BM555, 10400 and Pacific Salt Reviewed

Joined
May 1, 2004
Messages
1,240
BM555
grp.jpg

After spending most of the summer waking up at 5am to work I was finally able to have some money to purchase some higher quality steel. Since I spend about half the year in Chicago I wanted something for my EDC with a sub-3 inch blade and I have heard nothing but good things about the Griptilian series so I ordered one of the mini-grip 555s from newgraham.com and recieved it about 2 days from my order date.

First Impressions:
-bigger than expected, a very good thing. The handle is beefy and fills my hand very well for a smaller folder.
grip.jpg

-the axis lock is cool. really cool. the button is easy to manipulate and the lock-up feels very solid, one handed closing is smooth and easy.
-the rounded edge on the opening oval doesn't work for me. i found myself missing more often than not so i used a zip-tie and now i can open it a lot easier with wet hands/gloves/etc.
-the checkering on the side of the handle and the finger groves on the top and bottom work well. when i grip the knife it feels like an extension of my hand.
-the pocket clip seats the knife higher than i like and has somewhat of a rough finish but holds the knife very tight, even when hanging partially upside-down above some steam pipes.
grippants.jpg

-the 440C blade came very sharp, it would catch freehanging hairs and shave with little effort. i haven't needed to sharpen it after a week or so of use.
-overall the blade seems very strong. i picked the modified sheepsfoot because i have broken enough tips in my time to know that i need a stronger point.

Actual Use:
-pulling the knife out of my pocket and putting it into action is very fast and intuitive. the blade cuts all manner of things well and over the course of a week on the job i have used it to cut open a thick plastic paint bucket that was dried shut, slice up numerous boxes, cut twine, plastic straps, 3/8 rope and even pry off switchplates that were stuck to the wall.

This knife has been clipped to my left pocket everyday since i bought it and serves well as the people-friendly EDC.

BM10400
pika.jpg

from benchmade's red class i am very suprised by how good this knife is. i ordered it as a throw-away sort of knife to lend out at work and abuse as i saw fit and it has suprised my by holding up very well.

First Impressions:
-same as the mini-grip, the oval hole needed zip ties to work for me.
-opening this knife creates the most euphonious sound, a very loud and solid *CLICK*
-even though the knife has no liners the zytel(iirc) handles feel very solid and have no flex to them.
-the factory grind was uneven on the left side but the knife came sharp enough to shave and the 440C took a very good 20 degree edge on the lansky after about an hour of re-profiling.
-love the low profile pocket clip. i carry this knife on campus clipped to my pocket because so little is exposed that i don't draw any attention.
pikapntas.jpg

-ergos on the knife are good but it's a little to thin to be perfect for me, the pebble texture doesn't really seem to help or hinder my grip. in the future i may just sand it down and stick some skateboard tape on there instead.
-the lock feels very solid and seems to take enough force to disengage that i can't see it accidentally disengaging at all.

Actual Use:
-hard to use with wet hands. i had to grip it so hard that my hand would cramp up after a few cuts.
-cuts very well and held an edge for a lot longer than a 20$ knife should. after reprofiling to 20 degrees the edge still shaves after almost 2 weeks of constant use. resharpening is easy, the burr jumps out after a few strokes and is easy to knock off.
-one handed closing is too risky. i wasn't paying attention and pushed to hard with my index finger while closing one handed and gave myself a pretty nasty slice on my middle finger. tightening the pivot could help this but i don't really need it.
-this knife is strong. my workers used it for things no knife should ever see; screwdriver, chisel, prybar, hammer, etc. and it's still working great. they did manage to knock a big chunk out of the top of the handle when it fell onto a concrete floor from two stories up and broke a little piece of the tip off but it's still sharp and works great.

Pacific Salt
salthand.jpg

i won't lie, i have no real need for this particular knife but i really like the fact that i can tell people my blade doesn't have the ability to rust and i really like the blade shape so i picked up a pacific salt the same time as i got the mini-grip.

First Impressions:
-wow, the blade is a lot bigger than i expected.
-wow, the blade is a lot sharper than i expected. (i cut myself twice within the first 5 mintues of ripping open the package)
-the spyderhole is awesome. the edges are sharp enough to grip perfectly every time but not too sharp to be uncomfortable.
-i like the spyder-drop a little too much.
-the shape of the blade and the handle make this knife feel very secure in my grip.
-the traction grooves on the blade work very well.
-the pocket clip is too high like the mini-grip but i like the little spider and it does what it is supposed to so no real complaints.
saltpants.jpg

-the knife feels like it is a little too easy to close, if the pivot was adjustable i'd have the perfect knife.

