blades.

It felt okay in my hand (don't expect much for ergo in this small and thin a knife), good materials, usual good BM fit and finish, looks nice.

I would buy one if it weren't for the coated blade and the somewhat high price.

Hopes this helps. :)


Steve-O
 
I like the #450 a lot. Small, flat and unobtrusive, it's a classy little gent's knife that is very well made. Of course it's not for skinning deer, (but of course it COULD), it'll handle most chores asked of a pocket knife. The little sterling silver chain is not needed but a nice touch. The BM Mel Pardue #330 was always one of my favorite BM's, (and pocket knives), but I actually like the #450 better.
 
I was pretty excited about this knife until I handled one in a store. While it's nice, it's just too small for me to comfortably open one-handed. And my hands aren't that big. Same thing with the 770 & MOD Ladyhawk. Unless your hands are tiny, I'd recommend handling before you order. Other than the size I couldn't find anything wrong with it.
 
Received my new BM450 today from Roger at Bayou Lafourche. As in my previous experience, the item was in stock, shipped immediately and was offered at the lowest price in the United States (and I did a lot of looking and calling).

My review comments:

Metal Handle - either you like them or you don't. The aluminum scales are elegantly shaped and are visually very precise. The boxy look with minimal curvature is a good piece of industrial design and very consistent with the "Park Avenue" name.

Coated "Wharncliffe" Blade: I too do not like coated blades. I have a Boker Klotzli KLM3 with a satin glossy black coating which many others have found objectionable, and I rarely carry. I prefer a satin finish with obvious grind marks to keep glare down. Compared to my BM940, which is too shiny for my taste, the boron coating on this blade is great. It has a "transparent" quality which keeps it away from looking like it was dipped. You can still see the metal under the coating. Comparing it to the CRKT Wasp, it retains a clean and easily cleanable surface, wheras the Wasp features the bead blast finish which as too much surface texture and fouls easily.

Blade came out of box razor sharp and cleared at 2" x 2" patch on my arm in two passes. Blade shape is sexy and unlike any grind I have seen. My main reason for getting this knife is the blade height. Although I love my Spydies, all 14 of them, they have very tall blades. This makes them great for downward strokes and push cutting, but not as good for twisting or curving cuts IMO, such as in fruit. One way to think about the Park Avenue is as a very sophisticated SAK. (If only Spyderco made the Worker with a liner lock).

Ergonomics/Liner Lock: After 5 minutes practice, I found the sweet spot which makes this knife easy to open. Although I will be adjusting the pivot tension to be a bit lighter, this knife opens quickly once your thumb remembers how to hit that spot. Liner is nested and springs a full half width across the blade. No play whatsover. The cutout on the RH scale makes for easy access to the liner for closure.

Jewlers Chain/Clip: Felt a little lightweight to me. However, the clip is what it is intended to be, virtually un-noticable. Clipped at the low side of my pocket, a pinch on the clip easily gets the knife out of my pocket. Since this isn't an emergency or self-defense knife, I think it is a great approach. "Hanging" the knife does what Spyderco intended with the clip, it keeps the knife out of the bottom of your pocket so it doesn't mix with change, tokens etc. Hanging the knife also allows it to ride better with sitting and standing.

Overall: I think it is very sucessful at achieving what what intended. It won't substitute for every task, but it is a great EDC for the urban dweller. I plan on carrying the Park Avenue in my right pocket, and then rotate my Native and MOD Hornet as a self-defense, hard cutting knife. I am glad to own this Terzuola design.
 
I got the park avenue in a trade, and was very pleased with it. I'm not a fan of coated blades either, but this one is intended for light duty and was not objectionable at all. The scales remind me of sebenza's titanium in look, which is also nice. The only thing I was worried about was the little "lapel clip" . It turns out to be a nice feature for a knife of this design. It can be worn even with a suit and be presentable while keeping the knife within easy reach and out of your spare change/keys. All these things have been covered, but I wanted to add my .02. Nice little knife.
G.
 
I really like Benchmade knives in general. I think the 690 is great. But, I received one of these from another forumite. When I took it out of the box, it felt to me like something that would have come out of a crackerjack box.

I was really unimpressed. For the money, Benchmade didn't really provide much in this knife. I honestly don't know what they were thinking.. Just my opinion.

;)
 
Originally posted by bob_glassman


I was really unimpressed. For the money, Benchmade didn't really provide much in this knife. I honestly don't know what they were thinking.. Just my opinion.


I know it seems a far cry from the cutting edge (so to speak) Axis Lock folders they are putting out, but I think Benchmade's intention with the 450 was to bring out a no-frills, stripped down gent's folder. Though, stripped down does not necessarily mean that it is lacking in the performance department.

When I first received my 450, I felt that it was too small even for me. Granted, I don't have meathooks (average size, I guess) but it took some time to get used to the small size. I'm used to folders much bigger than this one. But after playing with it for a while I started to come around with it.

Fit and finish is very good and tight, no blade play in any direction. The black boron carbide coating complements the gray anodized handle very well. Overall, a good gent's knife. However, for my tastes I prefer my Osborne 770BC1 if I want to carry a small gents knife.
 
Back
Top