Actual Use:
-one handed closing is a very bad idea, same as the 10400. as soon as you trip the lock and put pressure on the blade the blade swings down and comes way to close to cutting off my finger for me to want to do it when i'm distracted.
saltclose.jpg

saltclose2.jpg

-cuts like a laser.
-the H-1 steel holds an edge fairly well and is easy to sharpen.
-i haven't been able to use this knife as much as the other two but so far it has worked great and is my primary EDC.
 
spoonrobot,

I note that you have the same problem that I do with BM's oval opening hole - it would be OK if not for the fact that they chamfer the surface. I have a BM 556, and decided to get a 555 based on my positive experience with the pointier version. I had to sell the 555 solely because I couldn't come anywhere near a 100% successful opening rate -- more like 75-80%.

I tried the mini- and the large Pika out at my local knife store - same deal.

I really wish BM would go back to licensing the round hole from Spyderco, if that is even a possibility any more...

Matthew
 
Fantastic review, spoonrobot!!
And great pics, to boot...

What do you mean by a "spyder-drop" in the Salt review??

Best to you
Tom
 
Normally, you hold on to the handle and flick the blade open...the Spyder drop is the opposite...you hold on to the Spyderhole (blade tip-up) and flick the knife so that the handle flies downward.
i didn't think it would work so well with such a light-handled knife but it does very well because the pivot is so loose.
 
Thanks for the great review. Sounds like you use your knives a lot on the job. Always interesting to see how well products stand up to real use.
 
Cliff Stamp said:
Any comments on the Salt after extended use?

-Cliff

up until two weeks ago when it was replaced by a manix the salt was my edc, quite literally. every single time i left my apartment the salt was clipped to my back pocket.

some comments from the past 5 or so months:

-14mm spyderhole makes it easy to open and easy to close one handed (trip lock with thumb, place index finger in spyderhole and guide blade shut, moving fingers from blade path as warranted.)

-typical lock-back blade play: by no means loose but i can make the blade just barely move up and down if i really jerk it. no side-to-side play at all.

-the hollow grind is frustrating. the edge is so sharp but it will bind when cutting most dense material (foam board, heavier card board, fruit, all manner of plastic, etc.) this was the main reason i switched to the manix.

-no rust made my life very easy for a few months, i work in a restaurant and have submerged the knife in all manner of grease, heavy detergent and other things that make me worry about my manix. the knife has come through unscathed. in addition to this treatment the knife was run through a professional dish machine (150 degree wash and 190 degree rinse cycles) daily for about a week and it functions exactly the same as it did prior to such treatment. no rust, no loose lock, no damage to the handle and no perceptible change in the edge (although it was sharpened nightly after my shift.)

-the knife needed treatment on crock sticks after daily use, at the end of a day of constant use the knife would usually not shave and cut poorly.

-the large handle made the knife feel very secure, my hands were often greasy and dirty when i used the knife but i never worried about it slipping from my grasp of my hand sliding onto the blade. the overall feel of the knife felt very good, i always had a good sense of control and the blade did exactly what i wanted it to do.

-i am ashamed to say it but the knife is a very good at prying. i have used it to pry open clogged drains, a painted-over window and a stuck PC CD player door and nothing has happened to the tip.

-the blade polish scratches very easily, the finish on the blade was very highly polished when new but has been significantly dulled from use.

-the lock always felt secure, due to laziness i found myself using the knife to chop 1" diameter plastic pipe into smaller pieces and even in a pretty solid "white-knuckle grip" the lock was fine. the knife did an okay job chopping the pipe too, two or three good whacks and the blade would chop through. chopping with the knife did feel very awkward though.

-i admit that the knife was never really used "heavily" but it was used constantly and it did perform spectacularly. i feel i have received more than my money's worth.

i've used the knife a lot so if i remember anything else i'll post about it, i'm sure there was some more stuff i didn't like about the knife but i really can't think of much right now.

p.s. Mr. Stamp,
I find your reviews very interesting and informative but for some reason i would like to see more pictures of the knives that get kicked around pretty hard when you are testing them. a side of me really wants to see that chinook II that you tested after it was all busted up. I browse your site fairly often, thanks for the information.
 
On H1 steel corrosion resistance I can say that I carried my Salt I for 10 days in my swimming trunks while fishing and swimming in the Indian Ocean (South Africa). Never rinsed it in fresh water. After the 10 days there was not a blemish or spot on the blade or rest of the knife for that matter.

I now also bought a Pacific Salt - like the size better than the Salt I.
 
spoonrobot said:
i would like to see more pictures of the knives that get kicked around pretty hard
Understandable, pictures are very informative. I also plan to add short digital video clips shortly. Thanks for the detailed info on the Salt.

-Cliff
 
Back
Top